00:00:09 AND GOOD MORNING EVERYONE AND WELCOME TO THE OCTOBER 5TH,
00:00:12 2026 RULES COMMITTEE MEETING. >> I AM YOUR CHAIR SUPERVISOR
00:00:16 SIMON WALTON I'M JOINED HERE BY VICE CHAIR SHELL AND WILL SOON
00:00:20 BE JOINED BY PRESIDENT MANDO MIN.
00:00:24 THIS MORNING'S CLERK TODAY IS VICTOR YOUNG AND I WANT TO
00:00:28 THANK SUSAN ENOS FOR MAKING SURE THAT THIS MEETING IS
00:00:35 TELEVISED AND THAT THE TRANSCRIPTS ARE MADE AVAILABLE
00:00:38 TO THE PUBLIC. >> MR. CLERK, DO WE HAVE ANY
00:00:41 ANNOUNCEMENTS THIS MORNING? >> YES, PUBLIC COMMENT WILL BE
00:00:43 TAKEN AND EACH ITEM ON THIS AGENDA WHEN YOUR ITEM OF
00:00:47 INTEREST COMES UP AND PUBLIC COMMENT IS CALLED PLEASE LINE
00:00:50 UP TO SPEAK. ALTERNATIVELY MAY SUBMIT PUBLIC
00:00:51 COMMENT IN WRITING IN EITHER OF THE FOLLOWING WAYS EMAIL THEM
00:00:55 TO MYSELF THE RULES COMMITTEE CLERK AND TO YOUR DOT Y O U
00:00:59 AND G AT S.F. GOV DAWG IF YOU SUBMIT PUBLIC COMMENT BY EMAIL
00:01:06 IT WILL BE INCLUDED AS PART OF THE FILE.
00:01:07 YOU MAY ALSO SEND YOUR WRITTEN COMMENTS FOR US MAIL TO OUR
00:01:10 OFFICE IN CITY HALL ONE DR. CARLTON BE GOOD PLACE ROOM 244
00:01:14 SAN FRANCISCO CALIFORNIA 94102 PLEASE MAKE SURE TO SILENT ALL
00:01:20 CELL PHONES AND ELECTRONIC DEVICES.
00:01:23 ITEMS ACTED UPON TODAY ARE EXPECTED TO APPEAR ON THE BOARD
00:01:24 OF SUPERVISORS AGENDA OF OCTOBER 20TH UNLESS OTHERWISE
00:01:28 STATED. THAT COMPLETES MY INITIAL
00:01:31 ANNOUNCEMENTS. >> THANK YOU SO MUCH.
00:01:32 WOULD YOU PLEASE CALL ITEM NUMBER ONE?
00:01:38 ITEM NUMBER ONE IS A MOTION APPROVING REJECTING THE CITY
00:01:42 COMPTROLLER GREG WAGNER'S NOMINATION FOR THE APPOINTMENT
00:01:45 OF ANTHONY RIVERA TO THE PUBLIC WORKS COMMISSION TERM ENDING
00:01:49 JULY 2ND, 2028. >> THANK YOU SO MUCH MR. CLERK
00:01:53 AND I BELIEVE MR. RIVERA IS HERE WITH US THIS MORNING
00:01:57 AND WHY DON'T YOU COME UP TELL US A LITTLE BIT ABOUT YOURSELF
00:02:00 AND WHY YOU WANT TO SERVE. GOOD MORNING SUPERVISORS.
00:02:04 MY NAME'S ANTHONY RIVERA. I'M A BORN AND RAISED HERE
00:02:08 IN SAN FRANCISCO. I'M A RETIRED FROM SAN
00:02:12 FRANCISCO FIRE DEPARTMENT. >> OVER 28 YEARS I ALSO WORKED
00:02:16 AS A LIAISON ON TO PUBLIC WORKS PUC.
00:02:20 I SERVED AS A COMMISSIONER ON PUC AND JUST AS A CITIZEN I
00:02:27 WOULD LOVE TO SERVE ON THIS BOARD TO MAINTAIN TRANSPARENCY
00:02:32 ,EFFICIENCY AND ENSURE THAT A LOT OF THE THE WORK
00:02:37 AND INFRASTRUCTURE THAT'S GOING ON IN THE CITY IS DONE IN A
00:02:41 PROPER MANNER. I'M ALWAYS TAKEN INTO THE
00:02:44 INTERESTS OF THE CITIZENS OF OUR CITY.
00:02:47 THANK YOU SO MUCH, MR. RIVERA. I DON'T SEE ANY QUESTIONS OR
00:02:51 COMMENTS FROM COLLEAGUES SO WE WILL GO TO PUBLIC COMMENT ON
00:02:53 THIS ITEM. >> YES, MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC
00:02:56 WHO WISH TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM SIGNED UP TO SPEAK AT THIS
00:02:59 TIME. EACH SPEAKER WILL BE ALLOWED
00:03:00 TWO MINUTES. ARE THERE ANY MEMBERS OF THE
00:03:03 PUBLIC WHO WOULD LIKE TO COMMENT ON THIS MATTER?
00:03:04 THERE ARE NO COMMENTERS ON THIS MATTER.
00:03:07 >> THANK YOU SO MUCH. VICE-CHAIR SURE, I BELIEVE YOU
00:03:10 HAVE A MOTION TO MAKE. >> YES, SORRY ABOUT THAT.
00:03:18 >> ACTUALLY ONE QUICK QUESTION. YES SIR.
00:03:24 >> YOUR EXPERIENCE IN THE FIRE DEPARTMENT AND THE INTERACTION
00:03:27 WITH THE STREETSCAPE. >> HOW HOW DO YOU SEE YOUR KIND
00:03:35 OF YOUR EXPERIENCE IN IN ACCESSING THE CURBSIDE ACTIONS
00:03:39 IN THE ROADSIDE AS A AS A MEMBER OF THE FIRE DEPARTMENT
00:03:41 INFLUENCING YOUR WORK ON PUBLIC WORKS IN A WAY THAT THEY MAY
00:03:47 LOOK AT CURB CUTS OR STREETSCAPE IMPROVEMENTS OR ANY
00:03:48 OTHER ITEMS LIKE THAT? >> YES, SIR.
00:03:51 SO I THINK I HAVE A UNIQUE PERSPECTIVE WHEREAS YOU KNOW, I
00:03:58 THINK THAT THERE'S PUBLIC ACCESS.
00:04:02 THERE'S YOU KNOW, MERCHANT ACCESS, COMMERCIAL ACCESS.
00:04:05 BUT PUBLIC SAFETY IS NUMBER ONE.
00:04:06 AND I THINK THAT WE DO NEED TO HAVE ACCESS FOR EMERGENCY
00:04:10 VEHICLES. YOU KNOW, OUR OUR CITY IS SET
00:04:16 UP PAYABLE TO EARTHQUAKES, LARGE FIRES, ETC. AND WE NEED
00:04:20 TO BE ABLE TO HAVE THE ABILITY TO ACCESS AREAS WHERE WE HAVE
00:04:25 FOR EXAMPLE, LARGE GATHERINGS OR MAYBE LARGE APARTMENT
00:04:29 BUILDINGS. >> AND SO IN MY OPINION I THINK
00:04:32 THAT THAT HAS TO BE TAKEN INTO CONSIDERATION WHEN IMPLEMENTING
00:04:36 THESE PROCEDURES. >> ALL RIGHT.
00:04:40 THANK YOU. I APPRECIATE THAT FEATURE.
00:04:41 I'D LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION STRAIGHT STRIKING, REJECTING
00:04:47 AND KEEPING APPROVING MR. RIVERA'S NOMINATION TO MAKE A
00:04:59 MOTION APPROVING MR. MR. RIVERA'S NOMINATION STRIKING
00:05:00 REJECTING. >> THANK YOU SO MUCH.
00:05:03 >> VICE-CHAIR SURE, MR. CLERK ON THE MOTION YES ON A MOTION
00:05:06 TO AMEND THE MOTION TO APPROVE THE NOMINATION AND TO RECOMMEND
00:05:10 IT TO THE BOARD AS AS AMENDED ON THAT MOTION.
00:05:14 VICE CHAIR CHERYL. HI CHERYL.
00:05:15 I REMEMBER IN HIGH MANAGEMENT I CHAIR WALTON HIGH WALTON I.
00:05:22 >> THAT MOTION PASSES WITHOUT OBJECTION.
00:05:23 THANK YOU. MOTION CARRIES.
00:05:25 CONGRATULATIONS, MR. CLERK. PLEASE CALL OUT A NUMBER TWO.
00:05:28 >> ITEM NUMBER TWO IS A HEARING TO CONSIDER APPOINTING TWO
00:05:33 MEMBERS TERM ENDING JULY 1ST, 2027 AND TWO MEMBERS TERMS
00:05:37 ENDING JULY 1ST, 2028. TO CHILDREN, YOUTH AND FAMILIES
00:05:41 OVERSIGHT AND ADVISORY COMMITTEE.
00:05:43 >> THANK YOU SO MUCH MR. CLERK AND I DON'T BELIEVE I SEE OUR
00:05:48 CANDIDATE HERE THIS MORNING. >> I DO NOT SEE HER.
00:05:52 I DID RECEIVE AN EMAIL FROM THE CANDIDATE ON FRIDAY STATING
00:05:55 THAT THEY WOULD BE HERE IN PERSON.
00:05:56 >> THANK YOU SO MUCH. WELL LET'S GO TO PUBLIC COMMENT
00:06:00 ON THIS ITEM BEFORE I MAKE A MOTION TO CONTINUE.
00:06:03 YES, OUR MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC WISH TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM
00:06:07 SHALL LINE UP TO SPEAK AT THIS TIME EACH SPEAKER WILL BE
00:06:09 ALLOWED TWO MINUTES. ARE THERE ANY MEMBERS OF THE
00:06:11 PUBLIC RIGHT TO COMMENT ON THIS MATTER?
00:06:13 >> THERE ARE NO SPEAKERS ON THIS MATTER.
00:06:14 THANK YOU. >> SENIOR SPEAKERS PUBLIC
00:06:17 COMMENT ON ITEM NUMBER TWO IS CLOSED AND I LIKE TO MAKE A
00:06:21 MOTION TO. >> CAN YOU CONTINUE THIS ITEM
00:06:22 TO THE CALL? THE CHAIR YES ON THAT MOTION TO
00:06:29 CONTINUE THE MATTER TO THE CALL OF THE CHAIR VICE CHAIR CHERYL
00:06:33 CHERYL I REMEMBER MANAGEMENT MADAM AND I CHAIR WALTON I WILL
00:06:37 DENY THAT MOTION IS APPROVED WITHOUT OBJECTION.
00:06:41 >> THANK YOU. MOTION CARRIES.
00:06:41 MR. CLERK, PLEASE CALL ITEM NUMBER THREE.
00:06:45 >> ITEM NUMBER THREE IS ORDINANCE APPROVING THE
00:06:46 SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY POLICY. GOVERNING THE USE OF SOCIAL
00:06:49 MEDIA MONITORING SOFTWARE FOR THE FIRE DEPARTMENT.
00:06:52 >> THANK YOU SO MUCH. AND I BELIEVE WE HAVE MR. MARK
00:06:56 CORSO HERE FOR THIS ITEM WITH THIS.
00:07:02 >> GOOD MORNING SUPERVISORS MARK CORSO AT THE FIRE
00:07:06 DEPARTMENT HERE TO SPEAK ON THE NEXT ITEM WHICH IS A SOCIAL
00:07:10 MEDIA PULSE MONITORING POLICY AS PER THE SURVEILLANCE
00:07:13 TECHNOLOGY LEGISLATION. APOLOGIES AND GETTING THIS
00:07:18 THROUGH. THIS WAS APPROVED BY QUITE A
00:07:19 LITTLE WHILE AGO AND NEVER MADE ITS WAY ALL THE WAY TO THE FULL
00:07:22 BOARD. >> SO WE JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE
00:07:23 THAT'S TAKEN CARE OF. >> THIS IS FOR A SOCIAL MEDIA
00:07:26 MONITORING PLATFORM CALLED CRITICAL MENTION THAT WE USE
00:07:30 ALONG WITH A NUMBER OF OTHER CITY DEPARTMENTS WE USE IT TO.
00:07:34 IT'S MORE OF A MEDIA ANALYTICS PLATFORM.
00:07:37 WE USE IT TO MONITOR SOCIAL MEDIA AS WELL AS NEWS MEDIA FOR
00:07:41 MENTIONS AND STORIES ABOUT THE FIRE DEPARTMENT.
00:07:42 >> WE DO NOT TRACK ANY INDIVIDUALS ON THIS.
00:07:45 THIS IS DONE IN AGGREGATE. WE USE IT TO MONITOR ENGAGEMENT
00:07:49 AMONGST DIFFERENT PLATFORMS AND SEE WHERE OUR MESSAGES
00:07:52 REACHING. WE DO RUN ANALYTICS FOR
00:07:53 REPORTING TO OUR SUPERVISORS AND THE CHIEFS IN THE
00:07:57 DEPARTMENT BUT IT'S NOT ANY INDIVIDUAL DATA.
00:08:01 >> THIS IS ALL PUBLICLY AVAILABLE DATA THAT'S BEEN
00:08:04 POSTED ON WEBSITES OR OTHER SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORMS.
00:08:06 SO WE ARE NOT MONITORING ANYTHING INDIVIDUALLY.
00:08:09 WE CAN DETERMINE BY U AS A PRACTICE AND WE POST
00:08:15 NOTICE IN EACH OF THE CAMERAS WHICH ALSO INFORM PEOPLE OF A
00:08:18 PARTICULAR CAMERA RECORDING ACTIVITY AND I'LL BE GLAD TO
00:08:21 ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS. >> THANK YOU SO MUCH.
00:08:23 DIRECTOR ARTS I DON'T SEE ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS FROM
00:08:26 COLLEAGUES SO LET'S GO TO PUBLIC COMMENT ON THIS ITEM.
00:08:29 YES, MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC WHO WISH TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM SHE
00:08:31 LINE UP TO SPEAK AT THIS TIME EACH SPEAKER WILL BE ALLOWED
00:08:35 TWO MINUTES ARE THE NEW MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC FOR PUBLIC
00:08:37 COMMENT. THERE ARE NO SPEAKERS.
00:08:40 >> THANK YOU SENIOR SPEAKERS PUBLIC COMMENT IS NOW CLOSED
00:08:43 AND I WOULD LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION TO MOVE THIS ITEM
00:08:45 FORWARD TO THE FULL BOARD WITH RECOMMENDATION.
00:08:48 >> YES ON THAT MOTION VICE CHAIR CHERYL.
00:08:52 HI CHERYL. I REMEMBER AMENDMENT AND I MEAN
00:08:56 I CHAIR WALTON I WANT DENY THAT MOTION PASSES WITHOUT OBJECTION
00:08:59 . >> THANK YOU.
00:09:00 MOTION PASSES. THANK YOU DIRECTOR MR. CLERK,
00:09:03 DO WE HAVE ANY MORE BUSINESS HERE BEFORE US?
00:09:04 THAT COMPLETES THE AGENDA FOR TODAY.
00:09:07 >> THANK YOU. WE ARE ADJOURNED