00:00:12 AND GOOD AFTERNOON. THIS MEETING WILL COME TO
00:00:13 ORDER. WELCOME TO THE SEPTEMBER 21ST
00:00:16 2020 SIX REGULAR MEETING OF THE LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION
00:00:20 COMMITTEE OF THE SAN FRANCISCO BOARD SUPERVISORS I AM
00:00:23 SUPERVISOR CHEYENNE CHAN VICE CHAIR OF THE COMMITTEE AND I
00:00:27 WILL BE CHAIRING THIS MEETING TODAY IN CHAIR MINGUS ABSENCE.
00:00:31 WE ARE JOINED TODAY BY SUPERVISOR MATT DORSEY
00:00:34 AND SUPERVISOR CHEMUNG WALTON, THE COMMITTEE CLERK TODAY IS
00:00:39 JOHN CARROLL. I WOULD ALSO LIKE TO
00:00:40 ACKNOWLEDGE SUE AT NOSE AT S.F. TV FOR STAFFING THIS MEETING.
00:00:46 >> MR. CLERK, DO WE HAVE ANY ANNOUNCEMENTS?
00:00:47 YES. THANK YOU, MADAM VICE CHAIR.
00:00:48 PLEASE ENSURE THAT YOU SILENCED YOUR CELL PHONES AND OTHER
00:00:51 ELECTRONIC DEVICES YOU'VE BROUGHT WITH YOU INTO THE
00:00:52 CHAMBER TODAY. IF YOU HAVE ANY DOCUMENTS TO BE
00:00:55 INCLUDED AS PART OF ANY OF TODAY'S FILES YOU CAN SUBMIT
00:00:58 THEM DIRECTLY TO ME. >> PUBLIC COMMENT WILL BE TAKEN
00:00:59 ON EACH ITEM ON TODAY'S AGENDA WHEN YOUR ITEM OF INTEREST
00:01:03 COMES UP AND PUBLIC COMMENT IS CALLED PLEASE LINE UP TO SPEAK
00:01:05 ALONG YOUR RIGHT HAND SIDE OF THIS ROOM.
00:01:06 >> ALTERNATIVELY YOU MAY SUBMIT PUBLIC COMMENTS IN WRITING
00:01:09 IN EITHER OF THE FOLLOWING WAYS.
00:01:10 FIRST YOU MAY EMAIL YOUR COMMENTS TO ME AT G O H
00:01:14 AND PERIOD C A R O L L S F G OF YOUR AG OR YOU MAY SEND YOUR
00:01:17 WRITTEN COMMENTS VIA US POSTAL SERVICE TO OUR OFFICE IN CITY
00:01:21 HALL. THE CLERK'S OFFICE IS FROM 244
00:01:24 AND CITY HALL'S ADDRESS IS ONE DR. CARLTON BEAGLE AT PLACE SAN
00:01:28 FRANCISCO CALIFORNIA 94102. IF YOU SUBMIT PUBLIC COMMENT
00:01:30 IN WRITING I WILL FORWARD YOUR COMMENTS TO THE MEMBERS OF THIS
00:01:34 COMMITTEE AND ALSO INCLUDE YOUR COMMENTS AS PART OF THE
00:01:37 OFFICIAL FILE ON WHICH YOU ARE COMMENTING ITEMS ACTED UPON
00:01:40 TODAY ARE EXPECTED TO APPEAR ON THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS AGENDA
00:01:42 OF SEPTEMBER 29TH 2026 UNLESS OTHERWISE STATED.
00:01:48 >> THANK YOU MR. CLERK. I WOULD LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION
00:01:52 TO EXCUSED SUPERVISOR MALKA FROM THIS MEETING.
00:01:53 >> PLEASE CALL THE ROLL MOTION OFFERED BY VICE CHAIR CHEN THAT
00:01:56 SUPERVISOR MELGAR BE EXCUSED FROM THIS MEETING.
00:02:00 >> ON THAT MOTION MEMBER WALTON I WALTON I REMEMBER DORSEY
00:02:04 DORSEY I VICE CHAIR CHEN I CHEN I AND VICE CHAIR THERE ARE
00:02:09 THREE EYES THANK YOU THE MOTION PASSES MR. CLERK PASCOE ITEM
00:02:15 NUMBER ONE AGENDA ITEM NUMBER ONE IS AN ORDINANCE AMENDING
00:02:16 THE LANDMARK DESIGNATION FOR LANDMARK NUMBER 61 SYLVESTER
00:02:20 HOUSE LOCATED AT 1556 REVERE AVENUE ASSESSOR'S PARCEL BLOCK
00:02:26 NUMBER 5340 LOT NUMBER 206 UNDER ARTICLE TEN OF THE
00:02:29 PLANNING CODE TO RENAME THE LANDMARK AND RECOGNIZE THE
00:02:32 RESTORATION AND STEWARDSHIP OF FORMER OWNER LINDA BLACK OTTER.
00:02:36 IT ALSO AFFIRMS THE PLANNING DEPARTMENT'S SECRET
00:02:37 DETERMINATION TO MAKE FINDINGS OF PUBLIC NECESSITY,
00:02:40 CONVENIENCE AND WELFARE UNDER PLANNING CODE SECTION 302
00:02:43 AND FINDINGS OF CONSISTENCY WITH THE GENERAL PLAN AND THE
00:02:46 EIGHT PRIORITY POLICIES OF PLANNING CODE SECTION ONE A 1.1
00:02:49 THANK YOU MR. KERR. >> SUPERVISOR WALTON THANK YOU
00:02:53 CHAIR CHEN AND I JUST WANTED TO THANK THE COMMITTEE FOR
00:02:55 GOODNESS SCHEDULE THIS MORNING. I APPRECIATE EVERYBODY.
00:02:58 THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
00:03:01 SUPERVISOR WALTON WE NOW HAVE ALICE WESTHOFF FROM THE
00:03:05 PLANNING DEPARTMENT. >> WELCOME, MR. WESTHOFF.
00:03:23 HELLO. GOOD AFTERNOON, SUPERVISORS
00:03:26 ALEX WEST STAFF PLANNING DEPARTMENT STAFF.
00:03:27 I'M HERE SPEAKING FOR PAULA LAVALLE, ALSO A PLANNING
00:03:31 DEPARTMENT STAFF BEFORE YOU TODAY IS A PROPOSAL TO AMEND
00:03:35 LANDMARK DESIGNATION OF LANDMARK NUMBER 61 KNOWN AS THE
00:03:39 SYLVESTER HOUSE. THE AMENDMENT WAS PROPOSED BY
00:03:43 THE PROPERTY OWNER TO ADD THE NAME OF HIS DECEASED WIFE LINDA
00:03:46 BLACK, A TIER TO THE LANDMARK DESIGNATION RENAMED IT TO THE
00:03:51 BLACK CATS OR SYLVESTER HOUSE IN HONOR AND RECOGNITION OF
00:03:54 BLACK CAT TEARS DECADES LONG PRESERVATION EFFORTS OF THE
00:03:56 LANDMARK PROPERTY. THE PROPOSED AMENDMENT WAS
00:03:59 INITIATED BY THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS ON FEBRUARY 24TH,
00:04:04 2026. LANDMARK NUMBER 61 WAS
00:04:08 ORIGINALLY DESIGNATED BY THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS IN 1974
00:04:11 BUILT BETWEEN 1865 AND 1870 BY PROMINENT BUILDER STEPHEN L
00:04:17 PIPER FOR THE SYLVESTER FAMILY THIS TWO STOREY WOOD FRAME
00:04:21 STRUCTURE REPRESENTS A VARIATION IN THE ITALIANATE
00:04:23 STYLE VILLA FROM 1950S TO 1970S.
00:04:28 THE BUILDING WAS NEGLECTED AND FELL INTO DISREPAIR
00:04:34 IN 1978. FORMER OWNER LINDA BLACK HERE,
00:04:36 A PUBLIC HEALTH NURSE PURCHASED THE BUILDING AND LAUNCHED A
00:04:39 DEDICATED MULTI-DECADE RESTORATION PROJECT FOR THE
00:04:42 LANDMARK IN 2005 BLACK INTERIORS PRESERVATION WORK
00:04:46 RECEIVED THE ROBERTS FRIESS PRESERVATION AWARD PRESENTED BY
00:04:50 A SAN FRANCISCO BEAUTIFUL AT A PUBLIC HEARING ON MAY 6TH, 2026
00:04:56 ,THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION HEARD COMMENTS
00:05:00 IN SUPPORT OF THEIR PROPOSAL AND VOTED UNANIMOUSLY TO
00:05:01 RECOMMEND APPROVAL OF AMENDING LANDMARK DESIGNATION OF
00:05:06 LANDMARK 61 ADOPTING RESOLUTION 1562.
00:05:10 THE HBC RECOMMENDATION INCLUDES FINDINGS THAT LINDA BLACK
00:05:14 INTERIORS MULTI-DECADE RESTORATION OF AN IMPORTANT
00:05:17 LANDMARK IN THE BAYVIEW NEIGHBORHOOD INCLUDING
00:05:18 APPLICANT CREATION OF TRADITIONAL ARTISAN
00:05:22 CRAFTSMANSHIP AND RESTORATION OF ORIGINAL FEATURES IS
00:05:25 ARCHITECTURALLY AND HISTORICALLY SIGNIFICANT
00:05:29 AND MEETS THE REQUIREMENTS OF ARTICLE TEN.
00:05:32 THANK YOU. THAT CONCLUDES MY PRESENTATION.
00:05:33 I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS.
00:05:39 >> THANK YOU MR. WESTHOFF. I DON'T SEE MY COLLEAGUES HAVE
00:05:40 ANY QUESTIONS. >> I JUST WANT TO SAY THAT BAY
00:05:43 VIEWS IT'S RICH WITH SO MANY CULTURAL AND ARCHITECTURAL
00:05:47 RESOURCES. >> THE SYLVESTER HOUSE IS SUCH
00:05:50 A BEAUTIFULLY RESTORED HOME AND IT HAS SUCH A FASCINATING
00:05:54 STORY. MR. CLERK, PLEASE LET ME AS A
00:05:58 CO-SPONSOR TO THIS LEGISLATION AND I DON'T SEE ANY OF MY
00:06:02 COLLEAGUES HAVE QUESTIONS OR COMMENT.
00:06:03 >> LET'S ALSO GO OPEN PUBLIC COMMENTS.
00:06:06 >> THANK YOU, MADAM VICE CHAIR. LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION
00:06:09 WILL NOW HEAR PUBLIC COMMENT RELATED TO AGENDA ITEM NUMBER
00:06:12 ONE IF YOU HAVE PUBLIC COMMENT FOR THIS LANDMARK ITEM PLEASE
00:06:14 COME FORWARD TO THE LECTERN AT THIS TIME AND IT APPEARS WE
00:06:16 HAVE NO SPEAKERS. >> OKAY.
00:06:20 PUBLIC COMMENT IS NOW CLOSED. >> SUPERVISOR WALTON, WHERE YOU
00:06:24 WOULD LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION? YES, THANK YOU.
00:06:27 I MOVE THAT WE SENT ITEM ONE FORWARD TO THE FULL BOARD WITH
00:06:31 RECOMMENDATION ON THE CHAIR. >> I'M SORRY ON THE MOTION
00:06:34 OFFERED BY MEMBER WALTON THAT THIS ORDINANCE BE RECOMMENDED
00:06:36 TO THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS MEMBER WALTON I WALTON I
00:06:42 REMEMBER DORSEY DORSEY I CHAIR CHEN I VICE CHAIR CHEN MADAM
00:06:49 VICE CHAIR THERE ARE THREE EYES THANK YOU.
00:06:50 >> THE MOTION PASSES MR. CLERK, PLEASE CALL ITEM NUMBER TWO
00:06:55 AND THREE TOGETHER. AGENDA ITEM NUMBER TWO IS AN
00:06:56 ORDINANCE APPROVING AN AMENDED AND RESTATED DEVELOPMENT
00:06:59 AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
00:07:01 IN CALIFORNIA BERYL COMPANY LLC FOR THE POTRERO POWER STATION
00:07:05 MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT PROJECT INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO
00:07:09 AMENDMENTS TO ITS HOUSING PLAN TRANSPORTATION PLAN AND PHASING
00:07:11 PLAN. AGENDA ITEM NUMBER THREE IS AN
00:07:13 ORDINANCE AMENDING THE PLANNING CODE AND ZONING MAP FOR THE
00:07:17 POTRERO POWER STATION SPECIAL USE DISTRICT TO INCREASE HEIGHT
00:07:21 LIMITS AND MODIFY THE LAND USE PARKING ROOFTOP PERTINENCE
00:07:24 BUILDING DESIGN AND BUILDING APPROVAL REQUIREMENTS
00:07:26 APPLICABLE WITHIN THE SPECIAL USE DISTRICT.
00:07:30 EACH ORDINANCE MAKES THE APPROPRIATE SCOPE FINDINGS
00:07:33 AND FINDINGS OF CONSISTENCY WITH THE GENERAL PLAN AND THE
00:07:34 IT PARTY POLICIES PLANNING CODE SECTION 11.1 AS WELL AS PUBLIC
00:07:37 NECESSITY, CONVENIENCE AND WELFARE FINDINGS UNDER
00:07:38 PLANNING CODE SECTION THREE ZERO TWO THANK YOU MR. CLERK
00:07:43 SUPERVISOR BISON WALTON THANK YOU, CHAIR CHIN I JUST WANT TO
00:07:45 STATE FOR THE PUBLIC AND TO OF COURSE EVERYONE WHO UNDERSTANDS
00:07:51 THE WORK HAPPENING AT THE POWER STATION THAT THE POWER STATION
00:07:55 REALLY HAS BEEN AN IMPORTANT PIECE OF GROWTH FOR DISTRICT
00:08:00 TEN. THE DOGPATCH IN THE PATROL
00:08:03 COMMUNITIES AND OF COURSE FOR THE CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN
00:08:05 FRANCISCO AS A WHOLE IN SHOWING THE FIRST HOUSING BUILT ON THE
00:08:10 SITE WAS AFFORDABLE LISTENING TO THE NEEDS OF COMMUNITY
00:08:14 AND WORKING WITH UCSF ON THE STATE OF THE ART CANCER CENTER
00:08:19 HAVE BEEN KEY INDICATORS OF HOW THE PEOPLE HAVE BEEN INCLUDED
00:08:22 IN THE WORK PARKS AND OPEN SPACE, NEW BUSINESSES, JOBS
00:08:26 AND OPPORTUNITY HIGHLIGHT JUST A PIECE OF WHAT IS YET TO COME
00:08:33 AT THE POWER STATION. BUT LIKE MOST DEVELOPMENTS ONE
00:08:37 OF THIS SIZE AND SCOPE AND WITH TIMING CHANGES MAY BE NECESSARY
00:08:41 IN ORDER FOR THE COMMUNITY TO RECEIVE MAXIMUM BENEFIT.
00:08:45 SO WE'RE HERE TODAY BECAUSE OF SOME OF THOSE CHANGES THAT ARE
00:08:49 NECESSARY TO MOVE FORWARD. THE HOUSING BUSINESS
00:08:52 OPPORTUNITIES, CHILD CARE OPPORTUNITIES AND AMENITIES
00:08:56 PROMISE TO COMMUNITY AND NEIGHBORS.
00:09:00 WE ALSO KNOW THAT NO PROJECT IS PERFECT AND THAT THERE ARE
00:09:04 TIMES WHEN MY OFFICE HAS TO STEP IN AND REMIND DEVELOPERS
00:09:07 THAT COMMUNITY VOICE TAKES PRECEDENCE.
00:09:11 >> EARLIER PROPOSED CHANGES WOULD HAVE ALLOWED FOR DATA
00:09:12 CENTERS ON THE SITE OR AT LEAST THE CONVERSATION OF A DATA
00:09:18 CENTER. NEW AMENDED LANGUAGE REMOVES
00:09:19 THAT POSSIBILITY. I AM NOT HAPPY ABOUT THE FACT
00:09:24 THAT THESE SITES WERE LISTED AND WERE PROPOSED IN THE FIRST
00:09:30 PLACE PARTICULARLY WITHOUT COMMUNITY INPUT, WITHOUT
00:09:31 CONVERSATION AS WITH LEADERSHIP OF THIS CITY.
00:09:35 >> BUT THE AMENDMENTS HAVE REMOVED THAT LANGUAGE AND I
00:09:39 WILL HAVE SOME VERY SPECIFIC QUESTIONS FOR THE CITY ATTORNEY
00:09:43 AND PRESENTERS POSSIBLY AFTER THE PRESENTATION.
00:09:47 >> THANK YOU CHAIR CHAN THANK YOU SUPERVISOR WALTON WE HAVE
00:09:54 TWO DEPARTMENT PRESENTATION ONE FROM OFFICE OF ECONOMIC
00:09:57 WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT AND ONE FROM PLANNING DEPARTMENT.
00:09:58 >> LET'S HAVE JOHN LAO FROM EWG .
00:10:05 >> THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
00:10:06 AND FOR THAT INTRODUCTION SUPERVISOR I AM HERE WITH
00:10:09 MONICA JACK MUCCI FROM THE SENIOR PLANNER AT THE PLANNING
00:10:13 DEPARTMENT. >> SO IF WE COULD SWITCH TO THE
00:10:17 SLIDES. SO THERE WE GO.
00:10:19 >> YES. AS WAS STATED WE'RE HERE TODAY
00:10:20 BECAUSE ARE A SET OF TARGETED AMENDMENTS TO BOTH ORDINANCES
00:10:24 THAT IMPLEMENT THE DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT EXCUSE ME.
00:10:30 >> I'LL JUST QUICKLY SET THE CONTEXT OF SORT OF WHY THIS
00:10:34 PROJECT WAS SO IMPORTANT TO PURSUE IN THE FIRST PLACE
00:10:38 AND WHAT IT ACCOMPLISHES A LITTLE BIT MORE ON WHAT
00:10:42 SUPERVISOR WALTON TOUCHED ON THIS HAS BEEN A KEY PIECE OF A
00:10:46 BROADER PUBLIC AND PRIVATE INVESTMENT STRATEGY OVER THE
00:10:49 PAST 12 TO 15 YEARS. WILL SAY LONGER IN THE CASE OF
00:10:53 MISSION BAY OF COURSE. >> BUT FOCUSING INVESTMENT ON
00:10:56 OUR CENTRAL BAYFRONT CREATING HOUSING OPPORTUNITIES WHERE
00:11:00 NONE EXISTED PREVIOUSLY AND IMPORTANTLY OPENING UP
00:11:07 WATERFRONT TO PUBLIC ACCESS AND ENJOYMENT WHERE THAT SIMPLY
00:11:11 DID NOT EXIST BEFORE ARE THERE. >> NEXT SLIDE PLEASE.
00:11:15 >> AND SO THIS IS WHAT WE NEGOTIATED AND AFTER SEVERAL
00:11:19 YEARS LEADING UP TO ADOPTION IN 2020 A ROBUST PROGRAM A
00:11:23 BALANCED PROGRAM OF HOUSING AND OFFICE POTENTIAL AGAIN
00:11:30 CRITICAL OPEN SPACE IN ITS SYSTEM AND SETTING ON THE
00:11:37 WATERFRONT. THIS WAS APPROVED BY THE BOARD
00:11:41 IN IN 2020 SOON AFTER THE COVID SHUTDOWN BEGAN.
00:11:45 I THOUGHT IT WAS SAFE TO SAY IT'S THE FIRST DAY EVER
00:11:47 APPROVED UNDER REMOTE CONDITIONS AND THIS WAS
00:11:51 APPROVED VIA A REMOTE HEARING AT THAT TIME AND AGAIN
00:11:58 ACTIVATION ON THE WATERFRONT IS JUST SUCH A KEY FOCUS OF THIS
00:12:02 ENTIRE PROGRAM. >> THAT'S WHY I KEEP SHOWING
00:12:06 SLIDES IT AND MENTIONING IT. IT'S JUST INCREDIBLY EXCITING
00:12:10 TO HAVE DENSE, VIBRANT NEIGHBORHOOD IN A WATERFRONT
00:12:14 SETTING. THIS IS SOMETHING PRETTY RARE
00:12:17 FOR SAN FRANCISCO AND WE LOOK FORWARD TO CONTINUING OUR ROADS
00:12:21 IMPLEMENTATION ON THIS VERY BRIEFLY I WON'T READ THROUGH
00:12:25 THIS. THIS AGAIN WAS WHAT WAS
00:12:29 APPROVED IN 2020 A VERY ROBUST PUBLIC BENEFITS PACKAGE IN ALL
00:12:32 THE AREAS THAT YOU SEE THERE. OBVIOUSLY A LOT OF CONSTRUCTION
00:12:37 AND FORCE AND USER SORRY WORKFORCE OPPORTUNITIES ALL OF
00:12:40 WHICH IS SUBJECT TO FIRST SOURCE AND AND AND MANY OTHER
00:12:47 AREAS THAT WE NEGOTIATED, YOU KNOW AND THANK YOU.
00:12:51 >> WE'RE GOING TO NEXT TIME WRITE SOME AGAIN A FLAVOR OF
00:12:55 THE VITALITY THAT WE'RE ALL SEEKING TO EXPERIENCE HERE
00:12:59 AND IN THE NEAR FUTURE. AND THEN AS TO TODAY, AS WAS
00:13:03 MENTIONED WITH THAT INCREDIBLY ROBUST BENEFITS PACKAGE THAT WE
00:13:09 NEGOTIATED IN 2020 AND CHANGING ECONOMIC CONDITIONS SUCH AS THE
00:13:14 WORLD HAS NOT SEEN FOR DECADES ,THE DEVELOPER CAME TO US A
00:13:18 LITTLE OVER A YEAR AGO ASKING TO WORK IN PARTNERSHIP TO
00:13:21 IDENTIFY AREAS WHERE WE MIGHT BE ABLE TO PULL SOME ADDITIONAL
00:13:25 LEVERS TO INTRODUCE FLEXIBILITY TO HELP THE PROJECT ALONG.
00:13:32 THIS IS A PROJECT SPONSOR WHO HAS BUILT THROUGH THE PANDEMIC
00:13:36 ADMIRABLY SO AS WAS MENTIONED, HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS OF DOLLARS
00:13:40 IN INFRASTRUCTURE AND A STAND ALONE 100% BELOW MARKET RATE
00:13:44 RESIDENTIAL PROJECTS SO WE ROLLED UP OUR SLEEVES AND WENT
00:13:48 AHEAD LOOKING FOR AREAS WHERE WE COULD INDEED INTRODUCE SOME
00:13:52 ADDED FLEXIBILITY AND MONICA WILL HAVE A LITTLE BIT MORE ON
00:13:55 THOSE ITEMS THAT WERE BEFORE THE PLANNING COMMISSION ABOUT A
00:13:57 MONTH AND A HALF AGO. >> THANK YOU JOHN AND GOOD
00:14:05 AFTERNOON SUPERVISORS MONICA JACKIE MOODY WITH PLANNING
00:14:08 STAFF. AS JOHN JUST NOTED, THE OVERALL
00:14:10 THEME OF THIS PACKAGE OF AMENDMENTS WAS REALLY
00:14:13 FLEXIBILITY AND FEASIBILITY. SO THE PREVIOUS SLIDE SHOWED A
00:14:16 FEW EXAMPLES OF VERY HIGH LEVEL ITEMS THAT ARE BEING AMENDED
00:14:21 IN THE DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT. I'LL DO THE SAME OVER THE NEXT
00:14:24 COUPLE OF SLIDES TALKING THROUGH KIND OF THE HIGHEST
00:14:27 LEVEL MOST COMMON SENSE ITEMS THAT WE DECIDED TO GO AHEAD
00:14:31 AND WORK WITH THE SPONSOR TO AMEND.
00:14:34 SO THIS FIRST ONE SHOWS SORT OF LAND USE CONTROLS AGAIN AT A
00:14:36 HIGH LEVEL THERE WAS MUCH MORE THAN THIS BUT I WANTED TO
00:14:39 HIGHLIGHT SOME INTERESTING OPTIONS THAT WERE PUT INTO THE
00:14:43 DAY. SO FOR INSTANCE BLOCKS FIVE
00:14:46 AND 12 WERE RESTRICTED TO ONLY RESIDENTIAL AND COMMERCIAL USE
00:14:48 RESPECTIVELY AND NOW BOTH CAN BE DEVELOPED WITH BOTH
00:14:51 RESIDENTIAL AND COMMERCIAL PUBLIC FACILITIES WERE
00:14:55 PREVIOUSLY UNPERMITTED AND NOW ARE PERMITTED ACROSS THE SITE
00:14:58 WHICH OPENS NEW OPPORTUNITIES OUTSIDE OF MORE CONVENTIONAL
00:14:59 COMMERCIAL AND RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT.
00:15:02 >> THE SUDDEN D4D ALSO HAD A NUMBER OF OVERLY RESTRICTIVE
00:15:06 CONTROLS SUCH AS ONLY ONE ROOFTOP BAR BEING PERMITTED AT
00:15:10 THE SITE AT BLOCK NINE AND OF COURSE THE SITE WILL HAVE
00:15:12 EXCELLENT VIEWS OF THE BAY AND SKYLINE IT ALREADY DOES BUT
00:15:16 EVEN MORE SO WHEN DEVELOPMENT HAPPENS AND WE HAVE SOME TALLER
00:15:19 BUILDINGS ON THE SITE. SO CITY STAFF WORKED WITH THE
00:15:21 SPONSOR TO RELAX THAT CONTROL AND ALLOW ROOFTOP BARS ANYWHERE
00:15:24 ON THE SITE. NEXT SLIDE PLEASE.
00:15:27 JOHN, THANKS. >> AND THEN WE OF COURSE ALSO
00:15:30 WORKED ON SOME CHANGES TO ACTUAL BUILDING AND DEVELOPMENT
00:15:33 CONTROLS IN THE SAME VEIN WHICH COULD MAKE BUILDINGS THEMSELVES
00:15:34 SLIGHTLY MORE NIMBLE TO CONSTRUCT.
00:15:37 A GOOD EXAMPLE OF THIS OR THE RANGE OF VERY SPECIFIC HEIGHT
00:15:41 INCREASES ACROSS THE SITE SUCH AS ALLOWING AN ADDITIONAL EIGHT
00:15:45 FEET FOR ANY RESIDENTIAL USE WHICH REALLY JUST ALLOWS SOME
00:15:48 FLEXIBILITY WHEN IT COMES TO BUILDING SYSTEMS
00:15:49 AND INTERSTITIAL SPACES BETWEEN FLOORS AND THEN SKIPPING DOWN A
00:15:53 BIT ON THIS PARTICULAR TABLE INCREASING THE HEIGHT OF BLOCK
00:15:57 15 WHICH IS PLANNED FOR A MAJOR OFFICE USE AND KIND OF AN
00:16:00 ANCHOR OF THE SITE FROM 160FT TO 190FT WHICH ALLOWS A
00:16:04 SLIGHTLY LARGER SQUARE FOOTAGE TOTAL THAT MAKES THIS
00:16:07 PARTICULAR BUILDING MORE COMPETITIVE IN THE OFFICE
00:16:11 LEASING MARKET WITHOUT DRAMATICALLY IMPACTING THE
00:16:14 OVERALL URBAN DESIGN VISION FOR THIS SITE.
00:16:15 >> NEXT SLIDE. >> AND FINALLY AGAIN ON THE
00:16:19 THEME OF COMMON SENSE CHANGES, WE ALSO WORKED WITH THE SPONSOR
00:16:23 ON ALIGNING SOME OF THE DESIGN CONTROLS AND THE DFAT WITH THE
00:16:26 MANY PLANNING CODE AMENDMENTS THAT HAVE COME THROUGH OVER THE
00:16:30 LAST FEW YEARS THAT ARE MEANT TO EASE RESTRICTIONS ON
00:16:31 DEVELOPMENT ACROSS THE CITY. SO FOR INSTANCE A GOOD EXAMPLE
00:16:37 WOULD BE 100% AFFORDABLE BUILDINGS AT POWER STATION ARE
00:16:38 NOW SUBJECT TO THE SAME CONTROLS THAT ARE 100%
00:16:41 AFFORDABLE PROJECT ANYWHERE IN THE CITY CAN USE AS PART OF
00:16:45 THE FAMILY ZONING PLAN. AND SIMILARLY OPEN SPACE
00:16:48 REQUIREMENTS FOR MARKET RATE PROJECTS NOW ALSO ALIGN WITH
00:16:50 FAMILY ZONING. AND THE LAST ITEM I'D HIGHLIGHT
00:16:52 IS THAT WE ARE NOW ALLOWING AN ABOVE GRADE CIRCULATION
00:16:56 STRUCTURE IN SPECIFIC OPEN SPACES FOR ACCESS TO A BELOW
00:16:59 GRADE PARKING GARAGE WHERE PREVIOUSLY THE STUDY AND D4D
00:17:03 WERE KIND OF SILENT ON THE INGRESS AND EGRESS TO THIS
00:17:04 STRUCTURE. SO AGAIN IT'S JUST MOSTLY
00:17:07 COMMON SENSE CHANGES THAT ARE ALLOWED ALLOWING MORE
00:17:08 FLEXIBILITY FOR DEVELOPMENT. >> NEXT SLIDE PLEASE.
00:17:11 AS YOU ALL KNOW, SUPERVISOR WALTON AND MAYOR LEARY
00:17:15 INTRODUCED TWO ORDINANCES AT THE BOARD ON JUNE 30TH.
00:17:20 FIRST AN ORDINANCE UNDER BOARD FILE NUMBER 260724 WOULD
00:17:23 AUTHORIZE AN AMENDMENT TO THE DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT IN THE
00:17:25 FORM OF AN AMENDED AND RESTATED DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT
00:17:28 AND SECONDLY THE ORDINANCE UNDER BOARD FILE NUMBER 260770
00:17:31 WOULD AMEND THE PLANNING CODE AND ZONING MAP BY MODIFYING
00:17:35 PLANNING CODE SECTION 249 .87 >> WHICH IS THE POWER STATION
00:17:38 SPECIAL USE DISTRICT OR STUDY AND MODIFYING THE HEIGHTENED
00:17:42 BULK MAP TO ZERO EIGHT. ON JULY 30TH THOSE TWO PLANNING
00:17:46 CODE AMENDMENTS AS WELL AS AN AMENDMENT TO THE FOUR D WERE
00:17:50 HEARD AT THE PLANNING COMMISSION.
00:17:51 THE COMMISSION ADVANCED THE DAY AND CITY ORDINANCE TO YOU WITH
00:17:54 APPROVAL WITH RECOMMENDATIONS FOR APPROVAL AND SOME VERY
00:17:57 SURGICAL MODIFICATIONS. >> AND I DO WANT TO TAKE A
00:18:02 MOMENT TO WALK THROUGH THOSE AT A HIGH LEVEL.
00:18:04 >> SO AFTER CONSULTATION WITH CITY ATTORNEY STAFF, THE
00:18:09 COMMISSION RECOMMENDED THAT THE STUDY ORDINANCE WHICH IS WHAT
00:18:12 WE'RE LOOKING AT HERE BE MODIFIED TO INCLUDE SORT OF
00:18:14 MORE CONCRETE LANGUAGE REGARDING THE ABOVE GRADE
00:18:17 ACCESSORY PARKING STRUCTURE THAT I JUST MENTIONED IN OPEN
00:18:20 SPACES. SO IT WAS A SITUATION WHERE IT
00:18:24 HAD BEEN INCLUDED IN THE DRAFT DESIGN FOR DEVELOPMENT AND CITY
00:18:25 ATTORNEY WANTED US TO ALSO INCLUDE THAT IN THE STUDY AS
00:18:28 WELL. SO A LITTLE BIT OF A TECHNICAL
00:18:31 MODIFICATION AND WE ALSO TOOK THAT OPPORTUNITY TO JUST DO
00:18:35 SOME VERY LIGHT CLEANUP NEXT. >> AS FOR THE DEVELOPMENT
00:18:39 AGREEMENT ORDINANCE, THE COMMISSION RECOMMENDED
00:18:42 MODIFICATIONS THAT JUST WEREN'T ABLE TO BE FINALIZED UNTIL THAT
00:18:45 PERIOD SORT OF BETWEEN INTRODUCTION ON JUNE 30TH AT
00:18:48 THE BOARD AND THEN THE COMMISSION HEARING ON JULY
00:18:50 30TH. >> SO THOSE MODIFICATION ONES
00:18:53 INCLUDE CHANGES TO THE TRANSPORTATION DEMAND
00:18:54 MANAGEMENT OR TDM PLAN RELATED TO PROVISION OF A SHUTTLE BUS.
00:18:58 >> AND RELATED TO THE CALCULATION OF REPORTING OF
00:19:01 VEHICLE TRIPS FOR A MITIGATION MEASURE, THE COMMISSION ALSO
00:19:04 RECOMMENDED MODIFICATIONS TO THE TRANSPORTATION PLAN WHICH
00:19:05 IS AN EXHIBIT OF THE DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT RELATED
00:19:09 TO A MUNI BUS SHELTER PLAN FOR BLOCK 12 AND TO MAKE SOME
00:19:12 CLARIFYING EDITS REGARDING COORDINATION WITH S.F. MTA
00:19:15 AND PUBLIC WORKS. AND JOHN AND I OF COURSE WOULD
00:19:16 BE HAPPY TO ELABORATE ON THOSE IF YOU HAD ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT
00:19:20 THEM SPECIFICALLY. >> NEXT UP PLEASE.
00:19:23 >> OKAY. SO TO RECAP THE ITEMS BEFORE
00:19:24 YOU TODAY, THOSE WOULD BE FORWARDING A RECOMMENDATION OF
00:19:28 APPROVAL TO THE BOARD FOR AN AMENDED AND RESTATED DAY WITH
00:19:31 THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S RECOMMENDED MODIFICATIONS
00:19:35 RELATED TO THE TIEDEMANN TRANSPORTATION PLAN.
00:19:36 LIKE I MENTIONED AND ALSO FORWARDING A RECOMMENDATION OF
00:19:39 APPROVAL TO THE BOARD FOR THE POWER STATION STUDY PLANNING
00:19:42 CODE SECTION 249 .78 >> OR EIGHT SEVEN.
00:19:46 I ALWAYS GET THAT BACKWARDS WITH THE COMMISSION'S
00:19:48 RECOMMENDED MODIFICATIONS TO INCLUDE A REFERENCE TO THAT
00:19:50 ABOVE GRADE PARKING STRUCTURE SO THAT INCLUDES THAT CONCLUDES
00:19:53 MY PORTION OF THAT'S THE PLANNING COMMISSION RECAP.
00:19:57 >> SO I WILL GO AHEAD AND TURN IT BACK OVER TO JOHN THANK YOU
00:20:01 . THANKS MONICA AND I'LL JUST A
00:20:04 QUICKLY BRING US DOWN THE HOMESTRETCH HERE SO AS MONICA
00:20:08 REVIEWED THE THE CHANGES THAT WENT THROUGH COMMISSION REALLY
00:20:12 SOME CLARIFICATION CLEANUP TARGETED ADJUSTMENTS WAS REALLY
00:20:16 THE NAME OF THE GAME AND IN SEEKING WAYS TO PROVIDE
00:20:20 ADDITIONAL FLEXIBILITY AND HELP GET SUBSEQUENT PHASES OF THE
00:20:22 PROJECT GOING. >> SO MONICA MENTIONED THE
00:20:28 LATER BREAKING CHANGES THAT THE COMMISSION WAS ABLE TO
00:20:32 INCORPORATE. THERE WERE HAVE BEEN A FEW
00:20:33 CHANGES SINCE THAT TIME THAT ARE ALSO BEFORE YOU YOU'VE GOT
00:20:36 AMENDED VERSIONS OF THE ORDINANCES AGAIN I CAN I WON'T
00:20:40 WALK THROUGH THEM NOW I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT
00:20:44 THEM BUT CLARIFICATION FOR INSTANCE ON IMPLEMENTING
00:20:47 LANGUAGE IN THE DATE SELF THAT'S NECESSARY TO DO SOME OF
00:20:52 THE THINGS THAT THE ORDINANCE SAYS SUCH AS WAVE ONE KIND OF
00:20:58 DPW STREET USE FOR CLARIFICATION THAT THE PROJECT
00:21:01 IS ABLE TO PARTICIPATE IN THE RECENT LEGISLATION AIMED AT
00:21:06 REDUCING IMPACT FEES MORE BROADLY THERE'S ONLY ONE THEORY
00:21:09 THAT THIS PROJECT PAYS INTO AND THAT BEING TSF SO THAT KIND
00:21:13 OF CLARIFYING LANGUAGE AND ACTUALLY ESTABLISHING
00:21:16 IMPLEMENTATION PROGRAM FOR THE NON POTABLE WATER ORDINANCE
00:21:21 THAT THE PUC WORKS ON AND WE'VE WORKED ON ALL OF THESE CHANGES
00:21:22 WITH THE RELEVANT DEPARTMENTS BE THEY PUBLIC WORKS OR PUC
00:21:25 ETC. SO IT'S LIKE THIS IS THE FINAL IT'S THE FINAL VOTE
00:21:32 AND THAT CONCLUDES OUR PRESENTATIONS IMPROVISERS WE
00:21:35 ARE AVAILABLE FOR QUESTIONS ON THE PROJECT SPONSOR AS WELL AS
00:21:40 IN ATTENDANCE HERE TODAY. >> THANK YOU.
00:21:43 THANK YOU. SO BOTH WALTER THANK YOU SO
00:21:48 MUCH CHAIR CHIN AND JUST A COUPLE OF QUESTIONS FOR CITY
00:21:51 ATTORNEY RUSTY. >> THE FIRST ONE IS DOES THE
00:21:55 LANGUAGE IN THE AMENDMENT ELIMINATE THE PERMITTING OF
00:21:59 DATA CENTERS? >> GOOD AFTERNOON SUPERVISORS.
00:22:03 DEPUTY CITY ATTORNEY BRAD RUSTY THE ORDINANCE AS AS INTRODUCED
00:22:09 WAS WOULD HAVE ALLOWED INTERNET SERVICE EXCHANGES WHICH INCLUDE
00:22:13 DATA CENTERS AS A CONDITIONAL USE AUTHORIZATION AND BLOCK
00:22:17 FIVE AND THE AMENDMENTS THAT ARE UNDER CONSIDERATION TODAY
00:22:20 WOULD REMOVE THAT CONDITIONAL USE POSSIBILITY AND MAKE DATA
00:22:24 CENTERS AND OTHER INTERNET EXCHANGES NOT PERMITTED.
00:22:28 AND WHERE DOES THAT LANGUAGE EXIST IN THE STUDY ORDINANCE IT
00:22:36 IS ON PAGE IN PAGE 15 LINE 15 OF THE AMEND THE AMENDMENTS
00:22:46 THAT ARE UNDER CONSIDERATION. >> GOT IT.
00:22:48 AND THANK YOU BRAD AND THIS IS TO EITHER ONE OF THE
00:22:53 DEPARTMENTS CAN ANSWER BUT THE THE LEGISLATION REFERENCES
00:22:57 CERTAIN WAIVERS FOR THE PROJECT TO ANY OF THOSE WAIVERS INCLUDE
00:23:03 APPROVAL FOR DATA CENTERS NO THERE WOULD BE NO SUCH RELIEF
00:23:11 OR WAIVER FROM DATA CENTER LEGISLATION OR CITYWIDE
00:23:15 CONTROLS SHOULD THEY BE IMPLEMENTED AND I KNOW THERE
00:23:19 WE'VE BEEN HAVING SOME CONVERSATIONS FOR A LITTLE BIT
00:23:23 OF TIME NOW WITH THE DEVELOPER ABOUT HAVING JETSKIS ON SITE
00:23:27 FOR WATER RESCUE AND JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE THERE'S ANY OF
00:23:31 THIS LANGUAGE HAMPER THAT ABILITY FOR US TO BE ABLE TO
00:23:38 HAVE THE JETSKIS ON SITE FOR WATER RESCUE THE DATA CENTER
00:23:41 CONTROL AS PROPOSED NO OR NOTHING IN THE PACKET OR
00:23:46 ANYTHING? THAT'S RIGHT.
00:23:47 SUPERVISOR NO, I DON'T THINK THAT WOULD BE PROHIBITED BY
00:23:50 ANYTHING BEFORE YOU TODAY. >> THANK YOU AND I'M SORRY
00:23:57 MADAM CHAIR I SHOULD HAVE CLARIFIED IN MY PRESENTATION
00:24:01 THAT REQUEST TO THE COMMITTEE TODAY BECAUSE CITY ATTORNEY HAS
00:24:04 DEEMED THERE IS ONE ELEMENT IN THE CHANGES BEFORE YOU THAT
00:24:08 HAS BEEN DEEMED SUBSTANTIVE SO IT WILL NEED TO SIT FOR A WEEK.
00:24:10 SO WE'RE ASKING SIMPLY TO ACCEPT THE AMENDMENTS TODAY
00:24:13 AND CONTINUE FOR ONE WEEK. THANK YOU FOR SEEING NO OTHER
00:24:20 COLLEAGUES ON MR. PLEASE OPEN FOR PUBLIC COMMENT.
00:24:27 >> THANK YOU MADAM VICE CHAIR. LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION
00:24:29 WILL NOW HEAR PUBLIC COMMENT FOR AGENDA ITEM NUMBERS TWO
00:24:31 AND THREE CALLED TOGETHER RELATED TO THE PATROL POWER
00:24:35 STATION MIXED USE SPECIAL DEVELOPMENT PROJECT IF YOU HAVE
00:24:36 PUBLIC COMMENT FOR THESE ITEMS PLEASE LINE UP TO SPEAK ALONG
00:24:40 THAT WESTERN WALL AND THE FOUR SPEAKER CAN COME FORWARD TO THE
00:24:42 LECTERN AT THIS TIME. >> GOOD AFTERNOON SUPERVISOR
00:24:46 ZACH WEISENBERG OR WITH YOUNG COMMUNITY DEVELOPERS.
00:24:50 I WANT TO START BY THANKING SUPERVISOR WALTON FOR ACTING ON
00:24:52 THE COMMUNITY'S CONCERNS AROUND THE PROPOSED DATA CENTER USE
00:24:54 AND WE APPRECIATE THE REMOVAL OF THAT LANGUAGE FROM THE
00:24:57 APPLICATION. HOWEVER, WE STILL HAVE CONCERNS
00:24:58 AROUND THE DEVELOPER'S REQUEST FOR EXEMPTIONS RELATED TO
00:25:01 INTERMEDIATE LENGTH OCCUPANCIES OR ALOS WHICH WERE NOT
00:25:04 DISCUSSED DURING THE JULY PLANNING COMMISSION HEARING.
00:25:07 THE DEVELOPER IS SEEKING AN EXEMPTION FROM MULTIPLE
00:25:09 COMPONENTS OF THE CITY'S EXISTING AIELLO FRAMEWORK
00:25:11 INCLUDING THE CITYWIDE AND GEOGRAPHIC CAPS COMPLIANCE
00:25:15 REQUIREMENTS AND ANNUAL REPORTING.
00:25:16 THIS FRAMEWORK WAS CAREFULLY CREATED WITH A CLEAR POLICY
00:25:20 RATIONALE TO ENCOURAGE DWELLING UNITS TO BE USED FOR LONG TERM
00:25:21 OCCUPANCY BY PERMANENT RESIDENTS.
00:25:24 THE DEVELOPER IS SEEKING THIS EXEMPTION NOW TO PRESERVE THE
00:25:27 ABILITY TO PURSUE ISLANDS IN THE FUTURE BUT THERE'S NO
00:25:29 DEMONSTRATED NEED FOR THIS EXEMPTION AS THERE IS STILL
00:25:32 SUBSTANTIAL CAPACITY UNDER BOTH THE CITYWIDE AND GEOGRAPHIC
00:25:33 CAPS. THE PROPOSED EXEMPTIONS WOULD
00:25:36 ALLOW THIS PROJECT TO OPERATE OUTSIDE MULTIPLE SAFEGUARDS
00:25:39 THAT THE CITY ESTABLISHED TO REGULATE IGHALO'S INCLUDING
00:25:40 WHERE THEY CAN BE LOCATED, HOW MANY CAN BE ESTABLISHED, HOW
00:25:44 THEY ARE APPROVED AND HOW THEY ARE TRACKED.
00:25:46 THIS AMENDMENT WOULD CREATE A SEPARATE REGULATORY PATHWAY FOR
00:25:48 THIS PROJECT. THE REPORTING EXEMPTION IS
00:25:50 PARTICULARLY CONCERNING. WITHOUT THIS REPORTING
00:25:52 REQUIREMENT THE CITY MAY NOT KNOW HOW MANY IOLO UNITS EXIST
00:25:54 WHERE THEY'RE LOCATED, HOW THEY'RE BEING USED OR HOW LONG
00:25:58 PEOPLE ARE ACTUALLY STAYING IN THEM.
00:25:59 WE SHOULD NOT CREATE A SEPARATE CATEGORY OF IOLO UNITS THAT
00:26:02 OPERATE OUTSIDE THE STANDARD ACCOUNTABILITY SYSTEM.
00:26:03 THE POTENTIAL SCALE IS ALSO SIGNIFICANT.
00:26:06 >> 200 UNITS WOULD EQUAL 20% OF THE CITY'S ENTIRE YELLOW CAP
00:26:09 IN A SINGLE DEVELOPMENT GRANTING A PROJECT SPECIFIC
00:26:12 EXEMPTION OF THIS SCALE COULD SET A DANGEROUS PRECEDENT
00:26:13 AND RISKS RENDERING THE CITY'S EXISTING FRAMEWORK MOOT.
00:26:16 WE DO NOT OBJECT TO THE DEVELOPER PURSUING IGHALO'S BUT
00:26:20 THE PROJECT SHOULD HAVE TO COMPLY WITH THE CITY'S EXISTING
00:26:21 REGULATORY FRAMEWORK. A RESPECTFULLY REQUEST THAT THE
00:26:24 PROPOSED IOLO EXEMPTIONS BE REMOVED.
00:26:25 >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU FOR YOUR COMMENTS.
00:26:28 SO THE NEXT SPEAKER PLACE GOOD AFTERNOON SUPERVISOR WALTON
00:26:31 AND THE LAND USE COMMITTEE JEANTEL OUR TALENTO WITH WRAP
00:26:35 UP OF THE RECENT EQUITY AND ALL PLANNING COALITION.
00:26:36 >> REP STAFF IS OPPOSED TO THE PROPOSAL TO INCLUDE ANY IOLO
00:26:42 UNITS ARE EXEMPTED FROM THE CITY'S RECENTLY ENACTED ILO CAP
00:26:44 AND MONITORING PROGRAM. NOT ONLY WOULD THIS UNDERMINE
00:26:47 THE INTEGRITY AND IMPORTANCE OF THE ILO PROGRAM, IT'S NOT
00:26:50 NECESSARY. >> THE ILO PROGRAM INCLUDES A
00:26:54 1000 UNIT CITYWIDE CAP WITH NO MORE THAN ONE THIRD OF THESE
00:26:57 UNITS BEING LOCATED OUTSIDE THE C THREE ZONING DISTRICTS OF THE
00:27:00 DOWNTOWN CORE. >> THE DEVELOPMENT IS ALSO
00:27:01 LOCATED IN A SENSITIVE COMMUNITY AND NO MORE THAN A
00:27:05 THIRD OF THE 1000 TOTAL ILO'S CAN BE LOCATED IN SENSITIVE
00:27:07 COMMUNITIES. >> THESE CAPS AND CONTROLS ON
00:27:11 GEOGRAPHIC DISTRIBUTION OF ILO'S ARE IMPORTANT
00:27:14 AND CRITICAL ASPECTS OF THE ILO LEGISLATION LONG TERM HOUSING
00:27:16 POLICIES ALSO ENCOURAGE DWELLING UNITS TO BE USED FOR
00:27:19 LONG TERM OCCUPANCY BY PERMANENT SAN FRANCISCO
00:27:22 RESIDENTS. >> THEREFORE IF ALL THOSE ARE
00:27:23 PERMITTED AS PART OF FIFTH SPACES DEVELOPMENT THEY MUST BE
00:27:27 SUBJECT TO THE ILO COMPLIANCE FRAMEWORK AND MUST ADHERE TO
00:27:30 THE ANNUAL REPORTING AND ACCOUNTABILITY REQUIRED FOR
00:27:34 ILO UNITS. ONCE THESE ILO'S ARE NO LONGER
00:27:35 NEEDED THESE UNITS MUST BE MADE AVAILABLE AS LONG TERM HOUSING.
00:27:38 >> THE ILO PROGRAM IS CRITICAL FOR COMMUNITIES CITYWIDE
00:27:42 ESPECIALLY SENSITIVE COMMUNITIES SUCH AS THOSE
00:27:43 AROUND THE POTRERO POWER STATION.
00:27:46 >> SUPERVISORS WE STRONGLY URGE YOU NOT TO UNDERMINE THE ILO
00:27:49 PROGRAM. >> THANK YOU.
00:27:50 THANK YOU FOR YOUR COMMENTS. NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE.
00:27:53 GOOD AFTERNOON BILL BLACKWELL A LOCAL 38 PLUMBERS AND PIPE
00:27:58 FITTERS THE PARISH'S POWER STATION HAS DELIVERED ON EVERY
00:28:01 COMMITMENT THEY HAVE MADE TO BLUE COLLAR WORKERS AND TO THE
00:28:05 COMMUNITY SINCE THE SITE WAS PURCHASED IN 2016.
00:28:08 THE PROJECT TEAM HAS MADE LISTENING TO THE COMMUNITY
00:28:12 AND LABOR STAKEHOLDERS A TOP PRIORITY.
00:28:13 WE SEE AN OPPORTUNITY TO CONTINUE THAT PROGRESS BEING
00:28:16 MADE THERE WORKFORCE HOUSING JOB TRAINING AND LOCAL
00:28:19 CONTRACTOR PARTICIPATION HAS BEEN KEY TO MAKING THIS SITE A
00:28:23 SUCCESS. NOW SOME CHANGES AND SOME
00:28:24 CHANGES NEED TO BE MADE TO CONTINUE MOMENTUM.
00:28:27 THE AMENDMENTS BEFORE YOU ALLOW SOME CHANGES TO BE MADE DEALING
00:28:31 WITH HEIGHT, HOUSING AND COMMERCIAL USE.
00:28:32 THE ECONOMY IS UNSTABLE AND THE INVESTMENT IN SAN FRANCISCO HAS
00:28:35 BEEN LACKING SINCE THE COVID SHUTDOWN.
00:28:38 WHAT IS STABLE AND CERTAIN IS THE PROJECTS COMMITMENT TO
00:28:42 DELIVER GOOD JOBS HOUSING INFRASTRUCTURE THAT IS NEEDED
00:28:46 TO REINVEST IN DOGPATCH AND IN THE SAN FRANCISCO.
00:28:50 >> THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME. THANK YOU FOR YOUR COMMENTS.
00:28:51 NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE. >> HELLO.
00:28:54 GOOD AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS SELENA ESKRIDGE,
00:28:58 EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE HOMELESS PRENATAL PROGRAM.
00:29:01 >> BUT I AM NOT ONLY THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR.
00:29:02 I AM ALSO LIVING PROOF THAT OUR PROGRAM WORKS.
00:29:05 MANY DECADES AGO MY MOTHER USED HOMELESS PRENATAL PROGRAM
00:29:08 SERVICES AT A CRITICAL TIME IN HER LIFE AND IT CHANGED THE
00:29:12 TRAJECTORY OF HER LIFE AND MINE.
00:29:13 >> I SHARE THAT STORY TO TELL YOU THAT FIRSTHAND.
00:29:17 I KNOW THAT TIME MATTERS AND PROVIDING SUPPORT FOR A
00:29:20 FAMILY THROUGH A CRITICAL TIME IN THEIR LIFE IS IMPORTANT.
00:29:24 >> AND SO I COME HERE TODAY TO TELL YOU THAT EVERY MONTH
00:29:28 AFFORDABLE HOUSING SITS IS A PART AS A PROMISE ON A PAPER.
00:29:33 IT IS A TIME THAT A FRONT DOOR A FAMILY CANNOT WALK THROUGH IS
00:29:37 A MONTH THAT A CHILD SPENDS WITHOUT A TRUE FOUNDATION.
00:29:43 I KNOW THAT BECAUSE A HOMELESS PRENATAL PROGRAM HAS A BUILDING
00:29:47 2530 18TH STREET THAT WE'VE HAD SINCE 2020 THAT WE CANNOT GET
00:29:51 BUILT. BUT I'VE SEEN POWER STATION BE
00:29:54 BUILT AND HOUSED SIX OF HOMELESS PRENATAL PROGRAMS
00:29:58 FAMILIES AND THROUGH THE DELIVERY OF THOSE SERVICES I
00:30:01 KNOW THAT THEY CAN DO MUCH MORE .
00:30:04 THIS PROJECT IS NOT JUST HOUSING IT'S SEVEN ACRES OF
00:30:07 PARKS, HEALTH CARE, AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND A FAMILY NEEDS MUCH
00:30:12 MORE. THEY NEED A DOCTOR NEARBY.
00:30:15 >> THEY NEED PARKS FOR KIDS. THEY NEED THEIR NEIGHBORS.
00:30:19 THEY NEED A COMMUNITY. AND I KNOW THAT THEY CAN DO
00:30:21 THIS. >> I JUST URGE YOU ALL TO SEND
00:30:26 THIS TO THE FULL BOARD. >> THANK YOU.
00:30:27 THANK YOU FOR YOUR COMMENTS. >> SO THE NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE.
00:30:33 THANK YOU. SUPERVISOR CHEN, SUPERVISOR
00:30:34 WALTON AND DORSEY AS WELL. I'M JAMIE BREEN MYLES,
00:30:37 PRESIDENT CEO OF THE YMCA GREATER SAN FRANCISCO.
00:30:40 AND I'M SPEAKING SPECIFICALLY TO THE FLEXIBILITY THAT CHILD
00:30:42 CARE AND COMMUNITY SPACES AND THE PROPOSAL FOR THE Y.
00:30:45 THIS HAS NEVER BEEN ABOUT BUILDINGS.
00:30:47 IT'S ABOUT CREATING PLACES WHERE CHILDREN, FAMILIES
00:30:49 AND NEIGHBORS CAN GROW, CONNECT AND KNOW THEY BELONG.
00:30:53 THIS WHAT DREW US TO OUR PARTNERSHIP THIS SPACE
00:30:56 BEGINNING WITH OUR WORK TOGETHER AT CRINKLE AND THE
00:30:57 DOGPATCH Y WE'VE ALWAYS SEEN WHAT A THIS IS A PARTNERSHIP
00:31:00 CAN MAKE POSSIBLE. THIS IS JUST NOT A PROMISE FOR
00:31:04 THE FUTURE. WE'RE SEEING IT HAPPEN TODAY.
00:31:07 WHAT'S IMPORTANT TO US ABOUT THESE AMENDMENTS IS A
00:31:08 FLEXIBILITY TO PROVIDE AROUND LOCATION OF CHILDCARE
00:31:12 AND COMMUNITY FACILITIES FOR INNOVATION LIKE THE YMCA.
00:31:15 THAT FLEXIBILITY MATTERS. IT GIVES US AN OPPORTUNITY TO
00:31:17 PUT PROGRAMS AND SERVICES WHERE FAMILIES CAN ACCESS THEM, WHERE
00:31:20 THEY CAN HAVE THE GREATEST IMPACT RATHER SIMPLY THAN WERE
00:31:23 RIGID REQUIREMENTS SAY THEY MUST GO AT THE SAME TIME
00:31:27 FLEXIBILITY MUST CONTINUE TO LIE AN UNDERLINING COMMITMENT
00:31:30 TO CHILDREN, FAMILY AND COMMUNITY RIGHTS RATHER ON
00:31:34 BECAUSE A NEIGHBORHOOD DOES NOT BECOME A COMMUNITY SIMPLY
00:31:36 BECAUSE WE BUILD BUILDINGS. COMMUNITY HAPPENS WHEN KIDS
00:31:39 HAVE SOMEWHERE TO PLAY. PARENTS HAVE SOMEWHERE THEY
00:31:42 TRUST IN NEIGHBORS OF PLACES WHERE THEY CAN GO TOGETHER.
00:31:43 THE PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDED APPROVAL OF THESE
00:31:46 AMENDMENTS ON JULY 30TH. THE YMCA SUPPORTS MOVING THEM
00:31:49 FORWARD. WE RESPECTFULLY ASK THE
00:31:50 COMMITTEE TO RECOMMEND APPROVAL TO THE FULL BOARD SO THAT WE
00:31:53 CAN CONTINUE BUILDING A NEIGHBORHOOD WHERE EVERY FILM
00:31:57 ME A PLACE TO BELONG. >> THANK YOU.
00:31:58 THANK YOU FOR COMMENTS. NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE.
00:32:03 GOOD AFTERNOON SUPERVISORS. MY NAME IS RASHID NAIROBI
00:32:07 AND I'M THE DIRECTOR OF AN ORGANIZATION CALLED SISTERS
00:32:08 WITH TOOLS. I JUST WANT TO REMIND US KIND
00:32:11 OF GET A POWER CHECK IN OF WHO WE ARE ON THAT SITE.
00:32:14 >> AND I THINK IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT FOR US TO UNDERSTAND
00:32:18 THE IMPACT THAT IS BEING MADE ON THE POWER STATION.
00:32:22 DEVELOPMENT IS NOT JUST ABOUT BUILDING BUILDINGS BUT IS
00:32:23 LITERALLY ABOUT BUILDING LIVES. IT GIVES BLACK AND LATINA
00:32:27 AND OTHER WOMEN AN OPPORTUNITY TO LEARN HOW TO BE CONSTRUCTION
00:32:31 WORKERS AND ACTUALLY GO TO WORK ON THAT SITE.
00:32:34 SO I DON'T WANT US TO LOSE THAT SIGHT.
00:32:38 THE THING THAT'S REALLY IMPORTANT TO US IS THAT WHAT WE
00:32:41 KNOW ABOUT COMMUNITIES IS IF YOU GIVE A WOMAN A CHANCE TO
00:32:46 GET A LEG UP, SHE BRINGS THE COMMUNITY THAT STANDS BEHIND
00:32:49 HER WITH. SO AGAIN I'M PLEADING WITH YOU
00:32:52 TO REALLY THINK ABOUT THE IMPACT OF THE WOMEN AND THE MEN
00:32:57 BUT PREDOMINANTLY THE WOMEN BECAUSE THIS IS THE FIRST TIME
00:32:58 WE HAVE HAD THAT OPPORTUNITY IN THIS CITY TO WORK ON AN
00:33:01 ACTIVE SITE AND ACTUALLY BRING THOSE JOBS HOME TO OUR FAMILIES
00:33:08 AND TO OUR COMMUNITIES. >> THANK YOU.
00:33:09 THANK YOU FOR YOUR COMMENTS. >> NEXT SPEAKER, PLEASE.
00:33:18 >> LITTLE SUPERVISORS. MY NAME IS BRUCE HUEY.
00:33:19 I'M A RESIDENT AND SMALL BUSINESS OWNER IN THE DOGPATCH
00:33:23 NEIGHBORHOOD. MY PAST COMMUNITY ACTIVITIES
00:33:25 INCLUDE PRESIDENT OF THE DOGPATCH NEIGHBORHOOD
00:33:27 ASSOCIATION FOUNDING MEMBER OF THE DOGPATCH AND NORTHWEST
00:33:30 PORTERVILLE GREEN VELVET DISTRICT BOARD MEMBER OF THE
00:33:33 DOGPATCH COMMUNITY CENTER HUB AND CURRENTLY A BOARD MEMBER AT
00:33:38 THE DOGPATCH ART AND BUSINESS ASSOCIATION.
00:33:40 I'VE WATCHED DOGPATCH GO FROM A QUIET INDUSTRIAL NEIGHBORHOOD
00:33:42 OVER THE PAST FEW YEARS MORE HOUSING DELIVERED SOONER
00:33:49 THROUGH THE ADDITIONAL INTERMEDIATE LENGTH OXIMETRY
00:33:53 UNITS MEANS MORE NEIGHBORS WALKING PAST OUR DOORS, EATING
00:33:56 AT OUR RESTAURANTS AND SHOPPING AT OUR STORES A THRIVING POWER
00:34:00 STATION DOES COMPETE DOES NOT COMPETE WITH THE DOGPATCH
00:34:04 EXISTING BUSINESS CORRIDOR ON THIRD STREET.
00:34:05 IT FEEDS IT. DOGPATCH HAS ALWAYS BEEN A
00:34:09 NEIGHBORHOOD THAT MAKES THINGS ART, FOOD, COMMUNITY AND THESE
00:34:15 CHANGES HELP MAKE SURE THAT THE SPIRIT HAS ROOM TO GROW
00:34:19 ALONGSIDE THE NEW DEVELOPMENT INSTEAD OF GETTING BOXED OUT BY
00:34:23 RULES WRITTEN BY A DIFFERENT MARKET.
00:34:24 WITH THE PLANNING COMMISSION APPROVAL OF THESE AMENDMENTS ON
00:34:27 JULY 30TH I ASKED YOUR COMMITTEE RECOMMEND
00:34:30 AND APPROVAL AT THE FULL BOARD SO OUR DOGPATCH NEIGHBORHOOD
00:34:32 BUSINESSES CONTINUE TO GROW WITH ADDITIONAL FUTURE
00:34:35 NEIGHBORS FROM THE POWER STATION.
00:34:36 THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU FOR YOUR COMMENTS.
00:34:39 SO THE NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE. AND THEN IF WE HAVE ANY FURTHER
00:34:42 SPEAKERS AFTER THIS ONE WHO WANT TO PROVIDE PUBLIC COMMENT
00:34:45 ON AGENDA ITEM NUMBERS TWO AND THREE FROM WHOM WE HAVE NOT
00:34:47 YET HEARD YOU MAY LINE UP TO SPEAK ALONG THAT WESTERN WALL.
00:34:51 GOOD AFTERNOON. THIS IS I'M ELAINE SPRAGUE
00:34:53 STUBING I'M THE PRESIDENT OF FRIENDS OF JACKSON PARK.
00:34:55 I'M ALSO A 24 YEAR RESIDENT OF PETRO HILL AND HAVE BEEN
00:35:02 BUILDING COMMUNITY THAT ENTIRE TIME.
00:35:03 I JUST WANT TO KNOW HAVE YOU THINK ABOUT ALL OF THESE
00:35:07 COMMENTS TO REALLY SHOW YOU THAT THE PETRO POWER STATION IS
00:35:14 MORE THAN JUST DEVELOPMENT. THEY ARE COMMUNITY MINDED
00:35:15 DEVELOPERS AND THAT IS WHY I'M HERE TO HAVE THE PLANNING
00:35:22 COMMISSION APPROVE OR BRING THE FULL BOARD APPROVAL FOR PARKS
00:35:29 AND OPEN SPACE. >> OUR COMMITTEE AND OUR
00:35:33 COMMUNITY IS THE CENTER OF THE CITY'S INNOVATION AND INDUSTRY
00:35:40 AND POPULATION GROWTH AND JUST THE HISTORY OF PETRO POWER
00:35:44 STATION IN THIS AREA IT'S REALLY DRIVING THAT.
00:35:46 SO THIS IS ALSO AN EXAMPLE THIS MEETING OF THAT KIND OF
00:35:49 PARTNERSHIP WHERE WE'RE LISTENING TO EACH OTHER TO GET
00:35:52 ALL OF THESE THINGS DONE. OBVIOUSLY HOMELESS PRENATAL
00:35:56 AFFORDABLE HOUSING, TRANSPORTATION IT'S A PERFECT
00:36:00 EXAMPLE OF HOW THE FAMILY ZONING PLAN SHOULD WORK IN THIS
00:36:05 ENTIRE CITY AND BEYOND. >> SO THESE AMENDMENTS WILL
00:36:08 HELP THE FLEXIBILITY OF SEQUENCING PARK DELIVERY WHICH
00:36:15 IS WHAT I'M ALL ABOUT THESE PRACTICAL CHANGES WILL KEEP
00:36:20 THIS PROJECT'S COMMITMENT TO OPEN SPACE INTACT.
00:36:23 >> THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME. >> THANK YOU FOR YOUR COMMENTS.
00:36:28 DO WE HAVE ANYONE ELSE FOR PUBLIC COMMENT FOR AGENDA ITEM
00:36:29 NUMBERS TWO AND THREE MADAM CHAIR, IF YOU HAVE NO FURTHER
00:36:34 SPEAKERS GREAT. >> THANK YOU MR. CARR PUBLIC
00:36:37 COMMENT IS NOW CLOSE SUMMARIZE WALTON THANK YOU SO MUCH CHAIR
00:36:42 CHIN AND I WANT TO THANK THE PUBLIC FOR COMING OUT THIS
00:36:45 AFTERNOON. >> I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT THAT
00:36:49 WE ALL REMEMBER THAT CHANGES TO DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENTS ARE NOT
00:36:53 JUST SMALL AND THAT MINISTERIAL AND IT'S IMPORTANT TO MAKE SURE
00:36:57 THAT THEY ARE FOR THE BENEFIT OF THE COMMUNITY AND FOR THE
00:37:01 NEIGHBORHOODS. >> I DO FEEL IN THIS CASE THEY
00:37:05 ARE NECESSARY FOR THAT MAXIMUM BENEFIT BUT I ALSO WANT US TO
00:37:09 REMEMBER THAT WORDS DO MATTER IN DOCUMENTS AND WE NEED TO
00:37:13 MAKE SURE THAT WHEN WE PREPARE DOCUMENTS, PARTICULARLY
00:37:16 DOCUMENTS THAT ARE GOING TO AFFECT THE COMMUNITY FOR
00:37:20 OBVIOUSLY THE THE ENTIRE FUTURE THAT WE DO GET THEM RIGHT
00:37:27 AND TRY TO GET THEM RIGHT THE FIRST TIME.
00:37:30 BUT I DO APPRECIATE EVERYONE WORKING TOGETHER AND SO I MOVE
00:37:33 TO ACCEPT THE AMENDMENTS AS SUBMITTED BY THE DEPARTMENTS
00:37:37 FOR THESE ITEMS HEARING TWO MOTIONS EACH OF THEM OFFERED BY
00:37:41 SUPERVISOR WALTON THAT EACH OF THE TWO ORDINANCES BE AMENDED
00:37:45 AS PRESENTED ON THOSE ON THAT MOTION EACH OF THEM MEMBER
00:37:52 WALTON WALTON I REMEMBER DORSEY DORSEY I VICE CHAIR CHIN CHIN I
00:37:59 MADAM CHAIR THERE ARE THREE EYES ON THE AMENDMENTS.
00:38:02 >> THE MOTION TO AMEND PASSES SO THANK YOU CHAIR CHAN AND I
00:38:10 MOVE THAT WE CONTINUE THESE ITEMS TO THE MONDAY SEPTEMBER
00:38:14 28TH 2026 LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
00:38:18 MEETING ON THE MOTION OFFERED BY MEMBER WALTON THAT BOTH
00:38:22 ORDINANCES BE CONTINUED AS AMENDED FOR CONSIDERATION BY
00:38:23 THIS COMMITTEE ON SEPTEMBER 28TH 2026.
00:38:26 ON THAT MOTION VICE CHAIR I'M SORRY MEMBER WALTON WALTON I
00:38:30 REMEMBER DORSEY DORSEY I FACE CHURCH AND I CHAIR AND VICE
00:38:34 CHAIR THERE ARE THREE EYES. >> THANK YOU.
00:38:38 THE MOTION PASSES. MR. CLERK PLEASE CALL ITEM
00:38:41 NUMBER FOUR THE AGENDA ITEM NUMBER FOUR IS AN ORDINANCE
00:38:47 TAKING VARIOUS ACTIONS RELATED TO THE TRANSBAY UNDER RENT PARK
00:38:50 PROJECT INCLUDING AFFIRMING THE TERMINATION OF THE OFFICE OF
00:38:54 COMMUNITY INVESTMENT AND INFRASTRUCTURE UNDER THE
00:38:55 CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT RELATED TO THE
00:38:58 ACTIONS IN THE ORDINANCE ORDERING THE SUMMARY STREET
00:39:01 VACATION OF PORTIONS OF OSCAR ALLEY BOUNDED BY TEHAMA
00:39:02 CLEMENTINA FIRST AND SECOND STREETS THAT WERE NOT
00:39:06 PREVIOUSLY VACATED. FINDING THE STREET VACATION
00:39:09 AREA IS NOT NECESSARY FOR THE CITY'S USE AND IS EXEMPT
00:39:11 SURPLUS PROPERTY UNDER THE CALIFORNIA SURPLUS LAND ACT
00:39:14 QUIT CLAIMING THE CITY'S INTEREST IN THE STREET VACATION
00:39:18 AREA TO THE TRANSBAY JOINT POWERS AUTHORITY FOR A NOMINAL
00:39:21 FEE WAIVING THE APPRAISAL REQUIREMENT OF ADMINISTRATIVE
00:39:25 CODE CHAPTER 23 IN CONNECTION WITH THE CONVEYANCE OF THE
00:39:27 STREET VACATION AREA AMENDING ORDINANCE NUMBER 1061 ENTITLED
00:39:32 REGULATING THE WIDTH OF SIDEWALKS TO NARROW THE
00:39:33 SIDEWALK WIDTHS ON FOLSOM STREET BETWEEN ESSEX AND SECOND
00:39:37 STREETS AND ON CLEMENTINA STREET BETWEEN FIRST AND SECOND
00:39:40 MAKING FINDINGS OF CONSISTENCY WITH THE GENERAL PLAN AND THE
00:39:44 EIGHT PRIORITY POLICIES THE PLANNING CODE SECTION 121.1 FOR
00:39:47 THE STREET VACATION AND SIDEWALK WIDTH CHANGES
00:39:50 CONDITIONALLY ACCEPTING A PUBLIC SIDEWALK EASEMENT
00:39:51 GRANTED BY THE JPA FOR AN AREA ADJACENT TO THE CLEMENTINA
00:39:55 SIDEWALK NARROWING TO ALLOW FOR CONTINUATION OF THE PATH OF
00:39:59 TRAVEL, ACCEPTING IRREVOCABLE OFFERS OF IMPROVEMENTS FOR
00:40:05 TRAFFIC SIGNAL INFRASTRUCTURE AT THE INTERSECTION OF FIRST
00:40:08 AND CLEMENTINA STREETS ACCEPTING THE INFRASTRUCTURE AS
00:40:12 A PUBLIC IMPROVEMENT FOR CITY MAINTENANCE AND LIABILITY
00:40:13 PURPOSES AND AUTHORIZING OFFICIAL ACTS IN CONNECTION
00:40:16 WITH THE ORDINANCE AS DEFINED WITHIN THE ORDINANCE AND MADAM
00:40:20 VICE CHAIR, WE ARE IN RECEIPT OF A MEMO FROM THE DESK OF THE
00:40:21 CHAIR REQUESTING THAT THIS MATTER BE AGENDAS AS A
00:40:25 COMMITTEE REPORT THIS ITEM MAY BE SENT FOR CONSIDERATION BY
00:40:28 THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS ON THE COMMITTEE REPORT AGENDA
00:40:29 TOMORROW SEPTEMBER 22ND, 2026. >> GREAT.
00:40:33 THANK YOU MR. CLERK. THIS ITEM WAS ALSO CONTINUE
00:40:37 FROM LAST WITH FOUR SUBSTANTIVE AMENDMENTS AND WITH THAT
00:40:43 SUPERVISOR DORSEY GREAT THANK YOU VICE CHAIR CHEN AS YOU
00:40:47 MENTIONED WE HEARD THIS LAST WEEK AND HAD TO CONTINUE IT
00:40:49 TODAY IS MEETING AFTER SOME MINOR TECHNICAL BUT STILL
00:40:52 LEGALLY SUBSTANTIVE AMENDMENTS STAFF IS NOT PLANNING TO
00:40:55 PRESENT TODAY AND I HAVE NOTHING TO ASK TO ADD BEYOND
00:41:00 WHAT WE ALREADY PRESENTED IN LAST WEEK'S MEETING.
00:41:03 OBVIOUSLY UNLESS MEMBERS HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OF ME OF COURSE
00:41:06 I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER THEM BUT AFTER PUBLIC COMMENT I WILL
00:41:09 MAKE A MOTION TO SEND THIS ITEM TO THE FULL BOARD AS A
00:41:11 COMMITTEE REPORT. THANK YOU MR. CLERK.
00:41:17 >> WHAT CAN WE GO TO PUBLIC COMMENTS THANK YOU, MADAM VICE
00:41:21 CHAIR. LAND USE AND TRANSPORTATION
00:41:22 WILL NOW HEAR PUBLIC COMMENT RELATED TO AGENDA ITEM NUMBER
00:41:24 FOUR IF YOU HAVE PUBLIC COMMENT FOR THIS ITEM PLEASE COME
00:41:26 FORWARD AT THIS TIME IT APPEARS WE HAVE NO SPEAKERS.
00:41:28 >> PUBLIC COMMENT IS NOW CLOSED.
00:41:31 >> SUPERVISOR DORSEY THANK YOU VICE CHAIR CHEN AT THIS TIME I
00:41:35 WOULD MOVE TO SEND THIS ITEM TO THE FULL BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
00:41:37 AS A COMMITTEE REPORT ON THE MOTION OFFERED BY MEMBER DORSEY
00:41:42 THAT THE ORDINANCE BE RECOMMENDED AS A COMMITTEE
00:41:44 REPORT MEMBER WALTON WALTON I REMEMBER DORSEY HIGH DORSEY I
00:41:47 VICE CHAIR CHEN I CHEN I MEANT OPPOSED TO OTHER THREE EYES
00:41:51 THANK YOU THE MOTION PASSES MR. CLERK IS THERE ANY MORE
00:41:55 BUSINESS BEFORE US TODAY? >> THERE'S NO FURTHER BUSINESS.
00:41:59 THANK YOU. THE MEETING IS NOW A JOIN