00:00:08 IN THE STANDS ONE NATION UNDER GOD INDIVISIBLE WITH LIBERTY
00:00:12 AND JUSTICE FOR ALL PRESIDENT CLAY LIKE TO TAKE ROLL YES
00:00:17 PLEASE. COMMISSIONER TECCE YES.
00:00:23 >> COMMISSIONER SCOTT YES. COMMISSIONER LIANG HERE
00:00:27 COMMISSIONER YEAR THERE ARE LICENSES EXCUSED VICE PRESIDENT
00:00:31 BENEDICTO YOU'RE PRESENT CLAY YOU HAVE A QUORUM.
00:00:35 ALSO WITH US TONIGHT ARE CHIEF LEW FROM THE SAN FRANCISCO
00:00:36 POLICE DEPARTMENT AND EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR PAUL HENDERSON FROM
00:00:39 THE DEPARTMENT OF POLICE ACCOUNTABILITY.
00:00:40 >> ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU EVERYONE FOR BEING
00:00:42 HERE FOR OUR FEBRUARY 18TH MEETING.
00:00:43 WE WILL BEGIN SERGEANT LINE ITEM ONE GENERAL PUBLIC COMMENT
00:00:47 AT THIS TIME THE PUBLIC IS NOW WELCOME TO ADDRESS THE
00:00:51 COMMISSION FOR UP TO TWO MINUTES ON ITEMS THAT DO NOT
00:00:53 APPEAR ON TONIGHT'S AGENDA BUT ARE WITHIN THE SUBJECT MATTER
00:00:55 JURISDICTION OF THE POLICE COMMISSION UNDER POLICE
00:00:58 COMMISSION RULES OF ORDER DURING PUBLIC COMMENT NEITHER
00:00:59 POLICE OR DPA PERSONNEL NOR COMMISSIONERS ARE REQUIRED TO
00:01:02 RESPOND TO QUESTIONS BY THE PUBLIC BUT MAY PROVIDE A BRIEF
00:01:04 RESPONSE. ALTERNATIVELY YOU MAY SUBMIT
00:01:06 PUBLIC COMMENT IN EITHER OF THE FOLLOWING WAYS EMAIL THE
00:01:09 SECRETARY OF THE POLICE COMMISSION AT SPEED
00:01:11 COMMISSIONERS S.F. BOARD OR WRITTEN COMMENTS MAY BE SENT
00:01:15 VIA US POSTAL SERVICE TO THE PUBLIC SAFETY BUILDING LOCATED
00:01:17 AT 1245 THIRD STREET SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA AT 94158.
00:01:21 IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO MAKE PUBLIC COMMENT PLEASE APPROACH
00:01:23 THE PODIUM AND THERE IS NO PUBLIC COMMENT LINE ITEM TO
00:01:31 CONSENT CALENDAR RECEIVE AND FILE ACTION DPA SUSTAIN
00:01:34 CASE PENDING LAPD CHIEF'S DECISION FOR JANUARY
00:01:37 AND FEBRUARY 2026 MOTION RECEIVED FILED SECOND OR SECOND
00:01:48 RIGHT IF ANY MEMBER OF THE PUBLIC WOULD LIKE TO MAKE
00:01:52 PUBLIC COMMENT REGARDING LINE ITEM TWO PLEASE APPROACH THE
00:01:54 PODIUM. >> THERE IS NO PUBLIC COMMENT
00:01:56 ON THE MOTION. COMMISSIONER TECCE HOW DO YOU
00:02:00 VOTE? YES MR. TECCE IS YES
00:02:00 COMMISSIONER SCOTT YES. COMMISSIONER SCOTT IS YES.
00:02:04 COMMISSIONER LEONE YES. MICHELLE YOUNG IS YES
00:02:05 COMMISSIONER YOU YES COMMISSIONER.
00:02:08 YES. YES.
00:02:08 VICE PRESIDENT BENEDICTO YES MY PRESENT BENEDICTO IS YES
00:02:11 AND PRESIDENT CLAY PRESENT CLAY IS YES.
00:02:12 YOU HAVE SIX YESES LIGHT ON THREE CHIEFS REPORT WEEKLY
00:02:15 CRIME TRENDS AND PUBLIC SAFETY CONCERNS PROVIDE AN OVERVIEW OF
00:02:18 OFFENSES, INCIDENTS OR EVENTS OCCURRING IN SAN FRANCISCO
00:02:21 HAVING AN IMPACT ON PUBLIC SAFETY CHIEF LUKE GOOD EVENING
00:02:24 PRESIDENT CLAY VICE PRESIDENT BENEDICTO COMMISSIONERS
00:02:28 AND DIRECTOR HENDERSON. I'LL START OFF WITH A SUMMARY
00:02:32 OF THE WEEKLY CRIME TRENDS OVERALL PART ONE CRIMES DOWN
00:02:36 34% YEAR TO DATE COMPARED TO 2025 TOTAL VIOLENT CRIMES ARE
00:02:41 DOWN 26% FOR THE YEAR. AS FAR AS HOMICIDES THERE HAVE
00:02:45 BEEN SIX HOMICIDES YEAR TO DATE IN 2026 COMPARED TO 1 IN 2025.
00:02:51 LOOKING AT GUN VIOLENCE WHICH IS DEFINED AS THE NUMBER OF
00:02:55 PEOPLE INJURED IN A SHOOTING INCIDENT ADDED TO THE NUMBER OF
00:02:56 PERSONS KILLED BY A FIREARM WE ARE DOWN 11% COMPARED TO 2025
00:03:01 INCIDENTS OF REPORTED RAPES WHICH INCLUDES ATTEMPTED
00:03:05 AND FORCIBLE RAPES ARE DOWN 14%.
00:03:08 THAT'S YEAR OVER YEAR WEEK OVER WEEK WE DO HAVE AN INCREASE OF
00:03:12 FOUR VERSUS ONE. I DID LOOK TAKE A LOOK AT SOME
00:03:19 OF THOSE. ONE DID LEAD TO AN ARREST
00:03:20 AND THEN THE OTHERS WERE REGARDING SEXUAL ASSAULTS THAT
00:03:26 WERE REPORTED. IT LOOKS LIKE AT LEAST FROM
00:03:29 INCIDENTS THAT OCCURRED GREATER THAN A YEAR AGO, ASSAULTS FOR
00:03:36 THE YEAR DOWN 25% WITH A DECREASE OF 41% IN ASSAULTS BY
00:03:41 FIREARM WEEK OVER WEEK THERE WAS AN INCREASE 41 VERSUS 29.
00:03:47 JUST A QUICK LOOK AT THAT. IT REVEALED THAT THERE WERE AT
00:03:52 LEAST IT LOOKS LIKE 17 ASSAULTS ON FEBRUARY NINTH WHICH WOULD
00:03:58 EQUATE TO ABOUT 41% OF THOSE NUMBERS OCCURRING ON ONE DAY.
00:04:03 JUST ANECDOTALLY I THINK I HAVEN'T LOOKED AT EVERY SINGLE
00:04:07 ONE BUT POTENTIALLY THOSE WOULD BE ASSAULTS THAT THAT CAME UP
00:04:11 DUE TO SUPER BOWL FESTIVITIES. A LOT OF BARS AND CLUBS WITH
00:04:15 ACTIVITIES ROBBERIES DOWN 33% WITH ROBBERIES USING A FIREARM
00:04:22 DECLINING BY 52%. HUMAN TRAFFICKING INCIDENTS UP
00:04:26 25% WITH FIVE INCIDENTS BEING REPORTED SO FAR THIS YEAR
00:04:29 COMPARED TO FOUR LAST YEAR AT THIS TIME.
00:04:31 TOTAL PROPERTY CRIMES DOWN 35%, BURGLARIES DOWN 43%.
00:04:36 MOTOR VEHICLE THEFTS DOWN 39%. LARCENY, WHICH INCLUDES VEHICLE
00:04:43 BURGLARIES ARE DOWN 32% OVERALL AND LOOKING SPECIFICALLY AT
00:04:46 AUTO BURGLARIES, IT'S A 39% DECREASE OVER 2025.
00:04:51 >> OKAY. DRILLING DOWN INTO THE
00:04:56 HOMICIDES AND SHOOTINGS, THERE WERE TWO HOMICIDE INCIDENTS
00:04:59 REPORTED DURING THIS REPORTING PERIOD WHICH WERE PREVIOUSLY
00:05:03 BRIEFED AT THE LAST COMMISSION MEETING.
00:05:06 BUT I'LL GO OVER THOSE AGAIN. THERE ARE SIX HOMICIDES YEAR TO
00:05:10 DATE WITH FOUR RESULTING FROM A FIREARM.
00:05:13 THREE TOTAL HOMICIDES IN FEBRUARY AND OUR OVERALL
00:05:16 CLEARANCE RATE FOR 2026 IS AT 167%.
00:05:19 IN TERMS OF SHOOTINGS, THERE WERE FOUR NON-FATAL FIREARM
00:05:23 RELATED SHOOTING INCIDENTS CAUSING INJURIES TO FOUR
00:05:27 VICTIMS THIS WEEK ENDING IN ENDING TO 15.
00:05:30 SO JUST DRILLING DOWN INTO THE NON-FATAL SHOOTINGS, I REPORTED
00:05:38 ON THIS ONE LAST WEEK BUT ON TWO NINE AT APPROXIMATELY ZERO
00:05:43 400 HOURS 1700 BLOCK OF MISSION THAT WAS RELATED TO THE 49 ERS
00:05:47 PLAYER INCIDENT OFFICERS RESPONDED TO THAT ADDRESS
00:05:55 AND THEY LOCATED A VICTIM THAT HAD SUSTAINED A GUNSHOT WOUND.
00:05:59 THERE HAS BEEN NO ARREST IN THAT CASE AND IT IS AN OPEN
00:06:03 INVESTIGATION. ON 214 AT APPROXIMATELY 1:39
00:06:09 A.M. 1200 BLOCK OF POLK OFFICERS RESPONDED TO THE CALL
00:06:13 OF A SHOOTING. THEY DID FIND THE VICTIM WHO
00:06:17 WAS LATER TRANSPORTED IN SERIOUS CONDITION.
00:06:21 NO ARREST OPENED INVESTIGATION ON ON 215 AT APPROXIMATELY 4:43
00:06:29 A.M. AT FIFTH AND WELSH IN THE SOUTHERN.
00:06:32 OFFICERS RESPONDED TO A SHOOTING.
00:06:36 THEY LOCATED A VICTIM SUFFERING FROM A GUNSHOT WOUND.
00:06:40 THEY WERE TRANSPORTED IN CRITICAL CONDITION
00:06:41 AND THAT'S CURRENTLY A OPEN INVESTIGATION.
00:06:44 NO ARREST. AND ALSO ON 215 AT ZERO SIX 27
00:06:51 HOURS ON THE 1200 BLOCK OF BUCHANAN, A VICTIM WAS SELF
00:06:57 TRANSPORTED OR SELF TRANSPORTED TO THE HOSPITAL WITH A GUNSHOT
00:07:02 WOUND AND DID NOT PROVIDE ANY INFORMATION TO POLICE.
00:07:06 IT'S CURRENTLY AN OPEN INVESTIGATION WITH NO ARREST.
00:07:09 SO I WENT OVER FOR NON-FATAL SHOOTINGS.
00:07:13 BUT JUST A REMINDER. YEAR TO DATE WE'RE STILL DOWN
00:07:16 31% YEAR TO DATE 11 VERSUS 16 IN TERMS OF NON-FATAL SHOOTING
00:07:19 INCIDENTS GOING OVER THE HOMICIDES.
00:07:26 AGAIN, WHICH I BRIEFED LAST WEEK ON MONDAY FEBRUARY 9TH
00:07:33 IN THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT, OFFICERS RESPONDED AREA OF
00:07:38 HARRISON AND SECOND STREETS SORRY SECOND STREET.
00:07:44 THEY LOCATED A VICTIM DESPITE LIFESAVING EFFORTS.
00:07:47 THE VICTIM WAS DECLARED DECEASED AT THE HOSPITAL.
00:07:51 IT'S AN OPEN AND ONGOING INVESTIGATION.
00:07:52 NO ARRESTS ON THAT YET. >> ON FEBRUARY 11TH, 2026 AT
00:08:00 APPROXIMATELY 8:55 A.M., OFFICERS RESPONDED TO THE SCENE
00:08:03 OF 100 THE 100 BLOCK OF TURK REGARDING A SHOOTING.
00:08:06 THEY DID LOCATE A VICTIM WHO WAS DECLARED DECEASED ON SCENE.
00:08:11 AN ARREST WAS MADE SHORTLY THEREAFTER.
00:08:15 HOWEVER, IT'S STILL AN OPEN INVESTIGATION AND MOVING ON TO
00:08:21 A NOTABLE ARRESTS. ON FEBRUARY 12TH A MALE SUBJECT
00:08:28 ENTERED A BANK ON 300 BLOCK OF CALIFORNIA STREET.
00:08:32 DEMANDED MONEY FROM AN EMPLOYEE.
00:08:33 IT WAS A FAILED ATTEMPT AND THE SUBJECT FLED FROM THE BANK.
00:08:36 RESPONDING OFFICERS SEARCHED THE AREA WITH NEGATIVE RESULTS.
00:08:40 THE NEXT DAY ON THE 13TH AS A PD RECEIVED A REPORT THAT
00:08:46 ANOTHER UNKNOWN MALE ENTERED A BUSINESS ON THE UNIT BLOCK OF
00:08:51 MONTGOMERY STREET AND THREATENED STAFF MEMBERS
00:08:52 EMPLOYEES SHOWED THE OFFICERS AN IMAGE OF THE SUBJECT WHO THE
00:08:56 OFFICERS THEN RECOGNIZED AS SUBJECT FROM THE PREVIOUS
00:09:00 ATTEMPTED ATTEMPTED ROBBERY OF THE BANK THE DAY BEFORE.
00:09:03 AND THE OFFICERS LOCATED THE SUSPECT ON THE UNIT BLOCK OF
00:09:06 FOURTH STREET AND TOOK HIM INTO CUSTODY.
00:09:09 SO GREAT WORK BY THE OFFICERS AND ALSO GREAT ASSISTANCE FROM
00:09:14 THE PUBLIC. JUST AGAIN, ANECDOTALLY
00:09:17 SPEAKING WE SEEM TO BE GETTING A LITTLE BIT MORE COMMUNITY
00:09:21 PARTICIPATION JUST IN TERMS OF BEING CALLING AND REPORTING
00:09:25 AND THEN BEING WITNESSES OR AND OR PROVIDING NECESSARY OR
00:09:30 VITAL VIDEO EVIDENCE AND WHATNOT TO MAKE CASES
00:09:34 HAPPEN. >> JUST AN UPDATE ON GUN
00:09:40 SEIZURES FOR THE YEAR. WE'VE SEIZED 137 FIREARMS
00:09:44 VERSUS 124 SAME TIME LAST YEAR .
00:09:55 >> AND AN UPDATE ON THE ACADEMY.
00:09:58 WE CURRENTLY HAVE 74 RECRUIT OFFICERS IN THE ACADEMY AND WE
00:10:03 HAVE ANOTHER ACADEMY STARTING ON MARCH 2ND.
00:10:07 AND THEN YESTERDAY WE GRADUATED THE LARGEST LATERAL CLASS
00:10:11 IN TEN PLUS YEARS. THAT CONSISTED OF NINE LATERALS
00:10:17 ,THREE SPECIAL EVENT OFFICERS AND ONE RESERVE OFFICER.
00:10:18 SO IT WAS A VERY GOOD DAY FOR US YESTERDAY.
00:10:25 >> AND THAT CONCLUDES MY REPORT.
00:10:26 SO CHIEF, IS THERE ANY CORRELATION BETWEEN THE DRUG
00:10:29 ARRESTS AND THE REDUCTION IN THE PROPERTY CRIMES?
00:10:35 >> IT'S IT'S YOU KNOW, IT'S HARD TO SAY.
00:10:39 I WOULD LIKE TO THINK SO. BUT NORMALLY WE SPEAK ABOUT THE
00:10:43 ECOSYSTEM OF DRUG USER POPULATION STEALING IN ORDER TO
00:10:51 FINANCE THEIR THEIR DRUG HABIT AND THEN THAT MONEY THEN GOES
00:10:55 TO DRUG DEALERS. BUT THAT GETS SOLD ON THE DRUG.
00:10:59 SORRY THE THE STOLEN PROPERTY GETS SOLD ON A BLACK MARKET OR
00:11:03 ILLEGAL VENDING. >> SO THAT'S ALL THE THE ENTIRE
00:11:06 ECOSYSTEM IS BEING WORKED ON BY OUR FOLKS AT DIMOCK.
00:11:10 IT'S HARD TO SAY EXACTLY WHAT WHAT THE CORRELATION IS OR IF
00:11:14 THERE IS THE CORRELATION. BUT I THINK THAT WE WORK ON ALL
00:11:18 FRONTS OF THAT ECOSYSTEM TO COMBAT DRUG DEALING, THE OPEN
00:11:22 AIR DRUG USE. BUT THEN WE ALSO WORK ON
00:11:26 ILLEGAL VENDING AND THEN ORGANIZE RETAIL THEFT AS WELL.
00:11:29 >> SO ALL OF THE THINGS IN COMBINATION I THINK LOWER
00:11:31 THE NUMBERS. IT'S IT'S A GOOD REPORT TO
00:11:34 CONTINUE. WE SEE CRIME IS GOING DOWN OR
00:11:36 STAYING NEGATIVE. SO THAT'S A GOOD REPORT.
00:11:37 THANK YOU. YOU COMMISSIONER YOU THANK YOU
00:11:40 VERY MUCH. >> PRESIDENT CLAY AND I JUST
00:11:44 GOT A QUESTION LOOKING AT THE DATA FOR HOMICIDE, IT'S GONE UP
00:11:51 A SUBSTANTIAL 500 AND I'M JUST SEEING IF THERE'S ANY THOUGHT
00:11:55 PUT INTO IT BECAUSE IF YOU CONTINUE THIS TREND YOU'LL
00:11:59 PROBABLY BE CLOSE TO 80 TO 80 HOMICIDE IN A YEAR OF THIS.
00:12:06 JUST CURIOUS, IS THIS AN ANOMALY OR IT IS THIS YOU KNOW,
00:12:09 HAPPENING BECAUSE WE JUST SUPER BOWL OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT
00:12:14 COME AND DO SO JUST NOW. >> I WONDER WHAT YOUR THOUGHTS
00:12:17 ARE, CHIEF? YEAH, I THINK A COUPLE OF
00:12:18 THINGS. NUMBER ONE, I WOULD SAY THAT
00:12:20 JUST LOOKING ACROSS THE HOMICIDE THERE'S NO CORRELATION
00:12:25 OR BETWEEN THEM SO WE DON'T FEEL LIKE IT'S A IT'S ANYTHING
00:12:29 LIKE A SERIAL ISSUE. THEY'RE ALL INDEPENDENT
00:12:32 INVESTIGATIONS AND I THINK THE OTHER THE OTHER PART TO THINK
00:12:36 ABOUT IS THAT OUR NUMBERS TYPICALLY IT'S NOT A STRAIGHT
00:12:41 LINE SO WE'LL GET WE'LL GET PEAKS AND WE'LL GET VALLEYS
00:12:44 AND IN THE END IT AVERAGES OUT .
00:12:48 SO IT'S SOMETHING THAT WE CONSTANTLY LOOK FOR ESPECIALLY
00:12:51 IF IT'S, YOU KNOW, INCIDENTS THAT WE THINK WOULD BE
00:12:56 RETALIATORY IN NATURE OR HAVE THAT COMPONENT.
00:13:00 AND SO WHEN WE SEE THOSE WE WORK VERY DILIGENTLY TO TRY TO,
00:13:03 YOU KNOW, KEEP A LID ON THOSE SITUATIONS AND WORK WITH A LOT
00:13:08 OF PARTNERS LIKE STREET VIOLENCE PARTNERS YOU KNOW, WE
00:13:11 HAVE A PRETTY ROBUST SHOOTING REVIEW PROCESS THAT WE'VE BEEN
00:13:20 THAT WE'VE IMPLEMENTED OVER THE YEARS WHERE WE TAKE A DEEP DIVE
00:13:21 AND LOOK AT EVERY SINGLE SHOOTING EVENT AND FIGURE OUT
00:13:26 WHY THAT MAY HAVE HAPPENED AND THEN THINK ABOUT ANY
00:13:30 COMPONENT SO THAT WE CAN EITHER HANDLE OURSELVES OR WORK WITH
00:13:35 PARTNERS TO BE ABLE TO GO AND DEAL WITH.
00:13:40 >> I ALSO WANT TO THANK YOU AT THE DEPARTMENT AND I GUESS THE
00:13:46 COMMANDS THAT I MEAN OFFICERS OUT ON THE STREETS TAKING DOWN
00:13:49 OR TAKING OFF 137 THE FIREARMS COMPARED TO 124 THAT'S YOU KNOW
00:13:56 THAT'S A LOT OF GUNS OUT THERE. >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH, THE
00:14:01 CHIEF. THANK YOU, MR. SCOTT.
00:14:03 THANK YOU, CHIEF, FOR THAT REPORT.
00:14:07 >> YOU MENTIONED THERE WERE FOUR NON-FATAL HOMICIDES AND A
00:14:11 TOTAL FOR FEBRUARY'S IS I MAY HAVE MISHEARD.
00:14:14 I THOUGHT IT SAID SIX TOTAL OF SIX FOR THE YEAR OF SIX FOR THE
00:14:21 YEAR FOR THE YEAR. >> SO FOR THE FOUR TOTAL
00:14:25 NON-FATAL SHOOTINGS TOTAL NON-FATAL SHOOTING INCIDENTS
00:14:29 FOR THE YEAR IS 11 VERSUS 16 LAST YEAR ON A TOTAL HOMICIDES
00:14:35 FOR THE YEAR IS SIX. >> YES.
00:14:36 OKAY. THAT'S VERY I MEAN ONE HOMICIDE
00:14:40 IS TOO MANY BUT THAT WE HAVE DEFINITELY LOWERED THE HOMICIDE
00:14:44 RATE IN THE CITY. I ALSO WANT TO X THE IT SEEMS
00:14:51 TO BE THE YOU FOR ME I'M JUST THINKING THE MAJORITY OF THE
00:14:58 WEAPONS THAT WERE RETRIEVED YOU SAID 137 YEAH.
00:15:01 >> LET ME MAKE SURE THAT'S RIGHT ONE 37 CORRECT.
00:15:05 >> OKAY. WAS ANY OF THEM THE MAJORITY OF
00:15:08 THOSE GUNS GOES GOES GOES UP AND I KNOW THAT'S WHY WE HAVE
00:15:16 SEEING ALL THESE SHOOTINGS ARE NOT JUST HERE IN BUT ALL OVER
00:15:20 THE BE AROUND THE COUNTRY BECAUSE THOSE GUNS HAVE NOW
00:15:24 QUADRUPLE BECAUSE YOU CAN GO ONLINE AND GET THE KIT
00:15:28 AND ASSEMBLE IT SO I JUST WANT TO WE'RE KEEPING TRACK OF THAT
00:15:31 MAJORITY OF THE WEAPONS OR THE GOLD GUNS OR THE OTHER
00:15:35 FIREARMS. >> SO I DON'T HAVE THAT
00:15:36 SPECIFIC BREAKDOWN RIGHT NOW. BUT I DO KNOW THAT JUST FROM MY
00:15:41 ,YOU KNOW, LONGSTANDING WORK IN GUN VIOLENCE THAT THAT IT WE
00:15:48 DO RECOVER A LOT OF GHOST GUNS .
00:15:52 I DON'T HAVE THAT NUMBER WITH ME RIGHT OKAY FOR THIS FOR THIS
00:15:53 DAY BUT I DO I DO I CAN TELL YOU THAT TYPICALLY THE MAJORITY
00:15:58 ARE NOT GHOST GUNS BUT IT'S A SIGNIFICANT MATERIAL PERCENTAGE
00:16:00 THAT ARE OKAY. >> THANK YOU, COMMISSIONER
00:16:03 YOUNG THANK YOU. PRESIDENT CLAY JUST TO FOLLOW
00:16:07 UP ON COMMISSIONER YEE'S QUESTION ABOUT HOMICIDES, HOW
00:16:11 MANY HAVE BEEN CLOSED OF THE SIX FIVE.
00:16:14 SO THAT'S A PRETTY GOOD PERCENTAGE.
00:16:15 DO YOU KNOW WHAT THE CLOSURE RATE FOR SHOOTINGS ARE?
00:16:18 >> NO, I DON'T HAVE THAT WITH ME.
00:16:21 OKAY. I CAN GET THAT FOR YOU.
00:16:22 NO, THANK YOU. THANK YOU, CHIEF.
00:16:25 WELCOME. IF ANY MEMBER OF THE PUBLIC
00:16:32 WOULD LIKE TO MAKE PUBLIC COMMENT REGARDING LINE ITEM
00:16:33 THREE CHIEFS REPORT, PLEASE APPROACH THE PODIUM AND THERE'S
00:16:36 NO PUBLIC COMMENT LINE ITEM FOR DEEP A DIRECTOR'S REPORT
00:16:41 DISCUSSION A REPORT ON RECENT ACTIVITIES AND ANNOUNCEMENTS.
00:16:44 EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR HENDERSON THANK YOU.
00:16:49 I HAVE A SHORT REPORT THIS WEEK MOST OF OUR TIME HAS BEEN SPENT
00:16:56 WORKING WITH BUDGET THE DEPARTMENTAL PHASE OF THE 2026
00:17:03 2027 BUDGET PROCESS CONCLUDES THIS WEEK.
00:17:04 SO WE'VE BEEN VERY BUSY WORKING ON THAT.
00:17:11 WE SPENT WE JUST FINISHED OUR TWO PUBLIC MEETINGS INCLUDING
00:17:15 THE ONE PRESENTED HERE AT THE COMMISSION BUT WE'VE ALSO HAD
00:17:18 AN INTERNAL MEETING FOR OUR STAFF TO WALK THEM THROUGH THE
00:17:22 BUDGET AS WELL AS SOME OF THE RESULTS FROM THAT ARE HERE WE
00:17:26 WERE ALLOWED TO REPLACE OUR POLICY POSITION THAT WAS A VERY
00:17:33 IMPORTANT POSITION HAD DPA AND SO THE OUR NEWEST EMPLOYEE
00:17:37 HASN'T STARTED YET BUT HE IS HERE TODAY JUST TO INTRODUCE
00:17:42 HIMSELF JAMAL ANDERSON WHO'S AT TODAY'S COMMISSION AND WE ARE
00:17:49 CONTINUING TO WORK WITH THE MAYOR'S OFFICE CLOSELY TO MAKE
00:17:51 SURE THAT OUR OPERATIONS AND BUDGET CONTINUES TO BE A
00:17:53 PRIORITY FOR THE OFFICE AND FOR THE REST OF THE CITY.
00:17:58 WE'RE ALSO CONTINUING AND WRAPPING UP OUR COURT
00:18:01 HEARINGS AND THAT'S THE MOST OF OUR TECHNOLOGY STAFF AND I'VE
00:18:05 BEEN TALKING ABOUT A LITTLE BIT WITH THE BUDGET AND OUR
00:18:09 PERFORMANCE WE PRESENTED TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON THOSE PROCESSES
00:18:13 WITH THE DIGITALIZATION PROJECT THAT WE'VE BEEN HAVING.
00:18:20 EVERY OTHER DEPARTMENT HAS IT. IT'S JUST PARTICULARLY RELEVANT
00:18:24 FOR DPA BECAUSE OUR RECORDS GO BACK TO THE 80S AND THIS IS THE
00:18:25 PROCESS OF DIGITALIZING OUR WORK SO IT'S MORE ASSESSABLE,
00:18:32 IT'S MANDATED BUT THAT'S HAPPENING RIGHT NOW.
00:18:36 OUR UPDATE ON THAT WAS WELL RECEIVED ENOUGH SO THAT DBA IS
00:18:40 GOING TO BE FEATURED AS A SUCCESS STORY FOR THE
00:18:43 SUBCOMMITTEE, FOR THE PROJECT FOR THE REST OF THE CITY.
00:18:44 LIKE I SAID, OURS IS A LOT MORE VOLUMINOUS THAN A LOT OF OTHER
00:18:48 DEPARTMENTS. >> OUR RECORDS GO BACK TO THE
00:18:51 80S AND INCLUDE THINGS THAT HAVE BEEN AND BOXES THAT WE'VE
00:18:55 HAD TO STORE AT EXORBITANT COSTS PARTICULARLY WITH SOME OF
00:18:59 THE MORE CHALLENGING DOCUMENTS THAT AREN'T EASILY DIGITIZED
00:19:06 HANDWRITTEN NOTES, TAPES, THOSE KINDS OF THINGS THAT ARE
00:19:11 HAPPENING. I'LL KEEP YOU UPDATED
00:19:12 PARTICULARLY NOW THAT WE'RE GOING TO BE FEATURED FROM THE
00:19:14 CITY FROM THE DEPARTMENT IN TERMS OF WHAT WE'RE DOING.
00:19:18 >> WE'VE HAD 17 CASES OPEN SINCE THE LAST COMMISSION
00:19:22 MEETING AND WE'VE CLOSED EIGHT CASES.
00:19:23 THE VOLUME OF COMPLAINTS NOW HAS JUST DIPPED BUT OUR CASE
00:19:29 NUMBER IN TERMS OF OPEN CASES ARE STILL HIGH DUE TO THE
00:19:34 VOLUME THAT WE'VE HAD OVER THE PAST YEAR IN TERMS OF THE
00:19:37 NUMBER OF COMPLAINTS THAT ARE COMING IN, THAT NUMBER IS 209.
00:19:39 SO FAR FOR 2026 WE'VE OPENED 109 CASES.
00:19:45 AS I SAID BEFORE, THERE ARE 209 CASES THAT ARE OPEN AND UNDER
00:19:48 INVESTIGATION RIGHT NOW. WE'VE SUSTAINED TWO CASES THIS
00:19:51 YEAR AND TWO CASES HAVE BEEN MEDIATE AND THERE ARE 12 CASES
00:19:56 THAT HAVE WHOSE INVESTIGATIONS HAVE GONE BEYOND THE 270 DAY
00:20:02 INVESTIGATION. ALL 12 OF THOSE CASES ARE TOLD
00:20:05 CASES AND THOSE COULD BE FOR ANY NUMBER OF REASONS.
00:20:09 TYPICALLY IT'S BECAUSE CASES HAVE CIVIL AND OR CRIMINAL
00:20:12 CASES CONCURRENT WHICH SUSPEND THE TOLLING TIME.
00:20:16 BUT FOR THE RECORD, THE 3304 DEADLINE HAS NOT BEEN MISSED
00:20:20 FOR OVER SEVEN YEARS NOW AND WE WILL CONTINUE TO MONITOR THOSE
00:20:26 CASES. >> THERE ARE 66 CASES THAT WERE
00:20:30 SUSTAINED BY DPA THAT ARE PENDING WITH THE POLICE
00:20:34 DEPARTMENT AND THERE ARE TWO CASES PENDING WITH THE POLICE
00:20:38 COMMISSION CURRENTLY AGAIN, THE FULL BREAKDOWN OF THESE CASES
00:20:43 AT A MACRO LEVEL IS IN THE REPORTS PRESENTED AND ALSO
00:20:46 AVAILABLE ONLINE IF PEOPLE WANT TO HEAR THOSE RECORDS I AM HERE
00:20:53 ALSO TODAY AND TODAY'S COMMISSION WITH SHARON WU WHO'S
00:20:58 GOING TO BE REPORTING ON AGENDA ITEM SEVEN.
00:21:02 SO I RESERVE MY COMMENTS THERE ALSO OUR SENIOR INVESTIGATOR IS
00:21:09 HERE AS WELL, CHRIS CHISNALL IS HERE IN CASE ISSUES COME UP
00:21:14 DURING THE MEETING WHERE PEOPLE NEED TO IN THE FUTURE PEOPLE
00:21:17 CAN CONTACT US DIRECTLY AT SFO FOR ITS LAST DAY OR CAN CONTACT
00:21:24 THE OFFICE DIRECTLY AT 41524 17711.
00:21:26 THAT CONCLUDES MY REPORT AND I WILL RESERVE COMMENTS FOR THE
00:21:30 LATER AGENDA ITEMS WHERE WE HAVE FOLKS IN THE AUDIENCE TO
00:21:32 BE PRESENTING. >> MR. BENEDETTO THANK YOU.
00:21:38 PRESIDENT CLAY THANK YOU FOR THAT REPORT.
00:21:39 DIRECTOR HENDERSON JUST A COUPLE OF QUESTIONS.
00:21:42 I KNOW YOU MENTIONED THAT YOU'RE JOINED BY YOUR STAFFERS
00:21:46 AS YOU TAKING OVER THE POLICY ROLE, CORRECT?
00:21:48 I WELCOME MR. ANDERSON. LOOKING FORWARD TO WORKING WITH
00:21:50 YOU. I HOPE WE DON'T SCARE YOU OFF.
00:21:53 >> THAT WAS A DEAL. THERE'S BEEN A RESTRICTION, AS
00:21:57 YOU KNOW ON HIRING FOR ALMOST A YEAR NOW AND SO BEING ABLE TO
00:22:01 REPLACE THAT POSITION WAS TRICKY COMPLICATED BUT IT'S
00:22:08 IT'S A VERY IMPORTANT ROLE FOR DPA.
00:22:09 SO IT'S A BIG DEAL WHICH IS WHY I JUST WANTED TO MAKE SURE THAT
00:22:13 HE WAS HERE AND YOU GUYS GOT A CHANCE TO KNOW WHO HE WAS
00:22:16 ABSOLUTELY. I ALSO WANTED TO ASK YOU YOU
00:22:20 MENTIONED THAT THE CASES THAT ARE PENDING WITH THE CHIEF I
00:22:23 THINK YOU SAID 66 WAS THAT THE NUMBER THAT IS THE LOWEST THAT
00:22:25 HAS BEEN AND 66 PENDING BUT THAT IS THE LOWEST IT'S BEEN
00:22:33 AND I WOULD SAY AT LEAST TWO, THREE YEARS, MAYBE EVEN LONGER.
00:22:36 THE NUMBERS ARE GOING DOWN. >> YEAH, THAT'S THAT'S WHAT I
00:22:40 WAS GOING TO I KNOW THAT TOWARDS THE END OF CHIEF GOT
00:22:43 TENURE IN THROUGH INTERIM CHIEF YOU HAVE TENURE WE IDENTIFIED
00:22:47 YOU KNOW AREAS IN WHICH TO TRY AND REDUCE THE BACKLOG OF CASES
00:22:51 AND THERE WAS AN EXPANSION OF CHIEF'S HEARING TO WAS A
00:22:55 COMMANDERS CHIEF WHO WERE AT IT.
00:22:56 YES. SO HOW IS THAT PROCESS?
00:22:58 >> IT SOUNDS LIKE IT'S WORKING EITHER PARTY.
00:23:00 HOW HAS THAT PROCESS BEEN TO REDUCE THE BACKLOG OF CASES
00:23:03 AWAITING CHIEF'S DECISION AT LEAST ON MY END JUST
00:23:06 IN MONITORING THOSE NUMBERS, EVEN WITH THE TRANSITION OF
00:23:09 BILL SCOTT LEAVING PAUL YEP, COMING IN AND THE NEW CHIEF
00:23:11 COMING IN WHATEVER THAT STRUCTURE IS THE NUMBERS ARE
00:23:15 GOING DOWN AND EVERY MONTH WE'RE SEEING THE NUMBERS GO
00:23:18 DOWN IN TERMS OF THOSE CASES BEING RESOLVED AND THAT'S I
00:23:21 THINK THAT'S THE POINT OF HAVING ME REPORT OUT ON THOSE
00:23:25 NUMBERS. THE CHIEF IS PROBABLY IN A
00:23:26 BETTER POSITION TO ARTICULATE WHAT'S HAPPENING INTERNALLY
00:23:30 IN TERMS OF HOW THOSE NUMBERS ARE GOING DOWN OR WHAT THE NEW
00:23:32 SYSTEM IS. >> THANK YOU, CHIEF.
00:23:33 YEAH, I WOULD JUST SAY IT'S WORKING QUITE WELL FOR US RIGHT
00:23:37 NOW. WE HAVE WE'RE FULLY STAFFED UP
00:23:40 AS FAR AS THE DEPUTY CHIEFS AND COMMANDERS WHEREAS WE HAD
00:23:44 SOME PEOPLE OUT BEFORE. SO THAT'S REALLY HELPING WITH
00:23:47 THE BACKLOG. >> SO I THINK THE SYSTEM IS
00:23:48 WORKING QUITE WELL NOW. >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:23:52 THOSE ARE ALL MY QUESTIONS. YOU ALSO SEE A SUMMARY OF THOSE
00:23:56 OUTCOMES IN OUR ANNUAL REPORT AND NOW WE HAVE A SCHEDULE WE
00:23:59 STARTED AT THE END OF 2025 BUT STARTING THROUGH 2026 YOU'LL BE
00:24:05 ABLE TO TRACK THAT SCHEDULE FOR OUR ANNUAL REPORT AND QUARTERLY
00:24:07 REPORTS ON A MORE REGULAR BASIS THAT WILL HAVE THE RESULTS
00:24:09 AND THE COMPARISONS WITH THE CHARTS AND THE SAME WAYS THAT
00:24:13 YOU'VE SEEN IN THE PAST FOR THE RESULTS OF THOSE HEARINGS.
00:24:16 >> THANK YOU. ARE THE FINAL DETERMINATIONS.
00:24:17 SURE. IF ANY MEMBER OF THE PUBLIC
00:24:23 WOULD LIKE TO MAKE PUBLIC COMMENT REGARDING LINE ITEM
00:24:25 FOUR PLEASE APPROACH THE PODIUM .
00:24:29 THERE IS NO PUBLIC COMMENT LINE ITEM FIVE COMMISSION REPORTS
00:24:33 DISCUSSION AND POSSIBLE ACTION COMMISSION PRESIDENTS REPORT
00:24:36 COMMISSIONERS REPORTS AND COMMISSION ANNOUNCEMENTS
00:24:37 AND SCHEDULING OF ITEMS IDENTIFIED FOR CONSIDERATION AT
00:24:40 A FUTURE COMMISSION MEETING. WELL I HAD THE WONDERFUL
00:24:44 OPPORTUNITY TODAY TO BE ACCOMPANIED BY SERGEANT
00:24:46 REYNOLDS IN SUCH A YOUNG BUT WHO ARRANGED FOR ME TO GO OUT
00:24:49 TO THE ACADEMY TO VISIT IT. AND I'LL TELL YOU WHAT A GREAT
00:24:52 TOUR I GOT IN TO TO MEET THE PEOPLE OUT THERE WHO ARE
00:24:56 EDUCATING THESE CADETS THE SET UP OUT THERE I GOT TO SEE A
00:25:01 GROUP OF THE SMALLER CLASS THAT WAS IN THE LARGER CLASS WAS OUT
00:25:07 HAVE AT THE RANGE SHOOTING BUT TO SEE THE FACILITIES AND HOW
00:25:10 THEY PULL IT OFF. NOW ALL OF US HAVE BEEN TO THE
00:25:12 GRADUATION SO WE'VE SEEN THE VIDEOS AND YOU SEE THESE CAMEOS
00:25:15 BUT YOU DON'T REALLY YOU SAY HOW DID THEY DO THIS?
00:25:18 WHERE IS IT SET? IT'S A VERY TIGHT SQUEEZE FOR
00:25:21 THEM TO BE SO INNOVATIVE TO DO IT AND PULL IT OFF AND HOW YOU
00:25:23 GET THE SENSE OF FEELING NOW WHEN YOU'RE SITTING BACK LIKE
00:25:26 YOU'RE WATCHING A MOVIE BUT THEN YOU'RE ON THE SET AND YOU
00:25:30 SEE IT AND GO OH MY GOD, LOOK AT THIS.
00:25:33 HOW DID THEY FEEL? BUT IT'S REALLY WAS A GREAT
00:25:35 OPPORTUNITY TO LEARN WHAT THEY WERE DOING AND HOW THEY WERE
00:25:38 DOING IT. I GOT TO MEET A THE SERGEANTS
00:25:41 WHO HAVE BEEN PROMOTED. THEY HAD A REVIEW IN EDUCATING
00:25:45 THEM TO TO BEGIN THEIR JOB OR CONTINUE TO BEGIN THEIR JOB
00:25:49 AND GOT THEIR EDUCATION THERE. THERE WAS A WHOLE GROUP OF THEM
00:25:52 THAT GOT TO MEET THERE ALSO WAS SOME OF THE LATERALS I GOT TO
00:25:56 MEET THE LATERALS WHO WERE COMING IN THE NEW CLASS OF THEM
00:25:57 WHO WERE THERE IN OTHER ROOMS WERE BEING EDUCATED.
00:26:00 I GOT TO READ SORT OF LIKE THE CAN YOU CONTINUE AN EDUCATION
00:26:04 GROUP? WHERE ARE THE POST
00:26:05 CERTIFICATIONS THE TWO YEAR EDUCATION OF THOSE THE GROUP
00:26:08 THAT DID THAT AS WELL AS TRAIN THE YOUNG YOUNG YOUNG OFFICERS
00:26:15 COME IN AND IT'S SORT OF LIKE WHEN YOU'RE A JUDGE OR A LAWYER
00:26:16 YOU GET TO CONTINUE EDUCATION. THE OFFICERS EVERY TWO YEARS
00:26:20 HAVE TO BE POSTS RE CERTIFIED SO THEY GET EDUCATED AND PEOPLE
00:26:23 SAY WELL WHY DIDN'T THEY INDUSTRY WELL THERE IS TRAINING
00:26:25 AVAILABLE AND SO AND THEY DO DO IT IT'S REQUIRED YOU CAN'T YOU
00:26:28 CAN'T GO ON THE JOB BUT IT WAS A REAL GOOD EXPERIENCE TO SEE
00:26:31 THE FACILITY TO SEE HOW IT WORKED, TO SEE THE ENERGY OF
00:26:35 THE PEOPLE THERE TEACHING THE OTHER PEOPLE AND THEIR JOBS
00:26:38 AND WANTING TO DO IT AND HOW MUCH THEY WERE IN YOU KNOW,
00:26:42 JUST INVESTED IN DOING IT. SO IT WAS A GREAT IT WAS A
00:26:45 GREAT, GREAT OPPORTUNITY. WHAT WE DO NEED TO DO AND THIS
00:26:49 IS ONE OF THE THINGS WE NEED TO PUT ON OUR AGENDA FOR THE
00:26:50 PEOPLE OF STEM. WE NEED TO REBUILD THAT
00:26:53 FACILITY AND GIVE THEM A BIGGER FACILITY TO DO THAT BECAUSE
00:26:56 WHAT THEY'RE WORKING I MEAN THEY'RE WORKING MIRACLES DOING
00:26:58 WHAT THEY'RE DOING IN THAT THAT SMALL AREA WE NEED TO DO A
00:27:03 FIRST CLASS. WE ARE SAN FRANCISCO.
00:27:04 WE NEED THE TECHNOLOGY. WE GOT ALL THE TECH INDUSTRY
00:27:07 HERE. WE SHOULD UPDATE THIS BECAUSE
00:27:10 SAN FRANCISCO IS THE MODEL FOR THE COUNTRY.
00:27:11 EVERYBODY SEES IT. THEY GOT TO SEE IT AND WE ARE
00:27:14 THAT. SO I THINK IN IN THE IN AS WE
00:27:16 GO FORWARD I THINK THAT'S A REAL CONSIDERATION.
00:27:18 I THINK WE HAVE TO DO WITH OUR ADMINISTRATION, OUR BOARD OF
00:27:22 SUPERVISORS, THE MAYOR AND ANYBODY ELSE OUT THERE IN THE
00:27:26 PRIVATE COMMUNITY WHICH WOULD LIKE TO GIVE AND HELP US OUT.
00:27:30 BUT THEY NEED THAT THEY NEED THAT TRAINING FACILITY.
00:27:33 BUT IT'S GREAT. IT WAS GREAT TO SEE IT AND IT
00:27:34 WAS A GREAT OPPORTUNITY. I THINK THAT SERGEANTS AGAIN
00:27:36 FOR GETTING ME OUT THERE WAS A GREAT, GREAT EXPERIENCE
00:27:38 ALTHOUGH THEY GOT A LITTLE CLAMMED UP BEFORE THAT THEY
00:27:41 WERE COMING THROUGH THE GATES, WERE SHAKING, GETTING A LITTLE
00:27:42 NERVOUS. HE THOUGHT THEY WERE GOING TO
00:27:43 HAVE TO COME BACK TO TRAINING ACADEMY AND I WAS GOING THROUGH
00:27:46 WAIT A MINUTE, WHAT'S GOING ON HERE?
00:27:47 BUT IT WAS IT WORKED OUT. THEY THEY CALMED DOWN SO YOU'RE
00:27:50 OKAY. YOU DON'T HAVE TO COME BACK.
00:27:52 SO IT WAS GOOD. IT WAS REAL GOOD.
00:27:54 ALL RIGHT. THAT'S MY REPORT.
00:27:56 >> COMMISSIONER BENEDICTO, THANK YOU VERY MUCH, PRESIDENT
00:28:01 CLAY FOR RECOGNIZING ME. YOU KNOW, THE LAST TIME I WAS
00:28:04 AT THE ACADEMY THEY TESTED A CONTROL DEVICE ON ME.
00:28:08 I DON'T KNOW IF THEY FIRED EBOLA UP AT YOU AND I I'LL TRY
00:28:09 NOT TO TAKE IT PERSONALLY IF I WAS THE ONE THAT EXPERIENCED
00:28:12 THAT WHICH ACTUALLY DID REMIND ME I KNOW WE DID THAT WAS THAT
00:28:15 I WAS AT THE ACADEMY CHIEF, HOW IS THAT THE I KNOW THERE WAS
00:28:19 LIKE A LIMITED DEPLOYMENT OF THAT OF THE EBOLA APP DEVICE.
00:28:23 I KNOW THERE WAS AN OS IN WHICH IT WAS DEPLOYED LIKE HOW WAS
00:28:27 THAT DEPLOYMENT GONE IS THERE ANYTHING YOU FROM THE
00:28:30 COMMISSION IN TERMS OF AN UPDATE ON THAT DEPLOYMENT
00:28:33 SPECIFICALLY WITH EBOLA APP? SURE.
00:28:37 YEAH. BOLA UP I DON'T THINK THAT WE
00:28:38 ARE GOING WITH THAT PRODUCT. OKAY.
00:28:41 YEAH SHE'S THE EXPERT ON IT BUT I GOT WRAPPED UP IN IT FOR
00:28:45 NOTHING. OKAY.
00:28:52 >> OKAY THIS IS HOT. OKAY THERE WE GO.
00:28:53 YOU GOT WRAPPED UP FOR NOTHING. SO IN OUR LIMITED DEPLOYMENT OF
00:28:58 IT BEYOND OUR SPECIAL OPERATIONS WE FOUND THAT IT
00:28:59 WASN'T A TERRIBLY CONSISTENTLY EFFECTIVE TOOL.
00:29:03 SO BECAUSE WE HAD EBBS AND FLOWS ON ITS SUCCESS MOSTLY
00:29:09 WITH IT NOT BEING SUCCESSFUL WE DECIDED NOT TO CONTINUE FORWARD
00:29:14 WITH THAT TECHNOLOGY. >> IT'S STILL IN THE
00:29:17 EXPLORATION PHASE AS YOU KNOW OUR FIELD TACTICS FORCE OPTIONS
00:29:21 UNIT IS EXTREMELY PROACTIVE ABOUT REVIEWING ALL OF THE
00:29:25 LATEST TECHNOLOGY THAT'S AVAILABLE OUT THERE AND TESTING
00:29:28 THEM OUT AND SECURING AND SEEING WHAT'S THE BEST
00:29:30 OPTION FOR THIS CITY AND OUR DEPARTMENT.
00:29:33 >> WHILE ON THAT TOPIC THAT BIT TO WORK ON YOU I MEAN A LITTLE
00:29:37 I GUESS ISH YOU KNOW WE'LL GO WITH ISH I ON THAT TOPIC I KNOW
00:29:43 ANOTHER TECHNOLOGY THAT WE WERE EVALUATING AROUND THAT SAME
00:29:45 TIME WAS STAR CHASE OR STAR CHASE IS STILL CURRENTLY BEING
00:29:48 USED. >> AND WE'RE FINDING SUCCESS
00:29:52 WITH THAT SO THAT'S GREAT. I KNOW A LOT OF THE SUBJECT
00:29:55 MATTER EXPERTS WE'D SPOKEN TO WERE WE'RE QUITE OPTIMISTIC ON
00:29:57 STAR TREK. >> THANK YOU.
00:29:59 YES, ABSOLUTELY. WE THANK YOU FOR THAT.
00:30:02 NEXT TIME I REPORT I WANTED TO GREET A HAPPY LUNAR NEW YEAR TO
00:30:06 FOLKS WHICH WAS CELEBRATED YESTERDAY AND THEY'LL BE THE
00:30:10 CHINESE NEW YEAR PARADE IN EARLY MARCH.
00:30:13 I THINK SOME OF US ARE IN RED TO COMMEMORATE MARCH 7TH WILL
00:30:17 BE THE PARADE I LOOK FORWARD TO TO JOIN THE SPEEDY CONTINGENT
00:30:20 IN THAT ONE. TODAY'S ALSO ASH WEDNESDAY FOR
00:30:21 THOSE WHO CELEBRATE HAPPY ASH WEDNESDAY AS WELL AND IT IS
00:30:24 STILL BLACK HISTORY MONTH SO CONTINUE TO COMMEMORATE THAT AS
00:30:28 WELL. >> ONE TOPIC I HAD THAT I
00:30:31 WANTED TO RAISE TOO ESPECIALLY IN LIGHT OF THE REPORT WAS OUR
00:30:36 DPA AND I KNOW WE HAVE THE IED AND QUARTERLY REPORTS TODAY
00:30:42 THAT I DON'T THINK IS COVERED IN ANY OF THE REPORTS I THINK
00:30:44 IS WORTH MAYBE DPA AND THE DEPARTMENT PUTTING THEIR HEADS
00:30:47 TOGETHER. >> I DON'T SEE A PURPLE FOLDERS
00:30:50 . I DON'T KNOW WHICH FORMAT TO
00:30:51 ASK FOR THIS AS A LONG TERM QUESTION WHICH IS WE HAVE SEEN
00:30:54 REALLY TREMENDOUS HISTORIC PUBLIC SAFETY RESULTS IN THE
00:30:56 LAST 12 MONTHS REALLY AS WE'VE HEARD TREMENDOUS DROPS
00:31:00 IN VIOLENT CRIME, PROPERTY CRIME AND I'D LIKE TO TAKE A
00:31:01 LOOK TO SEE YEAR OVER YEAR IF THAT'S CORRELATED IN ANY WAY
00:31:08 WHEN IT COMES TO DPA COMPLAINTS OR I.D. COMPLAINTS.
00:31:10 >> AND SO I HAVE TWO QUESTIONS DOES THAT NORMALLY CORRELATE SO
00:31:14 LIKE WHEN WE LOOK AT OTHER PERIODS WHERE CRIME HAS BEEN
00:31:17 LOW VERSUS CRIME HAS BEEN HIGH, DO WE SEE IED AND DPA
00:31:20 COMPLAINTS MATCHING THAT AND IF IF SO, ARE WE SEEING THAT NOW
00:31:24 BECAUSE WE ARE SEEING SUCH A HUGE DROP?
00:31:27 I'D LIKE TO KNOW IF THAT CORRELATES TO AND I KNOW A LOT
00:31:29 OF THE IED STUFF IS LOOKING FORWARD BY QUARTERS SO THIS IS
00:31:32 GOING TO BE DEFINING A LONGER TERM VIEW BUT I THINK IT'S A
00:31:35 QUESTION WORTH LOOKING INTO. >> I LOVE THE QUESTION I WOULD
00:31:38 LOVE TO SHARE AND COMPARE. WE HAVE VERY DETAILED NOTES
00:31:42 AND RECORDS AS YOU KNOW, AS I REPORTED OVER THE PAST YEAR
00:31:44 WHEN THOSE THE VOLUME IS COMING IN AND CHANGES DIFFERENCE
00:31:50 AND ALLEGATIONS THAT COME IN VERSUS SUSTAINED CASES
00:31:52 AND ACTUAL ACTUAL CASES AND INVESTIGATIONS THAT ARE
00:31:55 INDEPENDENT IF IF ID HAS THOSE RECORDS WE COULD OVERLAY THEM
00:32:01 VERY EASILY. >> OKAY.
00:32:02 I WAS GOING TO ASK THE QUESTION TO VICE PRESIDENT BENEDICTO SO
00:32:05 YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT THE ANALYSIS OF WE GET THESE
00:32:08 MONTHLY REPORTS. THEY HAVE STATISTICS FROM IED.
00:32:10 THEY HAVE IT FROM DPA. THEY CAN OVERLAP AND THEN WE
00:32:13 HAVE THE STATISTICS OF WHAT THE CRIMES ARE DONE.
00:32:16 SO TAKING THOSE ON A MONTH TO MONTH BASIS FOR THE 12 MONTHS
00:32:20 AND JUST MIRROR ON THEM AND SEE WHERE THE NUMBERS ARE.
00:32:23 >> YES. SEEING THOSE SEEING WHAT THE
00:32:24 NUMBERS ARE AND THEN IN A MORE HISTORICAL AND SEEING OKAY,
00:32:27 IN THIS PERIOD 2005 LET'S SAY THERE WAS HIGH LIKE YOU KNOW I
00:32:31 JUST WANT TO LIKE SO MUCH OF OUR WORK AND I KNOW THAT I WANT
00:32:35 TO ACKNOWLEDGE THE LEAGUE OF WOMEN VOTERS HAS ASKED THE
00:32:39 COMMISSION TO DO MORE OF THIS SORT OF LONG TERM LOOK, A LOT
00:32:41 OF OUR ANALYSIS IS MONTH TO MONTH DATA, WEEK TO WEEK DATA
00:32:43 AND TO SORT OF LOOK AT A LONGER HISTORICAL AND SO MAYBE IT'S
00:32:47 SOMETHING THAT THE DEPARTMENT AND I FOR ASSIGNMENT FOR OUR
00:32:50 NEW POLICY DIRECTOR DPA BUT NOW THAT THERE IS A YEAR TO PUT
00:32:53 YOUR HEADS TOGETHER AND MAYBE FIGURE OUT SOMETHING AGAIN WITH
00:32:57 A BIT OF A HISTORICAL LENS TO SEE WHAT THIS LOOKS LIKE.
00:33:00 >> I THOUGHT THE TIME SENSITIVE BUT SOMETIME IN THE SPRING OR
00:33:03 SUMMER TWO TO COME BACK I WOULD WELCOME THAT WE HAVE THE
00:33:04 PRESENTATION TODAY BUT WE EVEN AT A MACRO LEVEL DOWN AND EVEN
00:33:10 SAY LINE BY LINE WHAT EACH OF THE ALLEGATIONS ARE INDEPENDENT
00:33:15 OF THE WORK THAT COMES IN JUST TO GIVE YOU A SENSE OR A
00:33:18 MEASURE OF WHAT PEOPLE ARE COMPLAINING ABOUT OR WHAT WHAT
00:33:22 ISSUES ARE BEING RAISED AT LEAST ON THE SET I PRESUME IT'S
00:33:25 THE SAME FOR I WANT TO PUT UP FOR SIX MONTHS FROM NOW AND GET
00:33:30 A REPORT GET TOGETHER. GET A REPORT.
00:33:31 OKAY. >> THANK YOU AND WISH YOU THANK
00:33:36 VERY MUCH THERE PRESIDENT CLAY. I ALSO WANT TO SAY AGAIN IT'S
00:33:39 YESTERDAY WAS A HAPPY LUNAR NEW YEAR DAY CELEBRATED WITH
00:33:47 CHINESE CHAMBER OUT THERE AT THE PORTSMOUTH SQUARE ALONG
00:33:51 WITH THE CHIEF AND THE SHERIFF AND ALL THE ELECTED OFFICIALS
00:33:54 TALKING ABOUT PUBLIC SAFETY AND MAKING SURE THAT THEY
00:33:57 REPORT CRIMES IF THEY YOU KNOW ,IF IT HAPPENS, MAKING SURE
00:34:02 THAT THEY'RE SAFE OUT THERE EVEN IN THE RAIN THEY ALL CAME
00:34:06 OUT THERE. IT WAS RAINING PRETTY HARD.
00:34:09 ALSO JOINED AT CHINATOWN HISTORICAL CULTURE ASSOCIATIONS
00:34:13 THAT DID A GOOD FORTUNE WALK THROUGH CHINATOWN.
00:34:20 >> SO WHEN WE WALK THERE WAS THE RAIN STOP AND SUBSIDED AS A
00:34:24 SIGNAL THAT CITY IS BACK ON ITS FEET AND MOVING FORWARD.
00:34:29 SO AGAIN, STAY SAFE OUT THERE AND RAIN IS GOOD.
00:34:33 THANK YOU VERY MUCH, CHIEF. >> THANK YOU.
00:34:36 THANK YOU. IF ANY MEMBER OF THE PUBLIC
00:34:39 WOULD LIKE TO MAKE PUBLIC COMMENT REGARDING LINE ITEM
00:34:42 FIVE PLEASE APPROACH THE PODIUM .
00:34:46 >> THERE IS NO PUBLIC COMMENT LINE ITEM SIX PRESENTATION
00:34:49 AND DISCUSSION ON SPD'S SECOND AND THIRD QUARTER 2025 I.E.D.
00:34:52 REPORTS DISCUSSION AT THE REQUEST OF THE COMMISSION.
00:35:24 OKAY. HI.
00:35:25 GOOD EVENING PRESIDENT CLAY VICE PRESIDENT BENEDICTO
00:35:32 COMMISSIONERS DIRECTOR HENDERSON AND CHIEF LU.
00:35:33 AS YOU GUYS KNOW I AM LIEUTENANT LISA SPRINGER AND I
00:35:37 AM THE OFFICER IN CHARGE OF THE INTERNAL AFFAIRS DIVISION AND I
00:35:40 THINK YOU'RE GOING TO HEAR ME FOR THE REST OF THE NIGHT.
00:35:44 >> I WILL START WITH THE QUARTER TO FOUR 2025.
00:35:48 I DO REPORT AND THIS IS GOING TO LOOK AT OPEN CASES, CLOSED
00:35:52 CASES, SUSTAINED CASES AND IT'S GOING TO HAVE I ADD AS WELL AS
00:35:59 DPA CASES SHOWN JUST A BRIEF OVERVIEW OF THE DEMOGRAPHICS OF
00:36:07 THE DEPARTMENT. >> THIS IS BY BUREAU AND THEN
00:36:11 WE ALSO HAVE THE STATISTICS FOR ETHNICITY AND THIS IS FOR BOTH
00:36:16 SWORN AND PROFESSIONAL STAFF. THIS IS THE BREAKDOWN OF THE
00:36:23 AGE GROUPS IN THE DEPARTMENT AS WELL AS GENDER.
00:36:33 THESE ARE TEN YEAR GROUPS AND AGAIN MEMBER STATUS AND WE
00:36:38 KIND OF JUST LOOK AT THIS TO SEE IF WE'RE GETTING COMPLAINTS
00:36:42 IN A CERTAIN CATEGORY AND IF THERE'S ANYTHING WE CAN DO
00:36:46 ABOUT IT IN 2024 QUARTER TWO THERE WERE 66 OPEN CASES AND 43
00:36:55 CLOSED CASES IN EXCUSE ME OPEN CASES IN 2025.
00:37:00 >> SO YOU CAN SEE THAT THERE WERE A LOT FEWER CASES OPENED
00:37:06 AND IF YOU LOOK OVER TO THE RIGHT AND 2024 CASES AND IT'S
00:37:10 BROKEN UP BY DPA AND I CLOSED CASES 15 DPA 100 AND THREE ALL
00:37:21 MY GLASSES ARE CLOSED CASES IN 2025 YOU CAN SEE WE DID
00:37:28 CLOSE MORE CASES OF FEWER IED CASES OF THE OPEN CASES
00:37:39 IN QUARTER TWO. THIS IS A BREAKDOWN AND BY BY
00:37:43 THE ALLEGATION TYPE SO CONDUCT UNBECOMING WAS THE HIGHEST
00:37:47 AND THAT I LOOKED AT ALL OF THE CONDUCT UNBECOMING AND THERE
00:37:51 WAS NOT ONE ANY ANY SPECIFIC THING THAT KIND OF STOOD OUT TO
00:37:58 ME COULD BE ANYTHING FROM A FOUR THE OFFICER GOT A DUI TO
00:38:01 EVEN JUST JUST DISRESPECTFUL. SO NOT ONE THING STOOD OUT TO
00:38:07 ME THIS THE NEXT HIGHEST AT ABOUT 20 4% WAS FAILURE TO
00:38:14 APPEAR AT THE RANGE AND WE'VE ALSO BEEN WORKING ON THAT
00:38:18 SETTING UP LIKE A REMINDER FOR OFFICERS OR IF THEY DON'T GET
00:38:24 IN THE RANGE WOULD SEND THEM AN EMAIL AND WE ALSO DID OPEN UP
00:38:26 THE AIRPORT RANGE NOW WHICH HAS BEEN HELPFUL THEN A THIRD
00:38:33 HIGHEST WAS NEGLECT OF DUTY GENERAL AND AGAIN THIS COULD BE
00:38:37 ANYTHING FROM LOSING DEPARTMENT PROPERTY TO NOT DOING SOMETHING
00:38:43 THEY WERE SUPPOSED TO AND THERE WERE 67 TOTAL ALLEGATIONS.
00:38:50 THIS IS THE NUMBER OF OPEN CASES IN Q2 2025 BY MEMBER
00:38:55 STATUS MEAN PROFESSIONAL STAFF VERSUS SWORN AND THIS IS NUMBER
00:39:02 OF EMPLOYEES BY BUREAU AS YOU COULD SEE FIELD OPERATIONS IS
00:39:06 BY FAR THE MOST AND THAT'S OBVIOUS BECAUSE THAT'S PATROL
00:39:13 OPEN CASES BY RACE. >> BUT WE HAVE HERE A BROKEN UP
00:39:21 HIGHEST HIGHEST CATEGORY WAS WHITE FOLLOWED BY ASIAN
00:39:25 AND THEN HISPANIC. >> THESE ARE OPEN CASES BY AGE
00:39:34 GROUP, THE HIGHEST AGE GROUP BEING 40.
00:39:35 THE 40 TO 49 AGE GROUP FOR THIS QUARTER TYPICALLY IT'S IN THE
00:39:42 YOUNGER AGES NUMBER OF EMPLOYEES BY GENDER 11 ABOUT
00:39:53 21% FEMALE AND 78% MALE. >> THESE ARE OPEN CASES BY
00:39:59 TENURE AND YOU CAN SEE THE HIGHEST MEAN THOSE WITH THE
00:40:03 FEWEST NUMBER OF YEARS IN THE DEPARTMENT AND THEN WE HAVE THE
00:40:10 PEAK TO THE 16 TO 20 YEAR MARK AND THESE ARE CLOSED CASES BY
00:40:16 FINDINGS. >> SO ONE HUNDRED AND 31
00:40:22 AND THIS IS BY ALLEGATION WE FOUND PROPER CONDUCT SO JUST
00:40:27 UNDER 50% ABOUT 30% IMPROPER CONDUCT, 10% INSUFFICIENT
00:40:33 EVIDENCE. THESE ARE THE FINDINGS BROKEN
00:40:40 DOWN BY BUREAU. A LOT OF NUMBERS AND THERE
00:40:46 THERE ARE SO MANY SPECIFIC QUESTIONS ON ANY OF IT.
00:40:52 LET ME KNOW. THIS IS AGAIN CLOSED CASES BY
00:40:55 RACE AND THEN WE HAVE BY AGE AGAIN HERE TOTAL NUMBER WAS 273
00:41:05 AND THEN FINDINGS BY GENDER AND JUST BROKEN DOWN BY ANY
00:41:09 POSSIBLE FINDINGS. >> SO ANYTHING ANYTHING FROM
00:41:12 DISMISS TO UNFOUNDED TRAINING FAILURE INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE
00:41:19 AND THESE ARE FINDINGS BY TENURE I DON'T KNOW HOW LIKE
00:41:27 HOW MUCH INTO THE LEAD YOU WANT ME TO GET INTO TO ALL OF THIS
00:41:31 BUT I CAN FINDINGS BY MEMBER STATUS PROFESSIONAL VERSUS
00:41:37 SWORN AND THEN ACTION SO NON DISCIPLINARY ACTIONS IS
00:41:42 ANYTHING FROM ADMONISHMENT TO RETRAINING A PERFORMANCE
00:41:46 IMPROVEMENT PLAN IF THEY RESIGNED OBVIOUSLY THERE'S NO
00:41:52 DISCIPLINARY ACTION AND RETRAINING WE DO WITH EVERY
00:41:56 CASE THERE ARE FOUND IMPROPER AND THEN THE HIGHEST OR THE
00:42:01 WHAT WAS WHAT MOST HAPPENED WAS WRITTEN REPRIMANDS IF THERE WAS
00:42:08 A DISCIPLINARY ACTION AND THEN DONE BROKEN UP A NON
00:42:16 DISCIPLINARY OR DISCIPLINARY BY THE BUREAU THEN WE HAVE ACTIONS
00:42:23 BY RACE AS WELL AS AGE GROUP GENDER AND TENURE.
00:42:33 THESE ARE THE ACTIONS BY MEMBERS.
00:42:34 DOES AGAIN BROKEN DOWN SAME WAY .
00:42:43 >> SO THIS CLOSE THIS THESE ARE CLOSED CASES WITH EMPLOYEES
00:42:47 WITH EMPLOYER EXCUSE ME PRIOR DISCIPLINARY HISTORIES.
00:42:48 SO MEANING THAT WE PROBABLY USED PROGRESSIVE DISCIPLINE.
00:42:54 >> AGAIN WRITTEN WARNING IS STILL THE MOST OR THE HIGHEST
00:43:02 PERCENTAGE CLOSED CASES HERE AGAIN BY BUREAU RACE AGE GROUP
00:43:14 AND GENDER EMPLOYEE TENURE AND WE DO ONLY LOOK AT THE PAST
00:43:19 SEVEN YEARS MEMBER STATUS AGAIN SWORN VERSUS NON SWORN.
00:43:27 >> SO LOOKING AT TRENDS IS THIS IS THE PERCENTAGE OF SUSTAINED
00:43:31 AND NOT SUSTAINED ALLEGATIONS BY BUREAU AND THEN HERE'S A
00:43:41 CRAZY LOOKING CHART FOR YOU GUYS EITHER PRETTY MUCH IN LINE
00:43:46 WITH EACH OTHER THIS IS PERCENTAGE OF SUSTAINED AND NOT
00:43:51 SUSTAINED BY RACE WITH BOTH CHARTS AGE, BOTH CHARTS, GENDER
00:43:59 AND TENURE AND THEN AGAIN BY MEMBER STATUS AND THEN WE HAVE
00:44:06 THE OPEN CASE COMPLAINT SUMMARIES WHICH I THINK YOU
00:44:13 GUYS GOT A COPY OF THIS SO THERE AREN'T ANY QUESTIONS
00:44:18 ABOUT QUARTER TWO SO I DON'T HAVE ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT
00:44:22 QUARTER TWO BUT WHEN I WAS DOING THE ANALYSIS ON THIS
00:44:26 AND LOOKING AT THE NUMBERS HERE AND WHEN YOU SEE THE TOTAL
00:44:30 NUMBERS OF CASES BROUGHT OR INVESTIGATED, WHEN YOU TAKE A
00:44:33 LOOK AT LET'S SAY WE HAVE 1800 OFFICERS IN THE DEPARTMENT
00:44:37 AND WE'RE TALKING ABOUT 1800 OFFICERS AND THAT'S AGING
00:44:40 AND OFFICERS WHO MAYBE WORK 40 HOURS A WEEK 365 DAYS A YEAR.
00:44:46 SO WHAT WE GOT A DE MINIMUS NUMBER OF ACTUAL COMPLAINTS
00:44:50 WHEN YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT 100 OR 200 WITH ALL THOSE NUMBERS
00:44:53 OF POTENTIAL INCIDENCES WITH PEOPLE IT LOOKS LIKE WE'VE GOT
00:44:57 A GOOD DEPARTMENT IS IN REALLY GOOD SHAPE AND WE'RE NOT OUT OF
00:45:00 CONTROL IF THE NUMBERS WERE IN THE THOUSANDS BECAUSE WE GOT
00:45:02 SO MANY DAYS INVOLVED HERE I WOULD BE I'D BE UPSET AND 500
00:45:06 I'D BE UPSET. BUT WHAT WE HAVE HERE WITH YOU
00:45:08 THINK ABOUT ALL THE OPPORTUNITIES THAT YOU COULD
00:45:10 HAVE WITH SOMEBODY DOING SOMETHING EACH AND EVERY DAY
00:45:14 WITH THOSE NUMBERS AND YOU HAVE THESE NUMBERS.
00:45:17 IT WAS IT'S PRETTY GOOD TO SEE IT BUT IT'S GOOD THAT YOU'RE
00:45:19 KEEPING THESE STATS AND LET US KNOW AND WE CAN SEE THE AREAS
00:45:22 THAT YOU STILL NEED TO IMPROVE ON BUT IT'S NOT A SIGN THAT
00:45:26 WE'RE OUT OF CONTROL. BUT IN FACT YOU'RE DOING THE
00:45:29 NECESSARY THINGS THAT MAY BE DETERRING DISCIPLINE.
00:45:30 THESE GUYS GOING OUT MEN AND WOMEN DOING THINGS THAT
00:45:33 THEY SHOULDN'T DO AND FOLLOWING THE DEALS AS AS THEY'RE
00:45:36 SUPPOSED TO. SO THAT'S THAT'S WHAT I TAKE
00:45:37 FROM THIS AND OTHER PEOPLE TAKE DIFFERENTLY BUT LOOKING FROM
00:45:41 THE TOTALITY OF THE CIRCUMSTANCES IT LOOKS PRETTY
00:45:43 GOOD TO ME. >> THAT BEING SAID,
00:45:44 COMMISSIONER TECCE, THANK YOU. >> PRESENTLY MY QUESTION IS THE
00:45:51 FTA THE RANGE THING I WAS REALLY SHOCKED TO SEE SO MANY
00:45:55 OF THEM ALMOST I JUST COUNTED MAYBE 17 OF COURSE IT'S SWORN
00:46:01 OFFICERS AND THEY CARRY GUNS. SO WHAT ARE WE DOING TO HELP
00:46:08 OFFICERS TO REMIND THEM I MEAN I'M ASSUMING I DON'T KNOW THE
00:46:12 PROCESS PER SE BUT HOW ARE WE GOING TO TRAIN FOLKS AND ARE
00:46:16 THERE ANY THAT'S NUMBER ONE LIKE WHAT ARE WE DOING TO MAKE
00:46:20 SURE THEY REALLY DO GO AND DO THEIR PRACTICE?
00:46:23 >> SO WHAT WOULD THEY NEED TO BE DOING FOR THAT TO REMEDY
00:46:25 THAT? THE SECOND QUESTION I HAVE IS
00:46:27 LIKE HOW MANY OF THESE OFF HOW LONG CAN AN OFFICER GO WITHOUT
00:46:31 DOING THAT? >> THEN WHAT HAPPENS?
00:46:34 >> SO OUR DEPARTMENT REQUIRES US TO QUALIFY TWICE A YEAR THE
00:46:38 GUIDELINES FOR A POST OR REQUIREMENT BY POST IS JUST
00:46:42 ONCE A YEAR. SO I THINK DURING COVID WE DID
00:46:46 ONCE A YEAR BUT WE ARE A LOT OF THOSE TWO WERE RECRUITS OR
00:46:50 LATERALS AND SO THEY I THINK THEY HAVE SO MUCH INFORMATION
00:46:55 THROWN AT THEM SO THEY THINK THAT IF THEY WENT TO THE RANGE
00:46:58 IN THE ACADEMY YOU SAY IN APRIL THEY DON'T REALIZE THAT IF
00:47:02 THEY'RE OUT IN FIELD TRAINING IN JUNE BECAUSE IT'S BY STAR
00:47:06 NUMBER THAT THEY HAVE TO GO. SO WE HAVE EVEN THOUGH THEY ARE
00:47:10 TOLD WE HAVE A LOT OF THOSE ESPECIALLY WE'VE HAD A BUNCH
00:47:14 WITH THE LATERALS BECAUSE THEY LITERALLY HAD GONE LIKE TWO
00:47:17 WEEKS PRIOR. SO THEY THINK LIKE OH THAT ONE
00:47:20 I WENT TWO WEEKS PRIOR IT'S GOOD.
00:47:21 SO THEY ACTUALLY ARE CALLING THE PROBABLY MORE THAN TWICE A
00:47:24 YEAR. IT'S JUST THE TIMING IS OFF SO
00:47:27 THEY ACTUALLY WOULD HAVE TO DOUBLE QUAL IN THAT SIX MONTH
00:47:31 PERIOD AND THEN LIKE I SAID AT LEAST WE HAVE THE AIRPORT RANGE
00:47:35 NOW OPEN AND I THINK WE'VE RESTRUCTURED THE CHIEF CAN TALK
00:47:39 MORE TO THIS BUT WE'VE RESTRUCTURED THE RANGE AS WELL
00:47:42 . SO A LOT OF IT IT'S HARD FOR
00:47:44 OFFICERS TO GET THE TIME SLOTS OR THEY WERE BEING CANCELED OR
00:47:50 LIKE YOU HAD LIKE DURING APEC FOR EXAMPLE.
00:47:51 OBVIOUSLY WRONG QUARTER BUT IT WAS CLOSED FOR TWO WEEKS
00:47:57 AND THEN YOU HAVE THANKSGIVING SO IT'S HARDER BUT THAT'S WHY
00:48:00 WE WERE GOING TO IMPLEMENT WE HAVE SPOKEN WITH THE RANGE
00:48:04 MASTER AND SAID IS THERE A WAY YOU CAN WHEN YOU GET THE LIST
00:48:08 AT THE END OF THE MONTH OF WHO HAS NOT COME TO SEND THEM A
00:48:12 REMINDER LIKE GET TO THE RANGE ASAP AND YOU WON'T GET ENOUGH
00:48:16 TO YOU SO THOSE ARE THE THINGS THAT WE'VE TRIED TO IMPLEMENT.
00:48:20 >> THANK YOU COMMISSIONER, BUT CHIEF.
00:48:24 >> CHIEF HEARD SOMETHING. OH, I'M SORRY, CHIEF.
00:48:26 OH, NO WORRIES. I JUST WANTED TO CLARIFY SO I
00:48:28 THINK JUST TO UNDERSCORE FOR YOU I THINK IT'S AND YOU CAN
00:48:31 CORRECT ME IF I'M WRONG HERE, LISA, BUT IT'S RARE THAT YOU
00:48:35 WOULD HAVE AND SO ARE OFFICERS QUALIFIED TWICE A YEAR IT WOULD
00:48:39 BE RARE TO HAVE AN OFFICER NOT QUALIFY LIKE IF THEY MISS THEIR
00:48:45 MONTH THEY'RE GOING TO MAKE IT UP WITHIN A MONTH OR TWO SO
00:48:49 THEY WOULDN'T GO WITHOUT QUALIFYING AT ALL.
00:48:54 I JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE YOU UNDERSTOOD THAT.
00:48:55 OKAY. ALL RIGHT.
00:48:57 VICE PRESIDENT BENEDETTO, THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:49:00 >> I HAD A QUESTION. I THINK IT APPLIES TO BOTH
00:49:02 QUARTERS SO I'LL JUST ASK IT ONCE I WAS LOOKING AT THE
00:49:05 TRENDS SLIDE WHICH I THINK WAS PAGE WHICH PAGE IS THAT ON HERE
00:49:14 41 I THINK ON THE Q2 REPORT AND I'M CURIOUS AS TO WHEN
00:49:18 COMPARING 24 AND 2025 WHAT JUMPED OUT AT ME IS THE NOT
00:49:22 SUSTAINED SUSTAINED RATE AND THE FIELD OPERATIONS WHICH
00:49:23 IS THE HIGHEST NUMBER SO LESS LIKELY TO JUST BE SORT OF YOU
00:49:26 KNOW AFFECTED BY SAMPLE SIZE LIKE AIRPORT BEER OR SOMETHING
00:49:30 LIKE THAT WHERE IN QUARTER TWO IT WAS 35% NOT SUSTAINED, 64%
00:49:36 SUSTAINED IN 2024 AND THEN AT 25 THOSE EFFECTIVELY FLIP WHERE
00:49:39 IT'S 69% NOT SUSTAINED AND 30% SUSTAINED AND WE SEE THAT
00:49:44 IN QUARTER THREE AS WELL COMPARING 2024 TO 2025 OR
00:49:47 THERE'S A 6040 SPLIT THAT GETS MORE OR LESS COMPLETELY
00:49:51 INVERTED. IS THERE ANY PARTICULAR REASON
00:49:52 FOR FOR THAT DEVELOPMENT YOU CAN THINK OF NONE THAT I KNOW
00:49:56 OTHER THAN A LOT OF TIMES ONE CASE HAS MULTIPLE EMPLOYEES
00:50:02 INVOLVED SO IT COULD JUST BE LIKE A DIFFERENCE OF ONE CASE
00:50:06 EVEN. BUT YEAH, FOR ME LOOKING AT
00:50:07 THESE AND I'M NOT AN ANALYST AND I DON'T LIKE MATH BUT IT'S
00:50:13 REALLY HARD TO LOOK AT LIKE LIKE YOU WERE SAYING EARLIER I
00:50:15 THINK IT WAS YOU I THINK TO SEE IF THERE'S AN ACTUAL TREND WE
00:50:20 NEED TO LOOK AT LIKE FIVE YEARS OF DATA AND NOT JUST QUARTER TO
00:50:24 QUARTER FOR YEAR TO YEAR. >> YEAH.
00:50:25 WOULD IT BE POSSIBLE ALL AND I DON'T NEED THIS AS AN AGENDA
00:50:30 ITEM IT CAN BE PROVIDED IN WRITING TO THE COMMISSION ON
00:50:32 THE CONSENT CALENDAR TO JUST GET I KNOW OBVIOUSLY THIS LIVES
00:50:36 AND ALL THESE REPORTS BUT IT WOULD BE EASIER FOR DEPARTMENT
00:50:38 COULD DO IT COULD WE GET THAT STAT PULLED OUT WHICH IS THE
00:50:40 SUSTAINED NOT SUSTAINED FOR THE FIELD OPERATIONS BUREAU
00:50:44 ANNUALIZED GOING BACK LIKE SIX JUST SO WE CAN SEE WHERE THE
00:50:52 ABERRATION IS IS IT NORMALLY 6041 WAY OR THE OTHER?
00:50:53 IT DOESN'T EVEN HAVE TO BE QUARTER BY QUARTER.
00:50:55 I THINK IT WOULD BE HELPFUL TO SEE THAT DATA PRESENTED TO SEE
00:50:58 THE NOT SUSTAINED AND SUSTAINED RATE FOR FIELD OPERATIONS
00:51:03 BUREAU WHICH HAS THE VAST MAJORITY OF THE COMPLAINTS OR
00:51:06 HOW FAR DO YOU WANT YOU SAID FIVE YEARS TO GO BACK TO I MEAN
00:51:10 I THINK IF IT'S IF WE'RE DOING JUST ANNUAL DATA WHICH I THINK
00:51:15 WOULD BE MORE HELPFUL BECAUSE I THINK THE QUARTER BY QUARTER
00:51:19 DATA ISN'T AS HELPFUL IN THIS CONTEXT IF WE COULD GO BACK
00:51:20 SEVEN YEARS. >> OKAY.
00:51:22 HOW DOUBTFUL SO THE ANNUAL NOT QUARTERBACK FOR YEAH JUST
00:51:26 ANNUAL SEVEN YEARS IS JUST ONE TABLE RIGHT BECAUSE AGAIN I
00:51:27 THINK IT WOULD BE IF IF IT TURNS OUT IT'S ALMOST ALWAYS
00:51:30 YOU KNOW THE WAY 2025 LOOKED IN 2024 WAS UNUSUAL AND HOW
00:51:35 MANY CALLS IT WAS NOT SAY AND THAT'S HELPFUL TO KNOW IF
00:51:38 IT TURNS OUT THE OTHER WAY THAT'S HELPFUL TO KNOW
00:51:39 AND MIGHT INFORM THE COMMISSIONS SHOULD THAT BE
00:51:42 HELPFUL. BUT ALL RIGHT, SERGEANT, IF ANY
00:51:52 MEMBER OF THE PUBLIC WOULD LIKE TO MAKE PUBLIC COMMENT, PLEASE
00:51:53 APPROACH THE PODIUM. THERE IS NO PUBLIC COMMENT LINE
00:52:03 ITEM SEVEN EXCEPT A SERIOUS INCIDENT REVIEW BOARD FINDINGS
00:52:04 AND RECOMMENDATIONS THIRD QUARTER 2025 PART TWO
00:52:07 DISCUSSION OKAY. >> AS SERGEANT YOUNGBLOOD
00:52:22 STATED THIS WAS PART TWO AND I MENTIONED LAST TIME WE ACTUALLY
00:52:25 HAD SEVEN COVERT INCIDENTS CLOSED IN THE THIRD QUARTER OF
00:52:29 THESE DPA DID HANDLE ONE OR INVESTIGATE ONE WHICH I BELIEVE
00:52:37 WAS THE FIRST ONE WAS 20 3-004 THEY CONCURRED WITH WITH IED
00:52:43 IED FINDINGS WHICH I WILL PRESENT HERE.
00:52:46 SO WE'LL BE DISCUSSING THREE COVERED INCIDENTS.
00:52:50 YES 20 3-004 I'D 20 5-001 AND OS 20 5-002 THE FIRST
00:53:00 OFFICER INVOLVED SHOOTING OCCURRED ON AUGUST 28TH 2023 AT
00:53:06 APPROXIMATELY 10:22 P.M. DISPATCH RECEIVED IN A PRIORITY
00:53:10 222 CALL WHICH IS PERSON WITH A KNIFE IN THE TENDERLOIN THE 911
00:53:17 CALLER REPORTED A PERSON HOLDING A LARGE KNIFE
00:53:20 THREATENING PEOPLE ON THE 300 BLOCK OF JOHN STREET.
00:53:23 >> RESPONDING OFFICERS ARRIVED ON SCENE AND TACTICALLY
00:53:25 REPOSITION THEMSELVES AND THEIR VEHICLES PARKING ON THE NORTH
00:53:29 SOUTH AND EAST SIDE OF THE SUBJECT AT A SAFE DISTANCE TO
00:53:33 CONTAIN AND ISOLATE THE SUBJECT OFFICERS THEY USE THEIR VEHICLE
00:53:37 SPOTLIGHTS TO ILLUMINATE THE SUBJECT AND GAIN A BETTER
00:53:41 VISIBILITY AND CONTAINMENT AND THE FIRST OFFICERS ON SCENE
00:53:45 GAVE NUMEROUS COMMANDS FOR THE SUBJECT TO DROP THE KNIFE.
00:53:52 >> OFFICERS ATTEMPTED TO COMMUNICATE WITH THE SUBJECT.
00:53:56 HE WAS NONCOMPLIANT. THE SUBJECTS SHOOK THEIR HEAD
00:53:57 FROM SIDE TO SIDE BUT TOOK THE KNIFE FROM THEIR WAISTBAND
00:54:03 AND HELD IT BY THEIR SIDE SIMULTANEOUSLY AN OFFICER
00:54:06 DEPLOYED OR POINTED THE AREA AT THE SUBJECT AT APPROXIMATELY
00:54:13 10:28 P.M. A SERGEANT ARRIVED AND TOOK COMMAND OF THE SCENE
00:54:14 AND A LEADERSHIP ROLE. THE SERGEANT DIRECTED THE
00:54:18 OFFICERS TO CLEAR THE BLOCK FOR PUBLIC SAFETY, ESTABLISH ROLES
00:54:21 FOR THE OFFICERS INCLUDING A MAIN COMMUNICATOR LETHAL COVER,
00:54:25 NONLETHAL COVER ADDITIONAL VEHICLES FROM THE STATION
00:54:29 AND AN ARREST TEAM. THE SERGEANT REQUESTED A
00:54:33 TACTICAL SHIELD AND SPECIALISTS EQUIPPED WITH THE 40 MILLIMETER
00:54:39 . >> WOW AT APPROXIMATELY 10:30
00:54:42 P.M. AN OFFICER ATTEMPTED DIALOG WITH THE SUBJECT BY
00:54:46 ASKING THEM THEIR NAME. THE SUBJECT REPLIED I DON'T
00:54:50 HAVE A NAME. THE OFFICER FOLLOWED UP BY
00:54:51 ASKING HOW CAN WE HELP YOU? THE SUBJECT RESPONDED I DON'T
00:54:55 WANT YOUR HELP, THE OFFICER TOLD THE SUBJECT WELL YOU'RE
00:54:59 FREAKING PEOPLE OUT BECAUSE YOU'RE WALKING AROUND HERE WITH
00:55:02 A GIGANTIC KNIFE AND THE SUBJECT RESPONDED DON'T F WITH
00:55:05 ME. >> THE MAIN COMMUNICATOR ROLE
00:55:09 WAS TRANSITIONED TO ANOTHER OFFICER WHO WAS KNOWN BY THEIR
00:55:13 COLLEAGUES FOR PAST SUCCESS IN TALKING TO PEOPLE IN CRISIS
00:55:17 AND FOR OVER TEN MINUTES THE OFFICER ATTEMPTED DIALOG WITH
00:55:20 THE SUBJECT AT APPROXIMATELY 10:40 P.M. SO ABOUT 15 MINUTES
00:55:24 INTO THIS INCIDENT AFTER OR AFTER AFTER THE FIRST OFFICERS
00:55:31 ARRIVED THE SUBJECT BEGAN TO LEAVE THE CONTAINMENT AREA,
00:55:34 PICKED UP A DUFFEL BAG AND A MILK CRATE FROM THE GROUND.
00:55:37 THE SUBJECT THEN BEGAN WALKING NORTHEAST ON JONES STREET
00:55:41 TOWARDS THE OFFICERS WITH THEIR RIGHT HAND.
00:55:43 THE SUBJECT PULLED THE KNIFE OUT FROM THEIR WAISTBAND.
00:55:46 >> THE SUBJECT QUICKENED THEIR PACE AS THEY MOVED TOWARDS THE
00:55:50 OFFICERS AND WITH THEIR LEFT HAND THE SUBJECT HELD THE MILK
00:55:54 CRATE AND THE DUFFEL BAG UP IN FRONT OF THEIR FACE.
00:55:57 THE SUBJECT CONTINUED TO REFUSE COMMANDS TO DROP THE KNIFE
00:56:01 AND THEN BEGAN TO RUN AT THE OFFICERS WHILE SWINGING THE
00:56:05 KNIFE THAT HE DISPLAYED. >> MULTIPLE OFFICERS YELLED OUT
00:56:09 THE RED LIGHT ADMONITION TO WARN THE SUBJECT AND OFFICER
00:56:13 NUMBER THREE DEPLOYED THE AREA W ALONG WITH OFFICER NUMBER
00:56:19 FOUR. OFFICER NUMBER ONE DISCHARGED
00:56:20 THEIR DEPARTMENT ISSUED FIREARM AS WELL AS OFFICER NUMBER TWO
00:56:26 MULTIPLE OFFICERS YELLED SHOTS FIRE FIRED AND DROPPED THE
00:56:30 KNIFE AS THE SUBJECT FELL TO THE GROUND OFFICERS FORMED AN
00:56:34 ARREST TEAM AND APPROACHED THE SUBJECT WHO WAS LYING ON THEIR
00:56:39 STOMACH. THE SUBJECT'S KNIFE WAS ON THE
00:56:40 GROUND NEXT TO THEIR RIGHT HAND.
00:56:42 OFFICERS OBSERVED THE KNIFE APPEARED TO BE TIED TO THE
00:56:46 SUBJECT'S WRIST RIGHT WRIST WITH A STRAP AND THEY WERE ABLE
00:56:49 TO REMOVE THE KNIFE AND HANDCUFF THE SUBJECT
00:56:52 AND RENDERED AID. >> THESE ARE ALL OF THE
00:56:56 POLICIES THAT WE LOOKED AT ADMINISTRATIVELY MOST OF THEM
00:57:00 OBVIOUSLY IN USE OF FORCE AND AS WELL AS THE TREATMENT
00:57:05 FOR INJURED PERSONS AND INVESTIGATIONS OF OFFICER
00:57:08 INVOLVED SHOOTINGS AND BODY WORN CAMERA AND EQUIPMENT
00:57:09 AND WE FOUND OFFICER NUMBER ONE TO BE PROPER AND IN POLICY.
00:57:16 >> SAME FOR OFFICER NUMBER TWO AND THOSE WERE THE TWO THAT
00:57:20 DISCHARGE THEIR FIREARMS. >> SAME WITH THE TWO OFFICERS
00:57:26 THAT DEPLOYED THEIR RW WAS LETHAL AND PROPER AND CONCURRED
00:57:30 WITH WITH OUR FINDINGS IN THIS ONE THERE ANY QUESTIONS ON THAT
00:57:34 ONE BEFORE I MOVE ON TO THE OID THE SECOND CASE THAT WE
00:57:41 DISCUSSED WAS OFFICER INVOLVED DISCHARGE 20 5-001 AND THIS
00:57:47 OCCURRED IN NOVEMBER OF 2024 AT APPROXIMATELY 10:48 A.M.
00:57:52 OFFICERS RESPONDED TO THE SAFEWAY PARKING LOT ON WEBSTER
00:57:57 STREET REGARDING THREE LARGE BLACK DOGS THAT HAD ATTACKED A
00:58:01 SMALLER DOG AND POSSIBLY ATTACKING PEOPLE.
00:58:04 THERE WERE MULTIPLE 911 CALLERS REPORTING THE DANGEROUS DOGS
00:58:08 SOME INCLUDED DOGS WERE RUNNING AROUND THE MIDDLE OF THE STREET
00:58:12 AND IT'S UNKNOWN WHERE THE OWNERS ARE.
00:58:15 ONE OF THE CALLERS ADVISED THAT THEIR DOG HAD BEEN ATTACKED BY
00:58:17 THE DOGS THAT WERE RUNNING LOOSE AND THEY WERE ON THEIR
00:58:20 WAY TO THE EMERGENCY VET. >> ONE CALLER DESCRIBED THE
00:58:23 DOGS AS LARGE BLACK PIT BULLS AND ANOTHER AS THREE BLACK CANE
00:58:27 TORSOS WHICH IS WHAT THEY IN FACT WERE KING TORSOS.
00:58:31 >> I MAY BE SAYING THAT WRONG BUT WE SEE AN AVERAGE OF 80 TO
00:58:36 120 POUNDS AND THE OFFICERS ON SCENE BELIEVE THEY'RE ON THE
00:58:41 HEAVIER SIDE OF THAT AVERAGE. >> SEVERAL UNITS RESPONDED TO
00:58:44 THE PARKING LOT AND THEY LOCATED TWO OF THE BLACK DOGS.
00:58:50 ONE WAS ALREADY SECURED INSIDE OF A VEHICLE, A VAN THAT WAS
00:58:51 PARKED IN THE PARKING LOT. >> OFFICERS ATTEMPTED TO CREATE
00:58:54 A PERIMETER TO KEEP THE DOGS FROM FLEEING.
00:58:58 >> I THINK ONE EVEN WENT INSIDE AND BOUGHT SOME DOG TREATS.
00:59:01 THEY WAITED FOR ANIMAL CARE AND CONTROL TO ARRIVE
00:59:05 AND DELIVERED THE DOGS. ADDITIONALLY OFFICERS TRIED TO
00:59:09 USE A HOBBLE AS A LEASH BUT THEY WERE NOT SUCCESSFUL WHILE
00:59:15 OFFICERS WERE ON SCENE. >> AN INDIVIDUAL APPROACHED THE
00:59:19 OFFICERS AND ADVISED THAT HE KNEW THE DOGS AND THE OWNER.
00:59:23 THEY MADE SEVERAL ATTEMPTS TO SECURE THE DOGS BUT THE DOGS
00:59:27 STARTED TO BITE THE SUBJECT AND LATCHED ONTO HIS LEFT ARM.
00:59:31 THE SUBJECT YELLED THIS BE BITING SINCE THE DOGS WERE
00:59:34 ACTIVELY BITING THE SUBJECT. OFFICER ONE CLOSED THE DISTANCE
00:59:41 AND SHOT AT THE TWO DOGS STRIKING ONE OF THEM AND THIS
00:59:45 CAUSED BOTH DOGS TO RELEASE THEIR BITE ON THE SUBJECT
00:59:46 AND RUN AWAY. >> ONE OF THE DOGS COLLAPSED A
00:59:50 SHORT DISTANCE AND AWAY IN A PARKING LOT AFTER SUSTAINING
00:59:56 LETHAL WOUNDS AND THE OTHER DOG CONTINUED ON INTO A SURROUNDING
01:00:00 NEIGHBORHOOD. >> OFFICERS RESPONDED TO THE
01:00:04 AREA AND DEPLOYED LESS LETHAL CONTACT ING THE DOG SEVERAL
01:00:08 TIMES WHICH HAD NO EFFECT ON THE DOG ON THE 1400 BLOCK OF
01:00:12 GOLDEN GATE AVENUE THE DOG RAN DOWN A DRIVEWAY SO THEY HAD IT
01:00:16 TRAPPED SEVERAL OFFICERS SURROUNDED THE DOG TO PREVENT
01:00:20 ITS ESCAPE AND AT APPROXIMATELY 1122 THE DOG CAME RUNNING OUT
01:00:23 OF THE DRIVEWAY AREA. SO ONE OF THE OFFICERS FIRED AT
01:00:27 THE DOG AND LETHAL ROUNDS WERE DELIVERED AGAIN, THEY DID TRY
01:00:34 THE AREA WITH NO EFFECT PRIOR TO THAT THE DOG WAS STRUCK BUT
01:00:38 CONTINUED TO RUN AWAY AND A SHORT TIME LATER IT WAS LOCATED
01:00:42 AT KIMBALL PARK. IT WAS HIDING IN A BUSH.
01:00:45 OFFICERS MAINTAIN THE PERIMETER AND HCC CAME INTO CUSTODY OF
01:00:49 THE DOG. THESE ARE THE WOUNDS SUSTAINED
01:00:53 BY THE VICTIMS. YOU CAN SEE IT'S PRETTY SEVERE
01:00:56 . THESE ARE THE POLICIES THAT WE
01:01:01 LOOKED AT IN REGARDS TO THIS IDEA AND WE FOUND BOTH OFFICERS
01:01:04 TO BE WITHIN POLICY IMPROPER CONDUCT.
01:01:09 ANY QUESTIONS ON THAT ONE? >> OKAY.
01:01:12 THE LAST ONE WAS OFFICER INVOLVED SHOOTING 20 5-002
01:01:17 AND THIS OCCURRED ON TUESDAY JANUARY 28TH AT APPROXIMATELY
01:01:20 6:10 P.M.. >> OFFICER NUMBER ONE DISCHARGE
01:01:24 THEIR PERSONAL SEMIAUTOMATIC HANDGUN A SIX HOUR WHILE IN THE
01:01:29 LOCKER ROOM OF MISSION STATION .
01:01:32 SO WHEN OUR POLICY IS REWRITTEN THIS WILL ACTUALLY BE
01:01:33 CONSIDERED AN OID AND NOT AN OS.
01:01:36 THE BULLET STRUCK OFFICER NUMBER ONE IN THE LEFT LEG
01:01:40 MISSION OFFICERS ON SCENE PROVIDED AID TO THE OFFICER
01:01:44 INCLUDING A TOURNIQUET. FIRE PERSONNEL RESPONDED
01:01:48 AND TRANSPORTED HIM TO THE HOSPITAL.
01:01:49 >> HE WAS STABLE AND LATER DISCHARGED.
01:01:52 SO THIS ONE WE FOUND THE OFFICER WAS NOT IN POLICY.
01:01:58 >> UM, THIRD QUARTER 2025 THERE WERE NO IN-CUSTODY DEATHS
01:02:04 AND THEN WE HAVE THE STATUS OF ALL OPEN CASES WHICH WE'RE DOWN
01:02:09 TO TWO PAGES WAS FOUR NOT THAT LONG AGO.
01:02:12 >> THANK YOU. YOU'RE WELCOME.
01:02:16 IF ANY MEMBER OF THE PUBLIC WOULD LIKE TO MAKE PUBLIC
01:02:21 COMMENT, PLEASE APPROACH THE PODIUM.
01:02:23 >> THERE IS NO PUBLIC COMMENT LINE ITEM EIGHT PRESENTATION ON
01:02:27 SPD'S DISCIPLINARY REVIEW BOARD FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
01:02:32 THIRD QUARTER 2025 DISCUSSION. >> AS YOU GUYS ALL KNOW THIS AS
01:02:53 CHIEF OF STAFF SHARON MOVED FROM DPA AND WE WILL BE
01:02:57 PRESENTING TOGETHER ON THE DISCIPLINARY REVIEW BOARD
01:03:02 QUARTER THREE WHICH WE HELD ON NOVEMBER 13TH 2025.
01:03:09 THE AGGREGATE TRENDS ARE IDENTIFIED BY ICD AND DBA ARE
01:03:13 HERE. AS YOU CAN SEE CONDUCT
01:03:17 UNBECOMING WHICH IS WHAT WE DISCUSSED IN OTHER QUARTERS WAS
01:03:20 THE HIGHEST NUMBER OF ALLEGATIONS AT ABOUT 28%
01:03:28 FAILURE TO APPEAR RANGE ABOUT 24% AND NEGLECT OF DUTY GENERAL
01:03:31 ABOUT 27% FOR A GOOD EVENING EVERYBODY FOR SORRY FOR THE
01:03:42 NEGLECT OF DUTY THE GENERAL WAS THE HIGHEST AT 63%.
01:03:50 BODY WORN CAMERA IS NEXT. FAILURE TO START YOUR BODY WORN
01:03:54 CAMERA AND CONDUCT UNBECOMING 14%.
01:03:56 THERE ARE 50 CASES OPEN IN QUARTER THREE INVOLVING 75
01:04:03 EMPLOYEES AND 122 ALLEGATIONS. >> THOSE ARE THE ALLEGATIONS
01:04:08 ONLY NOT SUSTAINED CONDUCT AT ALL.
01:04:12 >> WHEN WE HAVE THESE MEETINGS WE ARE ONLY LOOKING AT POLICY
01:04:17 AND TRAINING FAILURES. SO THERE WERE TWO IAD CASES
01:04:20 THAT RESULTED IN A POLICY FAILURE IN QUARTER THREE
01:04:24 AND ZERO CASES THAT RESULTED IN A TRAINING FAILURE.
01:04:28 >> THOSE SAME NUMBERS FOR DPA AS WELL TWO POLICY FAILURES
01:04:32 ZERO TRAINING FAILURES THE FIRST POLICY FAILURE FOR IDU
01:04:40 INVOLVED THE FLOCK DATABASE. AN OUTSIDE AGENCY CONTACTED THE
01:04:44 DEPARTMENT AFTER ONE OF THEIR FLOCK IMAGES OF A STOLEN
01:04:47 VEHICLE APPEARED ON A PERSONAL INSTAGRAM ACCOUNT.
01:04:51 >> THE IMAGE ALSO INCLUDED TEXT STATING THAT THE VEHICLE HAD
01:04:55 BEEN STOLEN FROM A RELATIVE. AN AUDIT WAS CONDUCTED
01:04:59 AND FOUND THAT THE LICENSE PLATE WAS SEARCHED MULTIPLE
01:05:02 TIMES BY A MEMBER OF THE S.F. PD THAT IN FACT HAD FLOCK
01:05:05 ACCESS. >> ALTHOUGH THERE ARE NUMEROUS
01:05:07 ALLEGATIONS AND FINDINGS IN THIS CASE, THE POLICY
01:05:10 FAILURE THAT WAS EXPLORED WAS A CONFLICT OF INTEREST
01:05:14 IN INVESTIGATIONS AS THE VEHICLE THAT THE MEMBER
01:05:18 SEARCHED FOR IN THE DATABASE WAS THEIR SPOUSES VEHICLE.
01:05:28 >> THE SECOND POLICY FAILURE CASE INVOLVED AN ANONYMOUS
01:05:32 WHISTLEBLOWER COMPLAINT ALLEGING THAT A MEMBER OF
01:05:37 CIRCUMVENTED THE PURCHASING POLICY FOR A YEAR BY
01:05:38 INAPPROPRIATELY USING A PERSONAL ACCOUNT TO PURCHASE
01:05:41 AND LATER BE REIMBURSED FOR SUPPLIES FOR A SPECIALIZED UNIT
01:05:48 . >> THE COMPLAINT STATED THAT
01:05:48 ALTHOUGH OVER MULTIPLE YEARS THE MEMBER KNOWINGLY VIOLATED
01:05:52 THE CITY AND DEPARTMENT'S PURCHASING PROCESS AND THAT
01:05:55 THEY EXPLOITED THE USE OF THE CITY'S 12 BE COMPLIANT VENDOR
01:06:00 ITEMS THAT THEY BELIEVED THAT WERE NEEDED FOR DAY TO DAY
01:06:03 OPERATIONS OR PROJECTS WERE PERSONALLY PURCHASED FROM LOCAL
01:06:07 STORES SUCH AS HOME DEPOT AND AMAZON, COSTCO.
01:06:11 THESE PURCHASES WERE MADE USING THEIR PERSONAL CREDIT CARD
01:06:13 AND IT IS NOT A KNOWN FACT BUT IT ASSUMED THAT BY USING THEIR
01:06:19 CREDIT CARD THEY WOULD RECEIVE LIKE CERTAIN POINTS OR CREDITS.
01:06:22 THE MEMBER WOULD THEN TURN IN THESE RECEIPTS FOR A
01:06:26 REIMBURSEMENT FROM THE VENDOR AND THIS WAY OF PURCHASING
01:06:29 CIRCUMVENTS MANY POLICIES WITHIN THE CITY AND DEPARTMENT
01:06:33 . THESE PURCHASES COULD HAVE BEEN
01:06:33 DONE THROUGH THE APPROVED VENDORS BUT INSTEAD FOR
01:06:37 CONVENIENCE AND POSSIBLY PERSONAL BENEFIT THEY WERE MADE
01:06:39 IN UNAPPROVED WAYS. >> THE TWO POLICY FAILURES THAT
01:06:45 EPA NOTED DURING THIS QUARTER THE FIRST ONE INVOLVED A DECOY
01:06:51 VEHICLE THAT WAS PARKED IN THE UNION SQUARE AREA.
01:06:52 IT WAS PARKED THERE FOR AN EXTENDED PERIOD OF TIME.
01:06:56 THERE ARE COMPLAINTS FROM MERCHANTS THAT IT WAS IN A RED
01:07:00 ZONE FOR A VERY LONG TIME AND THE DPI HAS RECOMMENDED
01:07:03 THAT THE POLICY BE UPDATED TO TALK ABOUT HOW LONG A DECOY
01:07:08 VEHICLE CAN BE THERE, HOW AND WHO WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR
01:07:12 MOVING THAT VEHICLE AND WE DIDN'T FIND ANYTHING FOR THE
01:07:15 LIEUTENANT WHO WAS IN CHARGE OF OF THE ACTUAL VEHICLES
01:07:19 THEMSELVES. IT'S IMPOSSIBLE FOR HIM TO BE
01:07:23 REQUIRED TO MOVE ALL OF THOSE VEHICLES HIMSELF.
01:07:24 SO WE SUGGESTED THAT THE DEPARTMENT UPDATE THEIR
01:07:27 POLICIES TO TALK ABOUT HOW AND WHEN THOSE VEHICLES CAN BE
01:07:31 PARKED. >> THE SECOND POLICY FAILURE
01:07:35 HAD TO DO WITH DAIGO 6.15 WHICH IS PROPERTY PROCESSING.
01:07:41 >> A PHONE WAS TWOFOLD TWO CELL PHONES WERE SEIZED PURSUANT TO
01:07:44 AN ARREST. THE PHONES WERE PLACED IN A
01:07:48 SECURE LOCATION WHERE MANY OTHER PHONES WERE ALSO LOCATED
01:07:52 PENDING A SEARCH WARRANT TO DO A TO DOWNLOAD THOSE PHONES.
01:07:56 SOMEWHERE ALONG THE WAY THERE WAS A MIXUP.
01:08:00 THE PHONES WERE WOUND UP MISSING.
01:08:01 NOBODY COULD FIND THEM. A SEARCH WARRANT WAS NOT
01:08:04 CONDUCTED FOR THOSE PHONES. DPA HAS REQUESTED THAT 6.15
01:08:10 INCLUDE WHICH HASN'T BEEN UPDATED SINCE 1994 INCLUDE NEW
01:08:13 TECHNOLOGY AND HOW THAT TECHNOLOGY NEEDS TO BE SECURED
01:08:16 WHEN THE TECHNOLOGY NEEDS TO BE REVIEWED AND A AN APPROPRIATE
01:08:24 PROPERTY PROCESSING SO THAT WE CAN DETERMINE WHERE IT IS
01:08:28 AND WHO'S RESPONSIBLE. THERE WERE A NUMBER OF PHONES
01:08:32 ON CHARGING BANKS THERE ASSOCIATED WITH MANY DIFFERENT
01:08:36 CASES AND WHEN IT CAME BACK TIME TO YOU TO FIND THAT
01:08:39 PARTICULAR PHONE IT WAS JUST IT WAS GONE AND IT WAS I THINK
01:08:43 OVER SIX MONTHS THAT NOBODY HAD EVEN LOOKED FOR THE PHONES.
01:08:47 SO AND 6.15 I'M PRETTY CERTAIN IS ON FOR CONCURRENCE IN ON
01:08:52 MARCH 11TH SO THEY'VE ALREADY UPDATED 6.15 A I'VE LOOKED AT
01:08:56 IT I MIGHT HAVE A LITTLE BIT OF SUGGESTIONS BUT IT WILL BE
01:09:00 UPDATED. >> >> SO THESE WERE THE
01:09:06 RECOMMENDATIONS THAT THE BOARD CAME UP WITH.
01:09:10 >> RECOMMENDATION ONE WAS TO EXPAND 2.03 EXCUSE ME 2.01.03
01:09:17 RULE 19 THE CONFLICT OF INTEREST AND INVESTIGATIONS
01:09:20 JUST BE EXPANDED TO INCLUDE INCLUDE CLEAR LANGUAGE THAT
01:09:23 MEMBERS SHOULD NOT CONDUCT ANY PART OF AN INVESTIGATION IF
01:09:28 THERE'S A CONFLICT OF INTEREST. SO EVEN RUNNING A PLATE.
01:09:33 THE SECOND RECOMMENDATION IN THE DPA RECOMMENDS THAT A
01:09:35 POLICY OR PROCEDURE BE ADDED OR MODIFIED TO ADDRESS THE LACK OF
01:09:39 CLEAR GUIDELINES FOR PARKING PATROL VEHICLES USED FOR
01:09:42 OFFICERS OR VEHICLES DEPLOYED AT THE MOBILE COMMAND CENTER
01:09:46 FOR DETERRENT OR DECOY VEHICLES AS THERE ARE NO CLEAR
01:09:50 DEPARTMENT POLICIES, PROCEDURES OR OP ORDERS DESIGNATED LEGAL
01:09:53 PARKING AREAS FOR THESE CIRCUMSTANCE CASES.
01:09:59 RECOMMENDATION THREE THE WHAT SHARON JUST MENTIONED.
01:10:05 UPDATING SIX POINT YEAH. >> OKAY.
01:10:09 I DID REVIEW THE QUARTERLY REPORT AND BASED ON THEIR
01:10:10 REVIEW OF THE INFORMATION NO FINDINGS AND INDICATED ANY
01:10:13 NEGATIVE TRENDS TOWARDS BIAS DISPARITIES OR INEQUITIES.
01:10:20 SO NO CORRECT CORRECTIVE ACTION WAS RECOMMENDED.
01:10:24 FOURTH QUARTER DERBY ACTUALLY I THINK IS NEXT WEEK 26TH AND I
01:10:30 WILL REVIEW THAT INFORMATION AS WELL OR ALREADY HAS.
01:10:34 I WILL SAY I BELIEVE RECOMMENDATION NUMBER TO SOME
01:10:38 OF THE COMMAND STAFF DID NOT I THINK CONCUR THAT WE SHOULD
01:10:42 HAVE A POLICY BECAUSE WHERE WE PARK LIKE A LOT OF IT'S COVERED
01:10:49 IN VEHICLE CODE AND OR LIKE THERE'S A REASON WHY WE HAVE TO
01:10:53 PARK CLOSE BY SO NOT SURE WHAT WILL COME OF THAT.
01:11:00 >> ANY QUESTIONS? >> VICE PRESIDENT BIDEN
01:11:04 DIRECTOR THANK YOU PRESIDENT CLAY THANK YOU FOR THAT
01:11:07 PRESENTATION BOTH OF YOU. SO MY QUESTION RELATES TO
01:11:11 RECOMMENDATION ONE ABOUT VIDEO 2.01 OF THREE.
01:11:14 SO THIS WAS A RECOMMENDATION BECAUSE OF THE INCIDENT WITH
01:11:18 THE THE MEMBER SEARCHING FLOCK AND THEN IT APPEARED ON SOCIAL
01:11:19 MEDIA IS THAT CORRECT? CORRECT.
01:11:22 AND SO IT'S A POLICY FIELD BECAUSE THE POLICY RIGHT NOW
01:11:25 DOESN'T CLEARLY HAVE A PROHIBITION ON THAT BEHAVIOR OR
01:11:29 JUST THERE ARE OTHER ALLEGATIONS RELATED TO THAT
01:11:30 AND THIS WAS THE ONE POLICY FAILURE IDENTIFIED SO AS TO TO
01:11:33 US IT WASN'T CLEAR AS TO LIKE HOW HOW FAR CAN YOU GO RIGHT.
01:11:38 >> LIKE SO WHEN THE OFFICER WAS INTERVIEWED WE ASKED LIKE WELL
01:11:44 WHAT WOULD YOU HAVE DONE? LIKE IF THERE WAS A HIT LIKE
01:11:47 ARE YOU GOING TO GO LOOK FOR THE CAR AND THE THE OFFICER
01:11:51 SAID WE WOULD HAVE NOTIFIED THE LOCAL LAW.
01:11:53 >> YOU KNOW, LAW ENFORCEMENT JURISDICTION.
01:11:56 >> SO WE'RE JUST WE THINK IT HAS TO BE CLEAR LIKE AT WHAT
01:12:00 POINT SHOULD YOU BE INVOLVED IF AT ALL AND THAT MAKES SENSE.
01:12:03 >> I THINK ESPECIALLY AS THE DEPARTMENT HAS MOVED TO ADOPT A
01:12:10 LOT OF THIS NEW TECHNOLOGY THAT'S HAD A LOT OF BENEFITS, I
01:12:11 WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT THE POLICIES ARE KEEPING UP
01:12:15 AND THEY'RE HAVING YOU KNOW, MAKE SURE IT'S COMPLETELY CLEAR
01:12:18 IN CASES LIKE THAT. >> IS THERE A CHIEF DO YOU HAVE
01:12:20 A RESPONSE TO RECOMMENDATION ONE ABOUT EXPANDING RULE 19 OF
01:12:25 2.1. OR THREE AND BEFORE HE ANSWERS SORRY WE HAVE WE HAD
01:12:29 ANOTHER RECENT ONE WHERE IT WAS UNCLEAR BECAUSE THE MEMBER THE
01:12:33 MEMBER DIDN'T REALLY KNOW THE PERSON BUT LIKE THE FATHER WAS
01:12:37 GOOD FRIENDS WITH HIM. SO AGAIN IT WAS KIND OF LIKE A
01:12:41 GRAY AREA SO WE JUST THINK IT HAS TO BE VERY CLEAR LIKE WHAT
01:12:45 THE RELATIONSHIP IS AND AT WHAT POINT RIGHT NOW I WOULD SAY
01:12:51 THAT WHATEVER THE CHANGE WOULD BE WE JUST NEED TO STAY IN LINE
01:12:52 WITH LIKE CLERICAL ERROR VIOLATIONS.
01:12:55 >> IT'S ON A NEED TO KNOW BASIS.
01:12:56 EXACTLY. YEAH.
01:12:57 WE HAVE THIS LANGUAGE AND THE COMMISSION HAS DEALT WITH THIS
01:12:59 IN THE CONTEXT IS THERE I KNOW SOME TIMES WHEN WE HAVE THESE
01:13:06 SORT OF SURGICAL CHANGES THAT WE IDENTIFY WE'RE ABLE TO TAKE
01:13:10 THEM AND ABLE TO UPDATE THOSE FAIRLY QUICKLY IS THERE IS THIS
01:13:13 SOMETHING THAT IS ON TRACK FOR THAT RATHER THAN WAITING FOR
01:13:18 WHENEVER 2.1 IS UP NEXT IN THE CYCLE?
01:13:21 >> I KNOW WE HAVE OH YEAH I WOULD HAVE TO REFER TO OUR
01:13:23 POLICY. >> I KNOW WE HAVE DIRECTOR
01:13:25 STEVES HERE SO WE ARE PROPOSING A REVISION TO DG OF 301 THAT
01:13:38 ALLOWS FOR A LIMITED REVISION CARVE OUT SO WHEN WE HAVE THESE
01:13:43 SITUATIONS THAT COME UP WHERE DO YOU JUST NEED A SIMPLE
01:13:46 CHANGE THROUGHOUT INSTEAD OF OPENING THE ENTIRE DID GO
01:13:50 AND OPENING THE ENTIRE PROCESS TO THAT 225 DAYS OR EVEN THE 30
01:13:53 DAYS WHICH IS THE EXPEDITED EVEN THE CURRENT 301 EXPEDITED
01:13:56 PROCESS HAS MANY RULES AND REGS THAT WE HAVE TO COMPLY WITH
01:14:01 INSTEAD OF THAT THIS NEW 3A1 PROPOSES AGAIN JUST A LIMITED
01:14:04 REVISION THAT ALLOWS FOR THESE CHANGES AND THAT IS COMING TO
01:14:08 THE COMMISSION VERY SOON. SO OUR HOPE IS THAT THAT WILL
01:14:12 ADDRESS IT OTHERWISE THE ONLY OTHER OPTION REALLY IS TO PUT
01:14:14 IT ON AN EXPEDITED REVIEW OR SLATED FOR A FUTURE UPDATE FOR
01:14:20 2027. >> OKAY.
01:14:21 I MEAN BECAUSE EVEN IF WE IF THE IF THE REVISED THE ONE THAT
01:14:29 HAS THE LIMITED REVIEW COMES BEFORE THE COMMITTEE, YOU KNOW,
01:14:31 IT'S STILL MULTIPLE MONTHS FROM FILE THAT WILL HAVE TO GO TO
01:14:36 MEETING CONFER AND COME BACK AS WELL.
01:14:39 I KNOW THAT IN THE PAST WE'VE BEEN ABLE TO MAKE CHANGES LIKE
01:14:42 THIS THAT THE COMMISSION UNDER ITS AUTHORITY HAS THE
01:14:47 POLICYMAKING BODY OF THE DEPARTMENT IS ABLE TO AT THE
01:14:50 DEPARTMENT SUGGESTION MAKE CHANGES LIKE THIS OUTSIDE OF A
01:14:53 NORMAL 3.1 PROCESS LIKE I REMEMBER IT HAD COME UP WITH
01:14:55 THAT PREEMPTIVE DEPLOYMENT OF TIME DEFLATION DEVICES AS WELL
01:15:01 OR WHEN THERE WERE ISSUES WITH BURDENSOME DATA ENTRY FOR 5.1.
01:15:05 >> SO THOSE OCCURRED THE 5A1 REVISIONS OCCURRED BEFORE THE
01:15:11 2022 301 WENT INTO PLACE IF THE COMMISSION AND THIS MIGHT BE A
01:15:15 QUESTION FOR A CITY ATTORNEY IF THERE'S A RESOLUTION THAT SAYS
01:15:16 THAT WE CAN CIRCUMVENT DID YOU GO THROUGH A ONE AND DO A
01:15:19 POLICY REVISION, MAYBE THAT'S A POTENTIAL BUT DID YOU GO
01:15:24 THROUGH A ONE AS IS IS THE AUTHORITATIVE DOCUMENT TO
01:15:28 DETERMINES HOW THOSE POLICIES ARE UPDATED AND RIGHT NOW THE
01:15:29 OPTIONS ARE WE PUT IT ON THE ANNUAL LIST RIGHT AND IT HAS TO
01:15:34 COMPLY WITH THE TIMELINE THE CHIEF CAN INITIATE THE
01:15:37 COMMISSION CAN INITIATE WITHIN THAT OPENS UP PROPERTY.
01:15:40 SO THEN THE COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT PROCESS WOULD HAVE
01:15:44 TO OCCUR OR WAY OR YOU COULD DO AN EXPEDITED REVIEW WHICH THEN
01:15:48 WE NEED TO COUNT ALL OF THE GEOS THAT WE'RE WORKING ON
01:15:52 AND SO DEPENDING ON HOW MANY WE'RE WORKING ON WE CAN ONLY DO
01:15:56 EXPEDITED SO MANY TIMES A YEAR OR WE OPEN IT UP, PUT IT ON THE
01:16:02 2027 LIST AND DO THAT OR WHICH MIGHT ACTUALLY LINE UP WITH THE
01:16:06 TIMING OF THE NEW THREE. I WANT QUITE FRANKLY.
01:16:10 OKAY. I THINK THAT'S HELPFUL.
01:16:13 MAYBE WE CAN PUT OUR HEADS BECAUSE I THINK WHAT WE'VE DONE
01:16:15 IN THE PAST IS THAT 3 OR 1 ALLOWS LIKE LIKE YOU SAID FOR
01:16:21 COMMISSION INITIATED EGOS WHICH AND THEN IF THERE WERE A WAIVER
01:16:25 FOR THE PROPERTY ANYWAY I THINK IT'S WORTH FIGURING OUT HOW WE
01:16:29 CAN YOU KNOW WE'RE SEEING WE TAKE THESE DATA ACCESS ISSUES
01:16:33 VERY SERIOUSLY. I THINK WE SHOULD MAYBE WE CAN
01:16:36 PUT OUR HEADS TOGETHER AND TRY TO FIGURE OUT THE MOST
01:16:39 EFFICIENT WAY TO TO GET THIS BEFORE THE COMMISSION.
01:16:41 >> HAPPY TO DISCUSS I THINK WE CAN LOOK IT OVER BUT WE CAN'T
01:16:44 CIRCUMVENT ANYTHING WE HAVE. >> NO, NO I DON'T MEAN
01:16:47 CIRCUMVENT I JUST MEAN THAT THE EXISTING 3.21 HAS BEEN USED
01:16:49 IN WAYS THAT HAVE ALLOWED US TO MAKE THESE CHANGES AND I KNOW
01:16:51 THAT IN THE PAST WE HAVE DONE IT BUT IN THE FUTURE WE DON'T
01:16:54 DO IT WHEN WE'RE GOING TO FIGURE IT OUT WE'LL WE'LL SIT
01:16:56 DOWN AND FIGURE IT OUT OF COURSE.
01:16:58 BUT THIS IS NOT OF OF THE ESSENCE THAT WE HAVE TO DO THIS
01:17:00 NOW WE'LL DO IT RIGHT BECAUSE THIS I HAVEN'T SEEN THIS
01:17:03 SITUATION COME UP VERY MANY TIMES BEFORE US OR BEFORE YOU
01:17:07 WERE HERE ABOUT THAT. SO WE'LL WE'LL GET IT DONE BUT
01:17:10 I'M NOT INTERESTED IN CIRCUMVENTING ANYTHING I
01:17:14 APPRECIATE THAT'S WHEN WE DO THAT THEN WE GOT PROBLEMS
01:17:15 RIGHT. ALL RIGHT.
01:17:18 >> THANK YOU. ABSOLUTELY.
01:17:19 AND TO BE CLEAR, I WAS NOT SUGGESTING WE CIRCUMVENT
01:17:20 ANYTHING AND I JUST WANT TO CLEAR BECAUSE EVERYBODY'S
01:17:22 HEARING THAT LANGUAGE AND SO YES, EXACTLY.
01:17:23 >> I JUST WANTED TO YES, I'M CERTAINLY IN AGREEMENT WITH
01:17:27 YOU. >> OKAY.
01:17:27 ALL RIGHT. >> THANK YOU.
01:17:32 >> THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
01:17:33 IF ANY MEMBER THE PART BUT I CAN MAKE PUBLIC COMMENT
01:17:37 REGARDING LINE ITEM EIGHT PLEASE APPROACH THE PODIUM
01:17:39 AND THERE IS NO PUBLIC COMMENT LINE ITEM NINE PUBLIC COMMENT
01:17:43 AND ALL MATTERS PERTAINING TO ITEM 11 BELOW CLOSED SESSION
01:17:47 INCLUDING PUBLIC COMMENT AND ITEM TEN A VOTE WHETHER TO
01:17:49 HOLD ITEM 11 IN CLOSED SESSION AND PUBLIC COMMENT AND ITEM 12
01:17:54 A VOTE WHETHER TO DISCLOSE ANY OR ALL DISCUSSION ON ITEM 11
01:17:57 HELD IN CLOSED SESSION. IF YOU'D LIKE TO MAKE PUBLIC
01:17:58 COMMENT PLEASE APPROACH THE PODIUM AND THERE IS NO PUBLIC
01:18:05 COMMENT LINE ITEM TEN A VOTE ON WHETHER TO HOLD ITEM 11
01:18:10 IN CLOSED SESSION SAN FRANCISCO ADMINISTRATIVE CODE SECTION
01:18:12 67.10 ACTION WE NEED A MOTION MOTION TO GO IN CLOSED SESSION
01:18:17 SECOND. ALL RIGHT ON THE MOTION
01:18:21 COMMISSIONER TECHIE, HOW DO YOU VOTE?
01:18:22 YES, MR. TECH. YES.
01:18:24 YES. MR. SCOTT.
01:18:25 YES. MR. SCOTT IS YES, COMMISSIONER
01:18:27 LEONE. YES.
01:18:27 MR. LEE YOUNG IS YES COMMISSIONER YEA YES.
01:18:29 COMMISSIONER. YES.
01:18:31 YES. VICE PRESIDENT BENEDICTO YES.
01:18:32 VICE PRESIDENT BENEDICTO IS YES AND PRESIDENT CLAY YES.
01:18:35 >> PRESENT CLAY IS YES. YOU HAVE SIX YESES.
01:18:36 WE ARE GOING INTO CLOSED SESSION.
01:18:39 OKAY
01:19:21 S.F. GOV TV SAN FRANCISCO GOVERNMENT TELEVISION
01:26:48 AND I WILL DO IT AND I GOT 32 LATERAL SO COMING IN YEAH I
01:27:03 MEAN SOME OF THEM ARE A LITTLE DIFFERENT.
01:27:10 >> ALL RIGHT COMMISSIONERS, WE ARE BACK IN OPEN SESSION ON
01:27:13 LINE ITEM 12 A VOTE TO ELECT WHETHER TO DISCLOSE ANY OR ALL
01:27:15 DISCUSSION ON ITEM 11 HELD IN CLOSED SESSION SAN FRANCISCO
01:27:18 ADMINISTRATIVE CODE SECTION 67.1 TO A ACTION MOTION MOTION
01:27:25 TO NOT DISCLOSE SECOND RIGHT ON THE MOTION.
01:27:32 COMMISSIONER TECHIE HOW DO YOU VOTE YES, MR. TECH YES.
01:27:34 YES. COMMISSIONER SCOTT YES.
01:27:36 >> COMMISSIONER SCOTT IS YES. COMMISSIONER LEONE YES.
01:27:37 YES. YES.
01:27:39 YES. COMMISSIONER YEA YES
01:27:40 COMMISSIONER. YES YES.
01:27:41 VICE PRESENT BENEDICTO YES. VICE PRESIDENT BENEDICTO IS YES
01:27:44 AND PRESIDENT CLAY YES. PRESENT CLAY IS YES.
01:27:47 >> YOU HAVE SIX YESES LINE ITEM 13 ADJOURNMENT.
01:27:51 >> THANK YOU EVERYONE 658 THANK YOU